The state told the High Court of Justice on Monday that until mid-2014, it will
not begin to complete a plan to provide gas masks to the population who are
without, estimated as high as 45 percent.
In other words, the unequipped
portion of the population will wait long past when the mid-2014 plan is
finalized until they can actually have their masks in hand.
was filed in the beginning of September by Labor MK Nachman Shai and the NGO
Front for the Public Defense.
Justice Yoram Danziger blasted the state’s
response, stating that its gradual approach to solving the problem might have
“sounded reasonable if we were two and-a-half years after the 2009 decision,”
referring to the government’s decision in 2009 to distribute gas masks to the
entire populace by the middle of 2011.
Next, the state was asked what its
criteria is for deciding who is able to receive gas masks first and in what
When the state responded with the vague assurance that the gradual
distribution process was open to everyone, Deputy Supreme Court President Miriam
Naor quipped, “you have no criteria, other than whoever comes first, wins.
Whoever comes to the post-office distribution area first will get.”
added that giving to whoever shows up first “is not criteria, when there are not
Naor continued, “In a situation of not enough, you need
to set criteria. For professional authorities this is a slogan.”
questioned the state from different angles in an attempt to extract more
information about the process for gas mask distribution.
state expressed frustration, noting that for years it had “offered to distribute
gas masks,” but that a “very weird process” took place with “the state’s
residents” in which “no one came” until after “some report in the media,
suddenly they all assemble” at once to get the masks.
The state added
that “if people had come to take the masks” before, then there would not have
been “the long lines which were photographed by the media.”
was filed in the shadow of Syria’s use of chemical weapons on a Damascus suburb
that killed 1,429 Syrians and what Shai called “existential threats facing and
confronting the state.”
Shai’s petition came shortly after State
Comptroller Joseph Shapira upbraided the state for a litany of failures in its
distribution of gas masks on everything from shortages, long lines, to leaving
too many citizens undefended from a potential chemical weapons attack.