NEW YORK (JTA) – If the Talmud were written today, would it look like Facebook?
First, the rabbis of the Mishnaic period post a Jewish legal rule. Then,
Talmudic sages weigh in with their comments, all pithy and lacking punctuation.
Almost immediately, the comments grow far longer than the original post.
Eventually, outside links to the Shulchan Aruch and Maimonides’ compendium of
Jewish law appear on the right side.
It may sound too cute by half, but
if you look closely, the Talmud and Facebook actually share similar
They also share a few basic ideas about commentary and community.
The Talmud enabled scholars who lived in different times and different places to
argue with each other, creating a virtual community. Facebook allows people who
live in different places and may not know each other to do the
“Every piece of information that’s offered opens up the opportunity
for commentary, for amplification -- whether it’s a link from The New York Times
or something that happened to you at the Israeli Interior Ministry or an idea
that you simply want to express.” said Esther Kustanowitz, a Jewish social media
expert who works part time for the Jewish Federation of Greater Los Angeles.
“And Facebook doesn’t just amplify the message, it expands the
On the eve of Facebook’s initial public offering,
scheduled for Friday, Jews -- like everyone else -- are still figuring out how
Facebook can serve their personal or professional needs.
What started out
in a college dorm room in 2003 as a way for Harvard students to rate women’s
comparative “hotness” (it was then called Facemash.com) has morphed into a
medium for more than 900 million people worldwide to communicate with each
other, rally support or opposition, publicize news, make money, flirt and
fulminate in ways both profound and mundane about the million and one things
happening at any given moment.
For a few in the Jewish community,
Facebook’s IPO raises the $64,000 question -- or in this case, the $64 billion
question -- of how much of that newly created wealth will go to Jewish causes.
The jury’s still out on whether Facebook's Jewish creator, Mark Zuckerberg, will
turn into a major Jewish giver following the IPO, when the just-turned
28-year-old figures to become one of the richest people in the world.
the real story of Facebook’s impact on the Jewish world ultimately is likely to
be more about the ways it is prompting Jews to change the way they think,
behave, organize, and even mourn and celebrate than it will be about
Facebook helped thousands of Israelis coordinate
last summer’s socioeconomic protests, the biggest in Israel’s history. The site
helped J Street turn from a fledgling, little-known upstart into a broad-based,
left-wing alternative to the American Israel Public Affairs
Most Jewish community institutions, however, haven’t yet
figured out how to maximize the potential of Facebook, according to Lisa Colton,
president of Darim Online, a Virginia-based company that helps Jewish
organizations adapt to the digital age.
Partly, Colton says, that’s
because Facebook is inherently threatening to institutions.
about people more than it is about institutions. It supports individuals
connecting with and learning from each other,” she said. “It’s a wonderful way
for individuals to circumvent institutions.”
Facebook enables Jews to
construct communities organized around areas of interest rather than geography,
religious denomination or institution.
When Hindy Poupko Galena and her
husband, Seth, began using Facebook to update friends and family about their
year-old daughter’s fight against a rare bone marrow disease, a community of
sympathizers quickly emerged that included thousands of people who had never met
the toddler, Ayelet. Strangers reached out to the Galenas -- members of the
Modern Orthodox community on Manhattan’s Upper West Side -- not just with
messages but with care packages.
“It allowed people to connect with what
was going on on a very deep and real level,” Hindy said. “So many people came
out of the woodwork and emailed me and said, 'I had a sick kid and never told
anyone about it, but I now feel that I can tell people about it.’ ” Even now,
months after Ayelet’s death in January at age 2, the Facebook-based community,
which they call Ayelet Nation, serves as a source of sympathy for the
“For a girl who only lived two years, it’s very comforting to
know that people know her name, and I think that was only possible because of
Facebook,” Hindy said.
Whereas many Jewish institutions define their
community by who’s inside and who’s out -- synagogues, JCCs and the Israeli
Rabbinate, to name just a few -- Facebook offers an opportunity for Jewish
community with no bounds.
“It can take Jewish leaders off their pedestals
and get them to interact with real people and real life in a multidimensional
way,” said William Daroff, the director of the Washington office of the Jewish
Federations of North America who has more than 3,000 “friends” on the social
networking website. “And it’s not just about the Jewish world, but a place for
us to talk about our kids and our dogs and the games we like to play and who we
As Facebook evolves, the Jewish communities it enables will
“I think it really is analogous to having phone lines, which
later enabled faxes and early Internet,” Colton said. “With Facebook, it’s not
about what we see and use today, it’s about what its foundations and widespread
adoption make possible in the future.”