A new type of Jewish identity is on the rise. As with more classic forms of
Jewish identity, such as adherence to the strictures of tradition, involvement
in Jewish communal functions and Jewish scholarship, this new form of Jewish
identity might also help ensure Jewish continuity by preventing intermarriage
and providing positive reasons for wanting to remain a part of the Jewish
This new form of Jewish identity is called “attachment to Israel”
and it is strengthening among young US Jews – a segment of the American Jewish
population previously thought to be the most alienated from and indifferent to
the Jewish state.
Those are the findings of a recent survey commissioned
by the Workmen’s Circle/Arbeter Ring, an American organization first established
by Bundists in 1900 that today focuses on promoting Jewish social
US Jews aged 35 and under have become substantially more
attached to Israel than those aged 34 to 44, according to the survey, conducted
on the Internet in late April and early May among 1,000 Jews who are neither
Orthodox nor day school alumni.
This marks a turnaround in the downward
slide in young people’s attachment to Israel most famously lamented by American
pundit Peter Beinart. The research measured attachment to Israel through a
composite index based on two questions: “How emotionally attached are you to
Israel?” And: “To what extent do you see yourself as pro-Israel.”
survey seems to show that young American Jews without a strong background in
Jewish education or an Orthodox upbringing are finding an alternative way to
identify as Jews: through their attachment to Israel. This does not mean
that these young Jews now blindly accept Israeli government policies. Like many
Israelis, young American Jews are skeptical of political leadership in Israel.
Indeed, while younger American Jews felt more attached to Israel than the 35 to
44 age group, they scored significantly lower on the “Trust in Israeli Leaders”
index, which was based on three questions regarding whether or not Israel was
truly interested in peace, whether or not the Palestinian Authority was, and the
extent to which respondents backed a US preference for Israel over the
Palestinians. Indeed, it can be argued that as young American Jews begin to feel
more attached to Israel, they feel more comfortable voicing criticism out of a
sincere desire to improve the situation.
What explains this rise in
attachment to Israel among younger American Jews?
“In all likelihood, the
cumulative impact of Birthright Israel in bringing so many young Jews to Israel
may be coming to the fore,” said Prof. Steven M. Cohen, one of the researchers
who conducted the survey.
Historically, the ability of Jewish
organizations or Israeli institutions to strengthen American Jews’ ties to
Israel has been limited. American Jews – particularly the unaffiliated variety –
have in general felt somewhat distant from Israel if for no other reason than
the yawning geographic divide separating the two countries. Various
attempts were made to attempt to teach Israeli culture, current events, the
Hebrew language and Zionist ideology in America.
But unlike Jewish texts
and traditions that became the Jewish people’s portable homeland, the sights,
sounds and experiences of Israel could not be readily exported. There was no
substitute for going to the Jewish state and seeing the miraculous return of the
Jewish people to their historic homeland first hand.
But few American
Jews – particularly of the unaffiliated variety – ever ended up
Over a decade ago, a combined Israeli-American endeavor was
launched that has become probably the most successful Jewish identity project of
recent decades: Birthright Israel.
Cohen refers to it as the “Birthright
Since the year 2000, over 300,000 Jews worldwide, most of whom
from North America, have visited Israel. This has “bumped” upward
attachment to Israel, transforming a whole generation of young American Jews
who, according to studies conducted by Brandeis University’s Cohen Center for
Modern Jewish Studies, are less likely to intermarry.
Bringing young Jews
to Israel for a carefully organized, activity-packed trip of just 10 days has
resulted in the creation of a new form of Jewish identity called “attachment to
Israel,” and its impact could be critical for Jewish continuity in the 21st
Jerusalem Post Annual Conference. Buy it now, Special offer. Come meet Israel's top leaders