Opposition demands Netanyahu quit as Right denounces Abbas as 'gang leader'
Netanyahu to Kerry: Palestinian Authority's wild incitement causing wave of terror
Dennis Ross: Susan Rice sees Israel 'more of a problem' than partner
Wave of violence sweeping Israel is 'terrorism,' US says
Low-calorie bread Catch-22
Out and About : Top 10 Things To Do
Oo la la!
Maccabi Tel Aviv out to avenge recent flops as BSL season tips off
Israel on brink of securing spot in Euro 2016 playoff
Oman cancels Israeli windsurfers' visas
Appreciation: The loss of a renaissance man
Israel Radio’s English News faces closure
Iron Dome battery deployed in Beersheba
Iron Dome shoots down Palestinian rocket in skies over southern Israel
Dozens of Palestinians cross into Israel from Gaza; 5 of them arrested
Israel to beef up Border Police presence in mixed Arab-Jewish towns
Liberman considered most capable of curbing Palestinian terrorism, poll finds
IDF shoots dead two Palestinian boys protesting near Gaza border fence
NYC mayor de Blasio to visit Israel, Israeli businessman to foot bill
Edelstein: Romania strong ally in fight against anti-Semitism
Jewish MP in Iran decries ‘destruction of mosques in the Muslim World’
Hebrew education – in Harlem
Report: Russian Jewish leader endorses aid to Assad
Sources: US warns governments, bankers Iran sanctions still in place
Khamenei bans Iran from negotiations with US
Sources: US enforcement of Iran arms embargo slipped during nuclear talks
US measure for Iran victims to get paid before sanctions waived inspired by Shurat Hadin
ISIS vs. al-Qaida: Zawahiri says Baghdadi is not the leader of the Muslim world
'ISIS militants blow up ancient Arch of Triumph in Palmyra'
WATCH: Russian warplanes bomb ISIS targets in Syria
'Russia can't claim to fight ISIS terror, while supporting Assad's terror'
WATCH: Explosion at pro-Kurdish rally in Turkey caught on film
Ankara bombing kills at least 30 at Turkish peace rally
Two alleged Hezbollah associates face arms, money laundering charges in New York court
Barzilai gets medical administration degree recognition
How to cope with holiday’s excess calories and winter’s illnesses
Health scan: Israeli physicians slowly warming to medical marijuana
Still too soon to determine production potential of Golan Heights oil
Ness Ziona residents threaten to sue Rehovot for raw sewage flow
Burgeoning alternative fuel firms in Israel grow fivefold in less than three years
IN PICTURES: 1,500 eagles pass over Israel on migration route
Israeli parking app, coming to a university near you
Tech talk: Battle Hacks are back
Facebook pegs Israeli satellite to provide African Internet
Israel to host first international 'Under 30' Forbes Summit
Moody’s keeps Israel rating stable
United Airlines to launch non-stop Tel Aviv-San Francisco route
Grapevine: Mission Accomplished
This week in 60 seconds: Terror hits Israel
Grapevine: Labor of love
A faintly Jewish echo
Love, heartbreak, and a brooch – circa 1994
Jerusalem Post Editorial: PA spreadsheets
Status quo vadis?
Palestinians want hope, not just cycles of revenge
Letters to the Editor: Common denominator
Flight of the Black Tulip: The Russians in Syria
Who is a hero?
The diplomacy profession
Coexistence in a cone
2016 Budget: Not just numbers
The good doctor’s advice
Courage, rabbis, courage!
Fresh cooking tips from France
Meandering along the Rhine River, soaking up the rich Jewish heritage
Food does grow on trees
A treasure trove of historical posters
Is your dog Jewish?
Ironic Mother Earth
Neighborhood Watch: Regenerating Safed
Cancer Chronicles: Side effects
Feeling uneasy at the moment?
מִשִירֵי רָחֵל: זֶמֶר נוּגֶה
אֲנִי בְּחוֹפֶש, תִסְתַדְרוּ לְבַד
Living in a shoebox
Building health in Rwanda
‘The Sabbath is on Saturday not Sunday’
Born to dance
Bereshit: The Subatomic and Atomic
America wants out and let the chips fall where they may!
Computer Generated Spirituality
The Tower and the Sword
Do Not Fear - Do Laundry!
Inauguration of the Masonic Forest Square in Jerusalem
Free Schach Distribution in KKL-JNF Forests
Remembering the Victims of 9/11
600 Holocaust Survivors Enjoy Touring with KKL-JNF
greenXchange at EXPO Milano
First Tree after Shmita Year Planted by Bavarian Agriculture Minister
Prime Minister of Lithuania Plants Tree in Jerusalem
KKL-JNF International Expo Mission to Milan
An Ecological Festival at the Shafir Winter Pond
KKL-JNF Global Landscapes Seminar at Expo 2015
New Bio-filters Purify Surface Runoff Water for Reuse
Future Tour Guides Discover the Negev with KKL-JNF
Got Water Problems?
$100 Million JNF Boruchin Israel Education Advocacy Center Opens
JNF Canada Pays Tribute to the Honourable John Baird
From Sunny Israel to Cold Canada
Renewable Energies for the Future in the Arava
LDA Conference: Science and Technology for Forests
The Negev Conference on Agricultural Research and Development
Arava Open Day: Food Security for Israel and the Entire World
Melinda and Chelsea: The Inspiring Story of Aliyah Across the Ages
An Olah Reports From Nepal
How One Oleh is Helping to Transform the Way People Drink Water
From Think Tank to Environmental Consultant
Why People Love Volunteering in Israel
How Natalie Edwards Built a Successful Career in Israel’s Startup Industry
5 Tips to Land a Job in Israel
Starting Your Own Business in Israel: Real Life Examples
Where Are They Now? The Olim of the July 2014 Charter Flight
36 Hours in Southern Israel
Food Shopping In Israel
How Women Can Have it All in Israel
Why Retirees are Thriving in Israel
Thanks to Aliyah video
6 Frequently Asked Questions about Israeli Healthcare
Starting Over in Israel
Spotted on Social: Moshe Somers’ Activity List
Sam Eisenberg: From Nativ to Aliyah
WATCH: Why Olim #LiveLoveIsrael
5 Ways that Olim Kick Back
WATCH: Highlights of 221 Olim Landing on the July 2015 Charter Flight
“WATCH: Highlights of 232 Olim Landing on the August 2015 Charter Flight”
Make yourself at home… in Israel
10.10.2015 | 27 Tishri, 5776
Prime minister to Channel 1: I’ll be running again in next election
Not all bleak for Netanyahu
China’s moves: US decline, or balance in Asia?
Hanegbi heads to Myanmar for highest-level visit in 35 years
Former ambassador to the US Oren may enter politics on list Kahlon is drafting
MK calls on PM to destroy homes of Jews who murdered Arab teen
Netanyahu: Hamas leaders are legitimate targets, no one is invincible
Kahlon indicates comeback with new ‘framework’
'Israel no better than Chelm for providing electricity to Palestinian companies that boycott it'
Manhattan borough president shows solidarity with Israel visit
Ministers and MKs urge Netanyahu to pound Hamas
Right-wing MKs call to investigate Balad party, ban it from Knesset after Qatar trip
Diplomacy & Politics
HILARY LEILA KRIEGER, JPOST CORRESPONDENT \
Revolutionary Guards launch surface-to-surface missile 390 R.
(photo credit:Rauf Mohseni/Reuters)
WASHINGTON -- A former senior Pentagon official said Saturday that now is not an opportune time for an Israeli strike on Iran, and that any such strike would inevitably draw in the United States.Colin Kahl, who served as deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East until December, said that any Israeli strike that prompted an Iranian retaliation would affect the United States."Even if it's just retaliation against Israel, the Americans will be in it from the beginning," he said, since the US would provide assistance to Israeli defense and because Iran would see an Israeli attack as inseparable from an American attack.Kahl assessed that the Iranian response would be far-reaching and include rocket attacks on American embassies in the region, using area allies and proxies and threatening the functioning of the Strait of Hormuz."No one should delude themselves that ... the prospect of America getting dragged into this is minor. It's not," he warned.Kahl also laid out conditions that he felt should be in place before any country undertook a strike on Iran: that other options such as diplomacy and sanctions have run their course; that Iran had clearly decided to move toward nuclear weaponization; that the military action could seriously degrade Tehran's capabilities; that an international coalition could be maintained after a strike."One reason I've been so critical about the Israelis taking action against Iran's nuclear program is that at this moment they don't satisfy any of those four criteria," he said.Kahl argued that the the diplomatic process should be given more time and contended it wasn't clear Iran had decided to weaponize its nuclear program. And he warned that anyone opposed to containing Iran should be particularly wary of military action."A military strike does not end the Iranian nuclear program," he said. "If military action is done the wrong way, military action would be the prelude to the need to contain a nuclear-armed Iran."But Amos Yadlin, a former director of IDF intelligence attending the conference, questioned the wisdom of waiting too long before contemplating military action."Going from 'it's too early' to 'it's too late' is a very fine line," he cautioned.Yadlin described Iran as already nuclear but not yet weaponized, and said Tehran wanted to make the timeframe for a nuclear weapon breakout ability very short."Those who are not willing to contain Iran today, when they don't have a nuclear weapon, how can they contain it when they have nuclear weapons?" he asked.Yadlin stressed that it was important to preserve the possibility of military action to pressure Iran and give teeth to sanctions and diplomacy -- a point made as well by Kahl.But Yadlin suggested that despite statements from American officials about keeping the military option on the table, mixed messages were neutralizing their impact."The music the whole world is hearing is that this is not really a good option," he said.And he asserted that ultimately the consequences of military action outweigh the costs of doing nothing."A nuclear Iran is much more dangerous than attacking Iran," Yadlin concluded.
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com.
Disqus users can post comments automatically.
Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
Sign up for our newsletter
Please insert a valid email address
By signing up to The Jpost mailing list, I hereby