The Jerusalem Post
Jpost search icon google-icon iphone
  Set as Homepage
Sun, May 26, 2013   17 Sivan, 5773
newspapers magazines
 
    • Breaking News
    • Diplomacy & Politics
    • Defense
    • National
    • Mideast
    • Syria
    • Iran
    • World
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Health & Science
    • Environment
  • Video
  • Opinion
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Op-Eds
    • Letters
  • Jewish World
  • Lifestyle
    • Arts & Culture
    • Food & Wine
    • Travel
  • Features
    • Insights & Features
    • Week in review
    • On the Web
    • Shalva Superheroes
    • Obama in Israel
  • Blogs
    • In the news
    • Judaism
    • From the Middle East
    • Lifestyle
    • Aliya
    • Science and Technology
  • JPost Apps
    • iPhone app
    • iPad app
    • Android app
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS feeds
    • JPost Toolbar
    • JPost Newsletter
    • JPost Alert
  • Premium Zone
    • The Jerusalem Report
    • The Experts
    • 20 Questions
    • e-paper
    • Ivrit
    • Christian Edition
    • Dash
    • Magazine
    • Metro
    • In Jerusalem
  • French
    • Politique & Social
    • Affaires Palestiniennes
    • Diplomatie & Monde
    • Art & Culture
    • Israel
  • Green Israel
JPost Learn Hebrew  
Advertise with us  
Nefesh Guided Aliyah  
Eldan  
AFMDA  
Africa Israel Group  
Isram Group  
Kupat Ha  
JPost Twitter  
JPost Facebook  
Classifieds  
         
 
 
    
Breaking News
 
 
  • JPost.com
  • Jewish World
  • Jewish News
 

'Circumcision ban makes Germany a laughing stock'

By REUTERS
07/17/2012 14:46
Tweet

Merkel promises to overturn court ruling to ban circumcision, which Jewish, Muslim groups have called an attack on religious freedom.

Rabbi holds boy for circumcision
Rabbi holds boy for circumcision Photo: REUTERS

German Chancellor Angela Merkel has warned that Germany could become a laughing stock if it fails to overturn a district court ban on circumcision that has enraged Jews and Muslims.

Merkel's government has already criticised the Cologne court ruling and promised a new law to protect the right to circumcise male infants, but the conservative leader's strong comments underline how sensitive Germany is to charges of intolerance because of its Nazi past.

"I do not want Germany to be the only country in the world where Jews cannot practise their rituals. Otherwise we will become a laughing stock," the Bild daily quoted Merkel as telling a closed meeting of her Christian Democrats.

Joerg van Essen, parliamentary floor leader of Merkel's junior coalition partner the Free Democrats, told the Financial Times Deutschland newspaper that the new law would be introduced in the autumn.

The Cologne court, ruling in the case of a Muslim boy who suffered bleeding after circumcision, said the practice inflicts bodily harm and should not be carried out on young boys but could be practised on older males who give consent.

This is not acceptable under Jewish religious practice which requires boys to be circumcised from eight days old, nor for many Muslims, for whom the age of circumcision varies according to family, country and branch of Islam.

Jewish and Muslim groups have branded the court ruling an attack on their religious freedom and Jewish leaders say it could even threaten the continued existence of their community in Germany - a disturbing claim for a country still haunted by the Nazis' murder of six million European Jews in the Holocaust.

But the court ruling has drawn support from some, including Britain's Secular Medical Forum which has written to Merkel urging her to resist pressure to make non-consensual circumcision lawful.

"We are shocked that religious groups deny the harm [caused by circumcision] and at the distorted and disingenuous claims made by those opposing the court's decision, wrongly suggesting that it is an indication of anti-Semitism," the chairman of the Secular Medical Forum, Dr. Antony Lempert, said in the letter.

"We urge you not to let such emotional blackmail persuade you to change the law or criticise the court's decision. As it stands, the court's decision ensures that today's children will be free to grow up to make their own decisions," it said.

Echoing such comments, Ronald Goldman, head of the U.S.-based Jewish Circumcision Resource Center which opposes the practice, cited studies he said show that circumcision causes considerable pain and trauma.

"The majority of the world does not circumcise because of an instinctive awareness of the harm, analogous to cutting off any other healthy body part," it said in a statement entitled "The German Circumcision Ruling: What about the harm to the child?"

The German court ruling applies only to the city of Cologne and its environs - home to a large Muslim minority - but Jewish and Muslim groups fear it could set a precedent and the ban could spread to other parts of Germany.

German doctors have also urged politicians to act to clarify the legal situation, fearing the ruling may force circumcisions underground and increase health risks for young boys.

Germany is home to about 120,000 Jews and some four million Muslims, many from Turkey which has criticised the court ruling. 

  • 'Circumcision will be targeted after Shechita'
  • German court declares circumcisions a crime
  • Send
  • Large
  • Small
  • Print
  • Share
Most Viewed in
1
IN PICTURES: 25,000 hassidim attend Belz wedding
2
Campaign site for NY mayor chooses wrong city
3
Pro-Israel caucus forming in Russian parliament
4
CST: British Jews not affected by 'Jihadist attack'
JPost Community
Tweet
Circumcision Jewish Germany Religious Freedom Muslims Merkel
Share this article
Tweet
Share
Send
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com. Disqus users can post comments automatically.

Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
JPost Services
conferenceConference
newsletterNewsletter
iphoneMobile Apps
kotelcamKotel Cam
kolboJPost Alert
premiumPremium
JPost TV News  
Mobile Apps  
Bank Hapoalim  
Meir Panim  
Yad Ezra  
Rambam Hospital  
TourLuxe  
Zev Goldstein PLLC  
Penrose Gallery  
JPost Premium Zone  
JPost kotel Camera  
         
 
Israel Focus
JPost TV News
Coming soon to a screen near you!  
Nefesh B'Nefesh Guided Aliyah
Already living in Israel? Enjoy the Benefits of Aliyah!  
Give "Freedom" this Passover
to needy Israeli families. Donate now  
War Threatens
Protect the People of Northern Israel  
China Suppliers
 
Intelligence Squared
The international debate forum, announces it is coming to Israel  
Bank Hapoalim
Israeli's number one bank  
Jerusalem Post Lite
Lite Edition of the Jerusalem Post for English improvement  
Learn Hebrew with us
Get 10 minutes free personal coaching in Hebrew through phone or Skype  
JPost newspapers
Sign up for the JPost newspapers and receive one month free subscription  
Kosher English Magazine
English language weekly magazine - especially for religious people  
JReport Kindle Edition
Now you can get the Jerusalem Report directly to your Kindle  
JPost Premium Edition
The very best articles are available only in our Premium edition  
Lifestyle Magazine
 
 
Real Estate
Don't Look For a House!
In Israel, our website will do it for you!  
 
Travel
Eldan Rent a Car
20% off all Car Rental Reservations in Israel  
Hertz Car Rental
Special Online Discounts!  
The King David Jerusalem Hotel
One of the world's truly iconic hotels, and a Jerusalem landmark  
 
 
 

Sites Of Interest:

Jerusalem Hotels
KKL-JNF
Poalim Online
BreitBart.com
Our Friends
Jerusalem Attractions
Jerusalem Tours
itraveljerusalem.com

JPost sites:

Learn Hebrew
The Jerusalem Report
Our Magazines
JPost Edition Francaise
Green Israel
Christian World
Jerusalem Post Lite

Services:

JPost Mobile Apps
JPost Premium
JPost Newsletter
JPost Toolbar
JPost News Ticker
JPost RSS feeds
JPost Archives
JPost Alert
JPost Kotel Cam

JPost Conferences:

NYC Conference
Diplomatic Conference

Information:

About Us
Feedback
Staff E-mails
Copyright
Sitemap
News Partners
Advertise with Us
Statistics
Ad Specs
Terms Of Service
Jpost.com, the online edition of the Jerusalem Post Newspaper - the most read and best-selling English-language newspaper in Israel. For analysis and opinion from Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East. Jpost.com offers expert and in-depth reporting from Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including diplomacy and defense, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, the Arab Spring, the Mideast peace process, politics in Israel, life in Jerusalem, Israel's international affairs, Iran and its nuclear program, Syria and the Syrian civil war, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Israel's world of business and finance, and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
 
About Us | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Premium | Newsletter | RSS | Contact Us
 
All rights reserved © The Jerusalem Post 1995 - 2012