Winklevoss Reuters 311.
(photo credit: REUTERS/Adam Hunger)
SAN FRANCISCO - Mark Zuckerberg won a legal battle against former Harvard classmates who accuse him of stealing their idea for Facebook, but the feud made famous on the silver screen is not over yet.
RELATED:Friending Aaron SorkinZuckerberg ranks 4th in Businessperson of the Year list
Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss must accept a cash and stock settlement with Facebook that had been valued at $65 million, a US appeals court ruled on Monday. Meanwhile, a New York man filed an amended lawsuit against Zuckerberg on Monday, citing a 2003 email in which Zuckerberg discusses an urgent need to launch his site before "a couple of upperclassmen" could launch theirs, an apparent reference to the Winklevoss twins.
The Winklevoss brothers argued their settlement with Facebook was unfair because the company hid information from them during talks. But the twins were sophisticated negotiators aided by a team of lawyers, 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals Chief Judge Alex Kozinski wrote for a unanimous three-judge panel.
"At some point, litigation must come to an end," Kozinski wrote. "That point has now been reached."
An attorney for the brothers, Jerome Falk Jr., said on Monday his
clients would seek a rehearing before a larger, "en banc" group of 9th
That larger group can overrule a three-judge panel, although only a
fraction of cases undergo such a review. Should the 9th Circuit refuse
to rehear the case, the last option would be an appeal to the US
Falk said he "respectfully" disagreed with the 9th Circuit's conclusions.
The 1.96-meter Winklevoss brothers are Olympic rowers
who participated in the 2008 games in Beijing, and their saga with
Zuckerberg was dramatized in the film "The Social Network."
In the movie, actor Armie Hammer played both identical twins.
Zuckerberg's character snidely called them on-screen the "Winklevi."Fact and Fiction
The twins, along with Divya Narendra, started a company called ConnectU
while at Harvard. They say Zuckerberg stole their idea. Facebook denies
Facebook took in $1.2 billion of revenue in 2010's first nine months,
according to documents that Goldman Sachs provided to clients to entice
investors in a special fund set up to invest in the giant social
The company was valued at $50 billion as part of that transaction. The
company said on Monday it is evaluating the Internet market in China,
but a source indicated it has not yet signed a business deal with any
The Winklevoss twins and Narendra agreed to a settlement that had been
valued at $65 million. But they argue that, based on an internal
valuation that Facebook did not reveal, they should have received more
Facebook shares as part of the deal.
A lower court had granted Facebook's request to enforce the settlement
with the Winklevoss twins and Narendra. The 9th Circuit agreed on
"The Winklevosses are not the first parties bested by a competitor who
then seek to gain through litigation what they were unable to achieve in
the marketplace," Kozinski wrote.
Facebook deputy general counsel Colin Stretch said the company
appreciated the court's careful consideration of the case and was
"pleased" it ruled in their favor.
The case is not the only ownership dispute Zuckerberg must fend off. A
New York businessman, Paul Ceglia, claims a contract with Zuckerberg to
develop and design a website entitled him to an 84 percent stake in the
privately held social networking site.
In a new twist to the long-running case, Ceglia filed an amended lawsuit
on Monday, in which he outlined an 2003 email from Zuckerberg that
suggested the Facebook founder stalled "a couple of upperclassmen here"
from launching their competing website. The lawsuit does not
specifically name the Winklevoss twins.
"If we don't make a move soon, I think we will lose the advantage we
would have if we release before them," the lawsuit claims Zuckerberg
wrote in an email.
Ceglia claims Zuckerberg pleaded with him for money to finance the
social network's set-up with the intention of getting it live before the
Facebook has repeatedly said it believes the lawsuit is fraudulent. Orin
Snyder, a lawyer for the company, said Facebook looks forward to
defending the case in court and on Monday characterized Ceglia's claims
Join Jerusalem Post Premium Plus now for just $5 and upgrade your experience with an ads-free website and exclusive content. Click here>>