The Raise Your Spirits production company 311.
(photo credit: Lydia Polimeni)
Gentlemen, I have no voice (so those hoping to be aroused should listen
elsewhere). Sometimes hoarse, sometimes low and creaky, what sound can I produce
with no training and no practice?
When my daughter came of age, she was frum,
shy and proper and declined both ceremony and celebration. In this she followed
me, who shuddered in relief as I walked up to my silent unmarked bat mitzva in
the women’s gallery at Sydney’s Mizrahi synagogue.
Age has made me bold.
When a girl is born, her father receives an aliya to announce her name. In
parallel form, I petitioned to receive an aliya and read Torah at Shira Hadasha
in Jerusalem, to mark my daughter’s life crossing in her stead.
Hadasha is a medley, wading in a civilization deluged with history, rising to
gasp the air of a radical present. It invites women to leyn and honors them with
aliyot but permits only men to lead services.
I conferred with an
American rabbi regarding my plan to read Torah. The Mishna discusses women
receiving aliyot; how could he condemn the practice? But he did not see a way
around the prohibition against hearing a woman’s voice – kol isha erva. He
suggested I obtain instruction from a learned Jerusalemite, known for his
sympathy to women’s issues.
I did not go to the great man himself but to
one of his henchmen. Explaining my intention to leyn in the new forum, I raised
the problem of the woman’s voice. There was a pause; it lasted some months. When
the henchman indicated his readiness to talk again, he opened with the
pronouncement that kol isha did not apply in ritual contexts. He brought proof
from a legend of the rabbi’s illustrious grandfather.
As to my reading
Torah, however, that would be impossible. Wayward paths these new prayer
services, leading who knew where.
Being married to the scion of an
exalted rabbinic family, my participation would give them imprimatur.
I attended Shira Hadasha as a member of the audience and marked the bat mitzva
My daughter turned 12, lost her faith, became a citizen of
the world. At the urging of our American rabbi, she and I and attended Segulah,
a community where women and men participate equally in the full liturgy. It has
revived my daughter; she is Jew again. But by decree of a Jerusalem rabbi, I sit
at Segulah mute as I have been all my Orthodox life.
This man, he freed
my song but trammeled up my spirit.
By some oversight, the rabbis did not
forbid a woman’s voice on the written page. The loophole appears to have gone
unnoticed and unutilized. Nehama Leibowitz was reportedly gagged from emitting
her biblical voice for a couple of decades, but otherwise women have not been
voluble enough to be the object of such injunctions. Moreover, what is to
prevent a woman writing in a man’s name? There is a rumor that the poorly
drafted parts of Rashi on Nedarim were written by his daughters. Perhaps half
our scholarship was published under such ruses.
During the visit to
Israel we made for my daughter’s bat mitzva, we were cajoled into attending a
musical produced by the Raise Your Spirits production company. This group was
formed during the second intifada so the women of Gush Etzion could stand
against Arab terror with song.
What could be worse than an amateur
musical created by housewives and physical therapists in the occupied
territories? But an old friend had a daughter performing in it and she wouldn’t
get off my case till I bought tickets.
The night we went it was pouring
and cold; the bus lurched through the Judean Hills while I tried to catch what
my boss on the phone from America was haranguing me about.
We sat down in
the amphitheater. The performers before us were all sizes, dressed in flowing,
loose folds suitable for the shapes of childbearing women. And when they opened
their mouths, they had the voices of angels.
I do not understand how a
voice can be sexually arousing. If I can listen all day to Jessye Norman and
Sara Bareilles, beautiful voices perfected by the digital miracle, what can a
live song bouncing off concrete walls, performed by billowing housewives
possibly accomplish? My daughter argues against me. A mother’s voice is the
primordial stimulus the unborn child receives from the universe: The sound of a
woman is the most arousing thing there is.
This winter, Raise Your
Spirits has composed another musical. It is many years since I have been to
Israel; many duties detain me in the Diaspora. But I am come now to hear real
women singing new songs about ancient women’s stories: Ruth and Naomi, Deborah
I travel many days to hear sublime voices, undigitalized and
unperfected, in a concrete hall in Judean Hills, and I answer those voices the
only way I know how: a black stain on a white, unblemished page.
erva.The writer is a Washington lawyer and a research associate at the
Hadassah-Brandeis Institute, Brandeis University. [email protected]