Building a Jewish home and family is the modern Orthodox ideal from childhood –
but there are tens of thousands of young and not-so-young singles from this
sector around Israel and many more abroad who have not yet found their intended.
With the growing phenomenon of late bachelorhood in the community, one wonders:
What is going on?
Almost no academic research has been conducted into this
phenomenon, which is an ongoing and painful subject for national religious
families. But a nonprofit organization established a decade ago to find these
singles their longed-for shidduchim believes it understands at least some of the
reasons, and three years ago it launched a counseling program for those who have
some emotional block about tying the knot.
Known by the (inelegant) name
Yashfe (a stone in the breastplate of the High Priest and a combination of the
founders’ initials), the organization has already married off about 400 singles
and has a database of 4,000 more. The Jerusalem-based group (http://yashfe.org,
(02) 644-8422), initiated and chaired by humanitarian businessman Haim Falk,
also matches up some 500 couples for dates each month and counsels others who
are either contemplating engagement or having difficulty making an emotional
connection. About 450 trained volunteer counselors around the country (10
percent of them men) give of their time as well. There is a second office in
Givat Shmuel near Bar-Ilan University.
Two of the organization’s
professional counselors, psychologist Zipi Rhein and clinical social worker Roni
Hollander, recently held a workshop in the capital’s Bayit Vegan neighborhood on
delayed bachelorhood in the religious community, at the annual meeting of
ATEM-Nefesh, an Israeli network of modern Orthodox and haredi mental health
professionals. The allday conference was organized by ATEMNefesh chairwomen
Judith Guedalia and Leah Abramowitz.
“Maybe people are a bit spoiled
today,” suggested Rhein in an interview with
The Jerusalem Post following the
conference.
“They have seen their parents’ marriages, the good and the
bad, and want more. They yearn for perfection and romantic love.”
“They
don’t want to compromise,” added Hollander. “Society encourages individualism
and personal development. This influences singles [regarding] what they are
looking for in a marriage partner. They want to fall head over heels in
love.”
Yashfe director-general Shirat Malach – whose husband’s surname
romantically turned her own into the Hebrew phrase meaning “song of (an) angel”
– said that “young modern Orthodox tend to have high expectations for a mate,
hope for a deep relationship before getting married rather than something that
develops afterward; they used to have more patience.”
In addition, she
said, “people are afraid of the possibility of divorce; they want to be
sure.”
About 60 percent of those in the database (which includes
widow/ers and divorcees looking for a second time around) are women, said
Malach. The number of eligible single men may be depleted because some have left
religion or are homosexual, and the complexity of religious categories further
complicates the issue.
“Young women can call themselves observant even if
they wear pants. It is very flexible,” she said. “But if a young religious man
doesn’t put on
tefillin daily, he cannot call himself religious. Men usually
want to marry women several years younger than themselves, so it’s harder for
women in their 30s. Divorced men tend to marry singles, while its hard for
divorced women to find single men to marry. There definitely is a delay in
marriage among national religious Jews, even though there are still many who
marry very young. It’s such a big decision that people don’t know how to decide.
I don’t believe that most prefer their freedom. There is a lot of
societal and familial pressure to get married, but the vast majority also want
to wed.”
It’s much harder for the modern Orthodox to find a life partner
than for secular Jews, noted Rhein. Religious women do not go to bars and other
such gathering places to get “picked up.” They prefer to be introduced by
somebody who knows the potential partner well, his background, level of
religious practice, temperament and education.Young observant women who have
graduated from Torah seminaries have accumulated a great deal of Jewish
learning, often no less and sometimes more than their male counterparts, added
Malach.
National religious male singles also usually have strict
criteria, the Yashfe staffers agreed, but at least they do not include the
prevalent demand in the haredi sector that the potential bride’s family be
welloff enough to buy an apartment and even support the bridegroom during long
years of yeshiva study. Young haredi men, not only in the Diaspora but also
increasingly in Israel, want to marry beautiful and slim women – so much so that
anorexia and other eating disorders are no longer a rare phenomenon in that
sector despite their minimal exposure to the general media.
Speed dating,
in which an equal number of women and men encounter potential dates for five
minutes until the next one comes around, is “almost passé,” insisted Malach. “It
hasn’t proved itself. Get-togethers are desirable in this group only if they are
not called ‘singles events’ but provide opportunities to meet while learning or
doing something interesting.”
The increasing gender separation in modern
Orthodox society – which is a given in haredi culture – even from kindergarten,
also reduces opportunities for intermingling and naturally getting used to the
opposite sex. This separation, however, could be beneficial, suggested Malach,
as it could make the early encounters “more exciting.” But older singles who
share workplaces with the opposite gender will find this less of a
problem.
Getting married early “can result in problems. They have
children quickly and have so much on their shoulders,” said Hollander. “Early
marriage can also have benefits; they almost go through adolescence and form
their personalities together. But if they veer away and change
nevertheless, it could be harder.”
Rhein, Yashfe’s counseling director,
whose married name hints that she is married to a pedantic yekke of German-
Jewish parentage, told the participants at her lecture that this was in fact
true. The mother of two children, aged nine years and 18 months, is “by nature
disorganized, and I enjoy spending money. My husband is very orderly and
careful. I was nervous about living with someone who is so organized, in control
and always on time. But it turned out to be a great gift, as both of us adapted.
He learned to take it easy about things, and I learned to be more tidy and
organized. There can be good chemistry, even if there are big
differences. You can identify in a partner what you haven’t managed to
accomplish yourself. You are then attracted, and as a couple, you can reach
completeness.”
With the majority of the single population on computerized
social networks such as Facebook, one can have many “friends” and “likes,” but
this connection is almost always impersonal and superficial, said Rhein, who
will soon celebrate her 10th anniversary with her husband.
“Many young
people don’t have a clue about how to make real, not artificial, connections
with others. They arrive for a date wearing imaginary armor, especially if they
have been on many dates before,” she continued.
The two Yashfe lecturers
began by asking the audience of around 20 people (three of them men; almost all
of them married) to pick a neighbor (of the same sex) and introduce oneself and
hug her (or him). Some of those present found this refreshing and novel,
but others were taken aback by making physical contact with someone they had
never seen before and felt it was “artificial” and “embarrassing.” The lecturers
presumably used the exercise to show the difficulty of meeting people of the
opposite sex suddenly, as on blind dates.
There are a lot of personal
issues that get in the way of being prepared for marriage, they said. “These are
not people with trauma from childhood, psychiatric problems or a history of
abuse. They have difficulty exposing themselves as human beings,” they
agreed.
One of the techniques they use when counseling singles or
would-be couples is Imago Relationship Therapy (IRT), a pre- or post-marriage
therapy developed by Dr. Harville Hendrix, whose books G
etting the Love
You Want: A Guide for Couples, Keeping the Love You Find: A Personal Guide and
Giving the Love that Heals: A Guide for Parents attracted many
followers.
IRT claims to meld various behavioral sciences, psychological
systems and spiritual disciplines into a theory of primary love relationships.
IRT is based on the idea that people are born whole and complete; are
psychologically injured (usually not on purpose) by their parents (or other
primary adult caretakers); hold a composite image of all their positive and
negative traits; and marry someone who is an “Imago match,” who corresponds to
the composite image of our parents or other caretakers.
Thus, according
to the Imago theory, we marry to complete the unfinished business of childhood
and to heal ourselves. It also elevates the importance of romantic love as being
nature’s selection process in finding a suitable partner.
The Yashfe
counselors encourage a couple’s dialogue in which one – whose eyes are riveted
on the other’s about 40 centimeters away – makes a statement, while the other
repeats, summarizes, validates it and shows empathy. At the workshop, Rhein and
Hollander chose single-sex partners to try this process. Most reported that they
enjoyed it and got to know the person they had hugged much better.
The
Yashfe professionals most worry about singles who remain on their database for
five or even 10 years and never manage to find a partner. “It is for this reason
that we set up the counseling service,” said Rhein. “We believe that people,
from babyhood, naturally have the ability to love and make a human
connection.”
Hollander gave as a typical example a 28- year-old modern
Orthodox man who had been dating a woman on and off for three years. When the
idea of marriage came up, he always refused. “He saw a flaw in every woman.
Nobody met his criteria. He was so emotionally wounded. His ability to connect
was destroyed. On a blind date, he always felt on the defensive, as if he had to
protect himself. Only when you open yourself up for a connection will the
healing come.”
They use Imago to help the potential mates “think of their
connection and create a single space for themselves as a new entity, not
constantly harp on each other’s and one’s own attributes and weak
points.
They are building something together, like God’s presence between
them. This relaxes them. They want to make this new entity grow. If a person is
less critical, he or she is able to make a connection.”
Surprisingly,
even though the modern Orthodox establishment has in recent years been bemoaning
the phenomenon of late bachelorhood, it has not set up a nonprofit organization
like Yashfe, which remains the only one of its kind. Even Tzohar, the
organization of moderate Orthodox rabbis who perform weddings at no cost for
those who want to avoid the official rabbinate, has not joined the
effort.
If the community is serious about action, it would be well
advised to do so.
Join Jerusalem Post Premium Plus now for just $5 and upgrade your experience with an ads-free website and exclusive content. Click here>>