A permanent haredi presence at the Tel Aviv housing protest would kill the cause
by turning the secular media against it, a United Torah Judaism MK said on
Tuesday. Speaking just a few hours before a planned visit to the site, Yisrael
Eichler had no doubt that current public support of the protest, that would
benefit all Israelis including the ultra-Orthodox, would flip if haredim became
visible in it.
RELATED:Shas threatens coalition over housing flap‘Tent cities’ spread across nation
PM calls on ‘rent revolters’ to protest at Knesset
Can cottage cheese, tents snowball
into early elections?
An outsider picking up an average haredi newspaper might
be initially surprised to see the focus given to the real estate market,
alongside the expected religious and political affairs.
But that media
attention accurately reflects what is perhaps the biggest problem facing the
haredi sector: the housing crisis. Haredi Mks, from both Shas and United Torah
Judaism, focus much of their legislation on ways to ease the predicament of high
housing costs to a largely impoverished sector, in which a dowry can include an
apartment, and living walking distance from your rabbi is a must.
secular media aside, still, there is little chance of seeing among the tents
members of the haredi sector for reasons pertaining to their
“What is happening now in Tel Aviv is a protest very a-typical
of the haredi public,” said Yehonatan Steinberger, a 28-year-old father of three
who is renting an apartment in Jerusalem. “For a haredi, to go out on to the
public realm and streets is not simple, we keep our privacy.”
itself will no doubt only benefit the haredi sector, many of whom do not work,
and buckle under the rising living costs in Israel.
To haredim, there are
certain values that are worth paying almost any price for, such as education and
living near one’s rabbis, Steinberger explained.
“It’s very important for
me to be nearby my spiritual center, which is 10 minutes away from where I live
by foot,” he said. The Steinbergers, who live on the border of the haredi
neighborhood on one side and Rehov Yaffo on the other, recently decided to
relocate in Jerusalem to the entirely haredi area of Shmuel Hanavi. The move
will boost their rent from NIS 2,500 to NIS 4,500, a hefty sum that they see no
choice but to pay, due to their concerns over the influence the mixed
secular-haredi area might have on their children.
“Our oldest daughter is
six, and where we live now is not an area to raise children,” Steinberger said.
“We are adding a monthly 2,000 shekels expense for the education of our
Eichler couldn’t quantify the breadth of the housing crisis in
the haredi sector, but he noted how acute a problem it is, that only now –
thanks to the fact that it is not perceived as a haredi issue – it is being
“All of the edicts the Finance Ministry made against haredim
regarding housing were legitimate, so long the Israeli public thought it was a
haredi problem,” Eichler said. “Haredim don’t have civil rights in this country,
and get them only when they are given to Arabs... Now the protest has spread to
the streets, to Tel Aviv, Kiryat Shmona, Beersheba,” he said.
the problem of high housing costs is due to the fact that the Israel Land
Administration currently has no criteria for lot prices, besides the highest
“For years we warned the prime minister, we said it’s not just a
haredi problem, but also that of young couples and senior citizens.
told him the cause of it was the profiteering of the Israel Land
In the past, the administration would set a price table
in the Housing Ministry of how much it wants for the land it allocates for
apartment construction in each and every area. In the past two years, they
changed the system and now they sell land to the highest bidder, which caused
the prices of all the plots in the country to leap by 40 percent.”
the solution would be simple – to regulate the prices on lots and determine
criteria, such as location, the speed and quality of construction – there remain
staunch and powerful opponents to such an option, Eichler said.
Finance Ministry is against changing the system, since in the year 2010 alone
they raked in NIS 14 billion, compared to NIS 3 billion in years before the
change, at the expense of the simple Israeli citizens.”
Later on Tuesday
night, Eichler was scheduled to pay a visit to the Tel Aviv protest area. But
his brief presence is anything but an indication that haredi families might join
the protest of which they are a silent part.
“Once the organizers
informed me and the Knesset’s Economic Committee that this is an all-Israeli
protest, and not one solely of extreme-Left and anti-religious groups, I told
them – we’re with you,” he said.
“But as a media person,” continued
Eichler, who for years was a journalist and columnist in haredi newspapers and
hosted a weekly radio show, “I told them it would be against their best interest
to have haredim as part of the protest, since that would cause the media to
shift sides away from its current support. If the haredim will be in favor, the
media will be opposed to it. For years we have been trying to raise this
protest, and nobody cared.”