Nietzsche, zichrono livracha?
Nietzsche blamed the Jews for giving birth to Christianity, whose morality praising weakness he opposed. But he wrote that the Jews themselves have a history of great passions, virtues, decisions, struggles and victories that flow into great men and deeds.
Friedrich Nietzsche Photo: Courtesy
On August 25, 1900, the man who famously declared
the death of God died. As the body of German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche was
laid into its grave three days later, one of the mourners declared that one day
the world would consider Nietzsche’s name sacred. He spoke more from bereavement
than wisdom: Nietzsche himself had written that he was afraid people might one
day make him holy.
When I asked Israel Eldad to sign his translation of
one of the philosopher’s books, Eldad, the extremely ideological former
commander of Lehi, surprisingly quoted from Nietzsche: “If you want to follow
me, be loyal to yourselves.”
Vladimir Jabotinsky, supreme commander of
the Irgun in the 1930s, urged his followers to carry but “one flag” – that of
Zionism. Yet he wrote that he himself refused to be branded or categorized but
preferred to think freely as a Nietzschean “superman” would.
have been held in Jerusalem devoted to Nietzsche’s metaphysics, epistemology,
science, and theory of this or of that. But arguably, Nietzsche’s greatest
influence was his character.
Nietzsche’s most famous book is Thus Spake
Zarathustra, a book in four parts, each of which was published separately
between 1883 and 1885. One thousand copies of the first three were
The first part sold 85 copies; the second, 93; the third, 63.
Nietzsche couldn’t find a publisher for the fourth and printed 45 copies
himself; he only distributed 10.
Nonetheless, he wrote to one of these 10
recipients that writing the book justified his having lived, and then he wrote
several more masterpieces. Was it this sureness of one’s destiny, and this
commitment to one’s truth, that stirred Eldad and Jabotinsky?
question of Nietzsche’s character has distanced him from some Jews and Zionists.
When I lecture in Israel about Nietzsche, I am most frequently asked: “But
wasn’t he an anti-Semite?” An understandable question, since German soldiers
carried his books in World War I and the Nazis quoted him. Still, it is unfair
to judge a man by those who quoted and misquoted him decades after he
Here is what Nietzsche had to say about the Germans: “They are my
enemies, these Germans... They have twisted and tangled everything they
touched.” He called German hatred of Jews, Poles and French a “stupidity” and
said anti-Semites should be expelled from the country, that they try to excite
blockheads and one should “associate with no man who takes part in the
mendacious race swindle.”
Nietzsche wrote quite a bit about the Jews. He
blamed the Jews for giving birth to Christianity, whose morality praising
weakness he opposed. But he wrote that the Jews themselves have a history of
great passions, virtues, decisions, struggles and victories that flow into great
men and deeds; at some point Israel will turn into a blessing for Europe and the
Jewish God will then rejoice in himself, in his creation and in his people –
“and let us all, all of us, rejoice with him.”
Perhaps this rejection of
German nationalism, the repeated condemnations of anti-Semitism in his writings
– and his public break with composer Richard Wagner, partly because of Wagner’s
anti-Semitism – and his objective praise and, elsewhere, critique of Judaism –
stirred something in the souls of Eldad, Jabotinsky and other Zionists? Or did
they share Nietzsche’s distaste for weakness, and want to, in his words,
“revalue all values”; in their case, to leave post-Christian, Exilic Judaism and
In the 1940s, Eldad was imprisoned in Jerusalem. He took the
trouble to smuggle out an article he wrote for his underground paper about
Nietzsche. The article ended with a call to Jewish youth to see things as
clearly as Nietzsche had, from the mountaintops; Jews prefer to live in cities
and on flat ground, but the time had come to aspire to the heights of
In the 1950s Eldad wrote that Israel’s two great mountains,
Sinai and Moriah, were both outside the borders of the state but should inspire
Israelis with longing. It is not surprising that Jabotinsky wrote a song while
he was in jail in 1920, ending with the refrain: “Ours, ours, the crown of Mount
Hermon will be ours.”
In these days when protesters call for handouts,
when army veterans travel far east for inspiration, when leaders offer no vision
and so many of them try to inspire only hatred or jealousy of other segments of
the population, I think of how different things would be if Eldad’s call were
heeded by more Israelis.
We might learn how to write books not because
the government guarantees a commission but because we want to justify having
We might ascend to the mountains of Israel, breathe the air of
freedom, and seek to become great men of great deeds by channeling the great
Jewish passions and struggles of the past into our lives.
directs the Public Policy Center at the Jerusalem Institute for Market Studies
and is the author of God, Man and Nietzsche.