CAIRO - The Muslim Brotherhood, whose party is leading Egypt's staggered parliamentary election, came out on Thursday against bringing forward a presidential vote to end military rule, saying changing the timetable would wreak chaos.
Protesters who fought soldiers and police in central Cairo for five days before calm was restored this week want the army to cede power more swiftly.RELATED:Egypt sees Clinton remarks as 'interference'Egypt Salafist says party will honor Israel peace
Many Egyptians, suspicious of the military's stated commitment to democratic change, want a presidential vote by Jan. 25, the first anniversary of the start of the uprising that ousted Hosni Mubarak. The vote is now planned for mid-2012.
Activists plan a mass march to Tahrir Square on Friday to protest against army rule and the latest violence, which Egypt's prime minister said had contributed to billions of dollars of losses to the economy.
The once banned Brotherhood, keen to seal its place in mainstream
Egyptian politics via the six-week parliamentary vote after generations
of state repression, kept a low profile during the latest clashes in
Tahrir Square that killed 15 people.
Essam el-Erian, deputy head of the Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice
Party (FJP), which had the most candidates fielded in second-round
runoff votes on Thursday, said his group backed the army timetable to
hand power to an elected president by July.
"I think that is better than arranging it as soon as possible because this may create chaos," he told Reuters.
He said holding a presidential vote before both houses of parliament
were elected and able to draw up a new constitution risked handing too
much power to a new president. "We are not going to create a new
Mubarak," he said.
Elections to both houses will not be completed until March.
Protesters, who have stayed out in Tahrir since Nov. 18 despite several
charges by police to clear the square, are angry at the army's fierce
treatment of demonstrators and believe the military high command is
trying to cling to power.
Many activists accuse the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamists of
betraying the protesters' demands by focusing on securing their own
positions in the new power structure.
But analysts say an earlier presidential election would not necessarily
eliminate the military's predominance in a new civilian-governed state,
because all the viable candidates would likely have to have good
relations with the generals.
They include Amr Moussa, a former foreign minister and ex-head of the
Arab League. He, like some other candidates, has joined a consultative
council to advise the army, although the body suspended its activities
in protest over the violence.
A transitional period
A source close to the army told Reuters a popular mandate would not be
enough to support Egypt's next president because it would also need the
backing of the military establishment.
"This is a transitional period where one party hands power to another. A deal must be struck. This is politics," he said.
The violence of the past days, and an earlier flare-up in November when
42 people were killed, have shocked many Egyptians, although many still
regard the army as the only institution capable of restoring order after
months of turmoil since February, when Mubarak was ejected by a popular
Army-backed Prime Minister Kamal al-Ganzouri, appointed in November
under pressure from protests to sack the previous government, outlined
the challenges and appealed for unity at a news conference. His cabinet
was appointed this month.
"I had wished that after two weeks, I would come and tell you about what we have achieved ... but I cannot," he said.
"Is this not of itself a testimony to the fact that we are facing a real
problem and that we must sit down together and discuss it?" Ganzouri
said. "The economic situation requires that we have consensus and
He said that the economy had lost billions of dollars from the turmoil,
but had received only $1 billion from Arab states, while world powers
had not followed through on aid pledges. He said differences among
Egyptians were to blame.
"In the first months (after the uprising), everyone raced to help Egypt,
but when we disagreed among each other in the past few months, they
turned their backs on us," he said.
The clashes in Cairo have driven a wedge between those determined to
stay on the streets and other Egyptians desperate for a return to order
to shore up the economy and entice back foreign tourists.
But many have been shocked by images of police and soldiers hitting
protesters with batons even after they fell to the ground and, in one
case, kicking, beating and dragging a woman by her black robe, exposing
her bra, and then kicking her.
"I do not blame anyone nor do I defend anyone, I hope that everyone
seeks to remove the appearance of violence. How can the state of Egypt,
at the center of its capital, have these depressing events?" Ganzouri
"Is it not necessary for us to decide as a people that this must be
eliminated, so the tourist may come back, so the joy of the Egyptian
people may come back?"
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton this week responded with some of
the strongest US criticism of Egypt's new rulers, citing cases of women
protesters being sexually assaulted.
The United States, for which Egypt under Mubarak was a crucial ally, gives Cairo $1.3 billion a year in military aid.
Foreign Minister Mohamed Kamel Amr said on Wednesday that Egypt would
not accept meddling in its affairs, and did not take comments such as
Clinton's lightly. Ganzouri condemned all forms of violence,
particularly any directed at women.
Egypt's economy continues to take a beating. The credit rating agency
Moody's downgraded Egypt's debt on Wednesday and said it might knock it
down another notch because political uncertainty was undermining
A large number of the individual - rather than party list - seats up for
grabs in the run-offs were being contested between Muslim Brotherhood
and ultra-Islamist Salafi candidates.
Run-offs are held after each of the three rounds of the vote where no
candidate received more than 50 percent to win outright. Egypt's system
involves allocating two-thirds of seats of party lists with the rest
going to individuals.