Guess who's coming to dinner

Wednesday's White House guest list.

By RON KAMPEAS\ JTA
August 29, 2010 01:19
TRY AND TRY AGAIN. The summit in September 2009. Obama had urged then for both sides to start talks

Obama Netanyahu Abbas 311. (photo credit: Associated Press)

The White House dinner on Wednesday, on the eve of the official launch of renewed Palestinian-Israeli talks, will be key to outlining the contours of the negotiations.

“The dinner will help to restore trust,” Dennis Ross, the Obama administration’s top Iran-policy official, said in a conference call last Friday with Jewish organizational leaders.

Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.


Unless, that is, it turns into a food fight.

Until the dinner, the exact issues to be negotiated will remain unknown.

What we do know is who will be there and where they’re coming from. Here’s a preview.

Binyamin Netanyahu – prime minister

The proposed talks will mark the second time that the 60- year-old Netanyahu has engaged in negotiations with a Palestinian partner under US pressure.



Last time, in 1997, while facing then-president Bill Clinton and PLO chairman Yasser Arafat, Netanyahu ceded a degree of control around Hebron to the Palestinians. He has since suggested that he regrets the concession: He was recorded as telling a grieving settler family in 2001 that his agreement was little more than a ruse to keep a hostile administration at bay. Also, his revered father, historian Benzion Netanyahu, now aged 100, was known to be unhappy with the concession.

Having completed a slow climb back to the premiership after his plunge in popularity following his first term, from 1996 to 1999, Netanyahu reportedly sees himself in a much stronger position vis-avis Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and US President Barack Obama than he was with Arafat and Clinton.

Netanyahu wants to get security issues out of the way before he talks final-status issues such as Jerusalem, borders and refugees. Making sure that he has a plan to protect Israelis will be key in the effort to pitch concessions to an Israeli public still wary of the pounding Israel took after it withdrew unilaterally from the Gaza Strip in 2005.

The immediate question for Netanyahu is whether he’ll extend the self-imposed, partial, 10-month settlement construction freeze that is set to expire at midnight on September 26. If he doesn’t, Abbas has said he’ll quit the talks.

Mahmoud Abbas – PA president

Mahmoud Abbas, 75, is a successor to Arafat who has been far less problematic for his Western allies but far less esteemed by the Palestinian people. His nadir came when Hamas gunmen drove the PA out of Gaza in a bloody coup in June 2007. Since then, Abbas has tried to reestablish his Fatah party and the PA as the inevitable repository of Palestinian ambitions for statehood.

Negotiations are the only way for Abbas and his prime minister, Salaam Fayyad, to demonstrate to the Palestinian people that diplomacy trumps violence as a means to statehood.

Abbas insists that Israel agree to a permanent settlement freeze, and he wants to make sure the talks get to the final-status issues as soon as possible so he can show his constituents that he is reaping the benefits of cooperation.

Barack Obama – US president

It is tempting to cast the haste with which Obama, 49, has organized these talks for early September as a sign of his panic at the prospect of November 2’s congressional elections that seem likely to result in heavy losses for the Democratic Party.

However, such an analysis would ignore the fact that Obama was pressing hard for talks months ago, when his approval ratings were much higher; it would also disregard America’s broader foreign policy strategy in the region.

For the United States, having the talks now gives Netanyahu a reason to extend his settlement moratorium and thereby sustain Arab support for US policies elsewhere in the Middle East. This support is seen as key while Obama attempts to juggle other crises in the region, including Iraq’s vexed attempts to set up a government and the simmering concern over Iran’s accelerating nuclear ambitions.

A peace treaty also would signal US strength in the region; a Palestinian state would allow Arab governments leeway in explaining to their populace why they are aligning with a US effort to isolate the Iranian theocracy.

The US posture has been to insist that these are Israeli-PA direct talks, but Obama has not been shy about threatening direct intervention if there are stumbles.

Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and Jordanian King Abdullah

The United States sees both these figures as critical to making the talks – and, eventually, Palestinian statehood – work.

Egypt maintains some sway over Hamas, and controls access to a major entry point into Gaza. Jordan has been deeply involved in helping to train the PA police force, and would be a natural outlet for a resurgent Palestinian economy.

Mubarak, 82, is known to be ill and eager to transfer power smoothly to his son, Gamal; containing the Gaza problem and playing a role in birthing a Palestinian state would provide a much-needed boost to Mubarak rule.

Abdullah, 48, is also eager to contain Islamist extremism and has in recent years positioned his regime as a bridge between the West and the Muslim world. The emergence of a Palestinian state in the West Bank would also help to quell the notion that Abdullah’s kingdom, where the majority of the population is Palestinian, should be the Palestinian state.

Hillary Clinton – US secretary of state

Clinton, 62, is set to play the role of the primary broker at the peace talks. Beginning on Thursday, she will host the first substantive talks Israeli and Palestinian leaders will have had since 2000. That is a sign of Obama’s increasing confidence in his one-time bitter rival for the Democratic presidential nomination.

Clinton aides have leaked to the press their frustration with the perceived limits on her role, saying she has been kept out of the big games. That is changing, as evidenced not only by her newly central role in these talks, but also in her recent frontline exposure as she urged her former Senate colleagues to support new arms treaties with Russia.

Israelis have been hoping for Clinton’s return, despite her role in March in dressing down Netanyahu over an Interior Ministry committee’s announcement, during a visit by US Vice President Joe Biden, of a large housing start in eastern Jerusalem’s Ramat Shlomo neighborhood. Clinton long has been seen as having strong emotional ties to Israel – ties that Israelis feel Obama lacks.


Related Content

F35 Adir fighter jet
June 21, 2018
US F-35 diplomacy with Ankara puts Washington in Catch-22

By SETH J. FRANTZMAN