Trial and error
Sir, – I would not hold my breath regarding “Netanyahu vows to
change electoral system” (February 6). You need to be a super optimist or
masochist in this country after all these years to think that our undemocratic,
dysfunctional electoral system will ever be reformed.
It is our wish that
we elect a government that defends its citizens physically and economically, but
more so provides a future with an honest political structure for stability. We
need management and leadership that have the courage to overturn the present
system of cronyism that has provided us with inexperienced, second-rate
legislators who govern our way of life through trial and error.
Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s track record of political opportunism, weakness
and lack of substance is any indication, nothing will change for his promise to
change the electoral system.JACK DAVIS
– Reader Jessica Fischer is right in pointing out that former New York City
mayor Fiorello Laguardia’s mother was Jewish (“Jewish flower,” Letters, February
It is also true that Laguardia fiercely championed Jews and was very
strongly against the Nazis.
Interestingly enough, when he was assailed as
“a pronounced anti-Semite and Jew-hater” in the 1922 congressional campaign in a
district with numerous Jews, he declined the advice of friends that he emphasize
his mother’s Jewishness. Instead, he challenged his Jewish opponent to a public
debate – in Yiddish. (Laguardia won the election.) When he died his funeral took
place in the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. The service was conducted by the
Episcopalian bishop of New York, assisted by the rector of Christ Church,
Riverdale, Laguardia’s home parish.
Jerusalem Courage needed
Sir, – In Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz’s January 25 commentary (“Parshat Beshalach:
Jump into the water!,” Observations), he tells us: “Every person faces the need
for change in his life” but that there are occasions on which “the person is not
courageous enough to make the needed change.”
Rabinowitz illustrates the
importance of change with the story of Nachshon at the shore of the Sea of
Reeds. The Egyptian army was behind the Children of Israel and rapidly
God told them to go forward, but they were afraid. Then
Nachshon bravely walked into the waters. Only then did the sea part, and the
Israelites were able to cross safely.
This teaches that if even one of us
has courage, others will follow, and then God will help us.
1:27 it says: “God created man in His image... male and female He created them.”
If we are all in God’s image, everyone’s life is sacred, everyone is important
and everyone should be treated fairly, equally and with
Rabinowitz is rabbi of the Western Wall and its holy sites.
There, everyone is not treated equally and with respect. The Western Wall is
divided by a mehitza separating women from men. The men’s section is at least
twice as large as the women’s section, but at least half of the people who come
to the Wall to pray are women. As result, the men’s section is not crowded while
the women’s section is extremely overcrowded, with access to the Wall being very
Women are not allowed to hold a prayer service or read Torah.
If they do they are harassed and even attacked. If their tallit has black or
blue stripes they are arrested and dragged off to a police station. They
certainly are not treated fairly, equally or with respect.
deeds do not match his fine words. May he soon become courageous enough
to make needed changes. Then we can honor God by treating everyone fairly
and with dignity and respect.LENORE LEVIN
The writer is a Jewish
Jerusalem Post Annual Conference. Buy it now, Special offer. Come meet Israel's top leaders