Alleged rape victim’s lies weaken case against Strauss-Kahn

Former IMF chief released from house arrest without bail; 'NY Times' reports woman told jailed boyfriend, he has "a lot of money."

By GIL STERN STERN SHEFLER, REUTERS
Dominique Strauss-Kahn and his wife in NY 311 (R) (photo credit: REUTERS)
Dominique Strauss-Kahn and his wife in NY 311 (R)
(photo credit: REUTERS)
NEW YORK – News that rape charges against French-Jewish politician and former International Monetary Fund managing director Dominique Strauss-Kahn might be on the verge of collapse hit New York City by surprise over the weekend.
Strauss-Kahn was released from house arrest on Friday after prosecutors said the hotel maid who accused him of attempted rape lied to a grand jury, and made other false statements.
RELATED: Strauss-Kahn released from house arrest Sexual assault case against Strauss-Kahn near collapse
Sarkozy: Lagarde's win to head IMF 'victory for France'
Strauss-Kahn pleads not guilty to sex charges
Strauss-Kahn, 62, still faces charges that he sexually assaulted the woman in New York, but questions about her credibility appear to be shifting the case in his favor in a twist that could upend French politics.
Strauss-Kahn smiled as he left the courtroom with his wife, Anne Sinclair, at his side. Footage of him leaving the State Supreme Court in Madison Square Park without bail after the prosecution admitted to serious problems in the complainant’s testimony were broadcast live on countless television screens throughout the city.
The local tabloids were uncharacteristically ambivalent in their coverage. While some, like the New York Daily News, lead with the bellicose headline “Le Perv May Walk,” the New York Post put the relatively tame headline “DSK Case Bombshell” on its front page.
Such coverage was vastly different than the sensationalistic headlines that appeared last month when accusations were first made against Strauss-Kahn by a woman who said he had raped her at an expensive hotel in Manhattan.
On Friday, the prosecution said the woman’s testimony was laden with falsehoods, inaccuracies and contradictions, seriously undermining her credibility.
The Jewish politician’s ethnic background remained out of the conversation, as it has since the case first erupted last month, with few exceptions.
But the Financial Times’ blog carried a talkback comparing DSK to Alfred Dreyfuss, the French Jew whose false conviction for treason over a century ago sparked off a wave of anti-Semitism and, inadvertently, inspired the creation of the Zionist movement to counter such bigotry.
“Like Dreyfus, he was pursued mercilessly by new ideologues,” it read. “The hunt was on, and no one wanted him as a next-door neighbor anymore... It was execution by image, against a single man.”
Suddenly, talk was rife of a political rehabilitation for the man who was until not long ago the front-runner in the race for the presidency of France. But commentators said it was too early to make any predictions over his future in politics.
“Let’s all stay calm,” French politician Gérard Le Gall was quoted as saying. “It’s too early to draw any conclusions.”
Until his arrest on May 14, Strauss-Kahn had been a steward of the global economy and a leading contender in the 2012 French presidential elections. Jubilant supporters in the French Socialist party now hope he might rejoin the presidential race, but some analysts see him as too tarnished.
Amid the scandal, he was forced to resign as head of the International Monetary Fund on May 19. Christine Lagarde, who just stepped down as French finance minister, will take over the top IMF job on Tuesday.
Enjoying his first taste of freedom since being pulled off a Paris-bound jetliner hours after the purported attack, Strauss-Kahn emerged on Friday evening from the townhouse where he had been under house arrest and was driven with his wife and another couple to Scalinatella, a pricey Italian restaurant on Manhattan’s Upper East Side.
Strauss-Kahn’s lawyers want all the charges against him dropped.
“We are absolutely convinced that while today is a first giant step in the right direction, the next step will lead to a complete dismissal of the charges,” his high-priced lawyer Benjamin Brafman said.
The judge said prosecutors will reexamine the evidence after they revealed the housekeeper lied to a grand jury about her actions after the alleged attack, and on tax and immigration documents.
The woman initially said that after Strauss-Kahn assaulted her, she cowered in the hallway outside his room until he left and she felt safe to seek help. Now, prosecutors say, she admits she cleaned a nearby room and then returned to start cleaning Strauss-Kahn’s suite before reporting the incident.
Later on Friday, investigators said that card-key data showed she had cleaned Strauss-Kahn’s suite before cleaning another room, The New York Times reported.
As Judge Michael Obus released Strauss-Kahn, he told those in the courtroom: “I understand that the circumstances of this case have changed substantially, and I agree the risk that he would not be here has receded quite a bit. There will be no rush to judgment. The people will continue to investigate and reexamine the matter as appropriate.”
Strauss-Kahn, whose house arrest had included electronic monitoring and an armed guard, agreed to return to court as needed, including for a hearing on July 18.
His bail payment of $1 million and bond of $5m. were returned to him, but his passport was not.
Prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon told the court, “The facts of the sexual encounter was, and is, corroborated” but some details appear to have changed.
The complainant’s brother told Reuters in Guinea that she was the victim of a smear campaign.
Her lawyer, Kenneth Thompson, said after the hearing his client’s story had never wavered, adding that Strauss-Kahn had bruised her badly and tore a ligament in her shoulder.
“The claim that this was consensual is a lie,” Thompson told reporters. “She made some mistakes, but that doesn’t mean she is not a rape victim.”
The case has hinged on the accuser, a 32-year-old Guinean immigrant who cleaned the $3,000-a-night suite at the Sofitel hotel in Manhattan where Strauss-Kahn was staying.
Prosecutors found issues with her asylum application, tax return and statements to the grand jury investigating the assault case, court documents showed.
The New York Times quoted law enforcement officials as saying prosecutors had found possible links between the accuser and people involved in drug dealing and money laundering.
Quoting a well-placed law enforcement official, the paper reported on Friday that in particular, prosecutors were alarmed by a phone call the woman made within 28-hours of the alleged assault to a jailed boyfriend in Arizona.
The call was recorded, but it was in a special dialect of the Guinean language of Puli. When the translation was finally completed on Wednesday, prosecutors were alarmed, the paper said.
“She says words to the effect of, ‘Don’t worry, this guy has a lot of money. I know what I’m doing,’” the paper quoted the official as saying.
It said their image of her as a pious, devout Muslim shattered by the experience slowly changed as they interviewed her, and more and more inconsistencies came to light.
“Sit-downs with prosecutors became tense, even angry. Initially composed, she later collapsed in tears and got down on the floor during questioning. She became unavailable to investigators from the district attorney’s office for days at a time,” the paper said.
It said the last meeting, on Thursday, was devastating.
When investigators confronted her with bank records showing deposits of thousands of dollars in accounts in her name in Arizona, Georgia, New York and Pennsylvania, the woman – who repeatedly claimed that her Sofitel job was her only source of income – became silent and turned to her lawyer for guidance.
“[Thompson] was speechless,” the paper quoted the official as saying.
Some commentators suggested that Strauss-Kahn, known as the “great seducer” of French politics, could have been set up.
His arrest opened the field for several other Socialist candidates for next April’s presidential election, including party leader Martine Aubry, who trails colleague Francois Hollande in opinion polls.
Sarkozy, who nominated Strauss- Kahn for the IMF job, has not commented on the affair since his arrest. The case has prompted debate in France on gender equality and a media tradition of respecting