Israeli Supreme Court 311.
(photo credit: REUTERS/FILE)
Four justices were
appointed by the Judicial Selection Committee to the High Court of
Justice Friday morning. The four judges are Tel Aviv law school dean
Prof. Dafna Barak-Erez, Tel Aviv District Court Judge Noam Solberg,
Jerusalem District Court Deputy President Zvi Zilbartel and Tel Aviv
District Court Judge Uri Shohem.
followed disagreements between Surpeme Court President Dorit Beinisch
and committee chair Ya'akov Neeman regarding the appointment of
PM freezes contentious Bar Association Bill
Likud ministers rebel against ‘Bar Association Bill’
The committee approved all the judges unanimously except for Sohlberg, who received eight out of nine votes.
Education Minister Gideon Sa'ar welcomed the appointments, saying the decision validates the new selection method that requires seven out of the nine members to approve new judges.
committee's selection is excellent, balanced and demonstrates for the
second time the success of the new method," Sa'ar said.
National Union MK Uri Ariel, who sits on the selection committee along
with Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee chairman David
Rotem (Israel Beiteinu), expressed satisfaction with the appointment of
the new judges, and dismissed criticism of Neeman's leadership of the
"To my delight four judges were chosen to the Supreme Court...In
contrast to the doubts of many, this committee is run properly under
Neeman; today he proved that," Ariel said.
Uriel said that the committee would convene later this month to choose
the Supreme Court president to replace outgoing Judge Dorit Beinisch.
"I am positive we will continue our good work in the future as well," Ariel said.
Committee chairman MK David Rotem lauded the newly selected judges. "I'm not sure that significant change is needed in the Supreme Court," he said. "The selection made today was of four good, zionist judges who are loyal to the state of Israel and who will lead the Supreme Court to good places."
Likud faction chair MK Ze'ev Elkin also welcomed the committee's appointment, saying "This is a joyous victory of common sense."
Elkin commended Sohlberg as an "excellent judge" that "many tried to discredit because he is a settler that wears a kippa."
Sohlberg is considered a conservative judge.
will continue to work for the sake of varying the makeup up of the
Supreme Court, and again instilling the nation's faith in our judges,"
United Arab List-Ta'al MK Ahemd Tibi expressed
disappointment over the selection of Sohlberg to preside on the Supreme
Court, calling it a "black day for justice an equality - a moral defeat
for the Israeli legal system."
Tibi criticized Sohlberg for
living in a settlement, saying "A settler judge is still a settler that
lives on land stolen from Palestinians."