The lasting effect of terror
By ANAV SILVERMAN
03/15/2013 18:15
Higher rate of miscarriages in Sderot linked to rocket stress, new study finds.
Illustrative photo Photo: Ariel Jerozolimski [illustrative]
In the field of journalism, there are people you encounter who leave an imprint
on your yellow notepad even years after you’ve met them. Sometimes you find that
you can’t immediately write their particular story – as important as it may be –
as other articles and deadlines surface and the story is shelved in the back
files of your mind. But there comes a moment when you suddenly have that
opportunity to share.
Living in Sderot during the year of heavy rocket
fire leading up to Operation Cast Lead in 2008, I reported on a distressing
reality in a time when very little media attention was being given to the
situation. At the scene of rocket attacks, I would often meet the victims –
children and elderly, mothers and fathers – usually at their homes or
neighborhood grocery stores and playgrounds where a rocket had just
struck. I would write and remember everything that was said to me and
mentally photograph those scenes of rocket terror. The panic and fear
that laced the voices of people who stood in shock among the broken glass and
collapsed roofs of their homes, with the ugly gaping holes left by the rockets,
and the trauma that followed – all this I tried to convey in the articles I
wrote.
BUT THERE was one victim whose story, which was really a sentence,
I never got around to writing. I still remember the scene. It was the summer of
2007 and I had just started working at Sderot Media Center. Following the Color
Red siren and the explosion that ensued, the director, Noam Bedein, and I raced
to the apartment building that had been hit by a rocket fired from northern
Gaza.
This was all fairly new to me and the situation had a very surreal
quality, almost like a movie shot in slow-motion. We would rush to the
scene, film, photograph and delicately approach the residents to see if they
would be willing to talk. After this one particular attack, ironically, a
resident of the apartment building, a woman, probably in her early 30s, began
conversing with me. She told me that it was very difficult living with the
constant rocket hits and that she had recently suffered a miscarriage because of
the stress.
The Sderot woman had two children with her. When she spoke of
her miscarriage, it caught me off guard. It was such a personal revelation, and
it made me realize that there were probably many women like her in Sderot, whose
lives had been shattered by an incoming rocket.
I was 21 at the time, a
student at university, but that Sderot mother’s story stayed with me. The fact
that a rocket fired from Gaza could take away the life of an unborn child a few
kilometers away in Israel was a tragedy beyond words.
Recently,
researchers from Ben-Gurion University shared a very important study, linking
the rocket attacks from Gaza to an increased number of miscarriages in Sderot
from 2004 to 2008. The study, which was published in the Psychosomatic
Medicine Journal of Bio-behavioral Medicine, found “statistically significant
correlations” between exposure to life-threatening rocket attacks in Sderot and
spontaneous abortions (more commonly known as miscarriages) and prenatal
maternal stress.
The authors explain in the study that the Israeli
southern town of Sderot had been the constant target of rocket fire from the
Gaza Strip since 2001. Between April 2001 and December 2008, more than
1,000 rocket alarms were sounded in or near Sderot, with 500 of them during 2008
alone. Out of the 1,132 Sderot women who took part in the study, only seven had
never experienced a siren during a six-month period before and during
pregnancy.
The researchers, Tamar Wainstock and Prof. Ilana Shoham-Vardi
of the epidemiology department of BGU’s Faculty of Health Sciences, and their
colleagues, Dr. Liat Lerner-Geva and Saralee Glasser, both of the Gertner
Institute at Tel Hashomer, and Dr. Eyal Anteby of the Barzilai Medical Center in
Ashkelon, compared two groups of women, from Sderot and Kiryat Gat, with similar
health characteristics.
Kiryat Gat was chosen as the control city for
several reasons. The city’s socioeconomic and demographic features were very
similar to Sderot and pregnant women from both cities took part in the study at
Ashkelon’s Barzilai Medical Center, which serves both populations. It is
also important to note that during the period chosen to record the women, Kiryat
Gat was still out of rocket range, although since then the city has been the
target of rocket attacks from Gaza as well.
The final study population
included records of 3,488 pregnancies of 2937 women, 1,132 from Sderot and 1,805
from Kiryat Gat. It was found that women in Sderot exposed to the stress of
alarms or actual rocket fire had higher rates of miscarriage than women in
Kiryat Gat who did not suffer from that kind of stress (6.9% verses 4.7%). The
perceived stress level among Sderot women was also higher, with the exposed
group scoring 4.36 on the stress questionnaire and the unexposed group
3.05.
“The findings demonstrate a significantly increased risk of SA
among women exposed to potentially life-threatening situations for a prolonged
period, both before and during pregnancy, compared with women of similar
demographic characteristics who were not exposed to missile-attack alarms or
missile attacks,” the authors wrote.
The researchers theorized that one
possible reason for miscarriages was an increase in cortisol due to stress, and
suggested it was important to assess the level of stress among women in the very
early stages of pregnancy, and in couples trying to conceive. The authors also
recommended policy planning to reduce the negative effects of stress on
reproductive health.
The study, whose results were presented at a
prenatal and pediatric epidemiology conference in Montreal two years ago, shed
important light on an aspect of life that Israelis living under rocket fire have
been coping with for years. Such research can only lead to more awareness
about life in Israel’s south and the lasting impact that rocket terror has on
Israel’s civilian population.
The writer spent two years living in Sderot,
where she experienced constant rocket attacks on the city working as an
international media liaison and front line reporter between 2007 and 2009. She
now works as a writer and educator at Hebrew University High School.