SIMI VALLEY, Calif. - Texas Governor Rick Perry came out swinging in his national debut on Wednesday, all but calling US President Barack Obama a liar, describing Social Security as a fraud and attacking his main Republican rival in the presidential race.
Perry, a conservative Tea Party favorite and the Republican front-runner, traded barbs with closest competitor Mitt Romney over who has created more jobs.
Their testy exchange in Perry's first presidential debate was proof that
the fight to determine the 2012 Republican challenger to Democrat Obama
is becoming a two-man contest.
The Republicans battled with each other to promote their records on
jobs, a day before Obama makes a crucial speech to Congress on his plan
to bring down the 9.1 percent jobless rate.
Perry, who entered the race only a month ago and has leapfrogged over
Romney in Republican polls, was full of confidence but may be forced to
defend some blunt comments.
Using harsh language, he said Obama is an "abject liar" if he believes the U.S. border with Mexico is stronger.
And Perry declared Social Security a "Ponzi scheme," the kind of comment
that Democrats can seize on as proof that the Texas governor would try
to dismantle the popular government-run retirement program.
"Anybody that's for the status quo with Social Security today is
involved with a monstrous lie to our kids, and it's not right," said
It was up to former Massachusetts Governor Romney to defend the popular
entitlement program for seniors and allow him to appeal to independent
voters who may well decide the 2012 election.
"You can't say that to tens of millions of Americans who live on Social Security and those who have lived on it," Romney said.
The Perry-Romney fireworks largely overshadowed the six other candidates
in the debate, reducing almost to spectators Minnesota Congresswoman
Michele Bachmann, seen as the third-placed contender, and the gaggle of
other longshot candidates.
The debate at the Ronald Reagan presidential library, a shrine to the
Republican president, was the first in a series in the next six weeks
likely to help define the Republican race with early voting states to
begin choosing early next year.
"Basically this is another affirmation that the race has become a
two-man contest," said Matthew Dowd, a former campaign strategist for
President George W. Bush. "Perry met the threshold and Romney stays in."
Of Bachmann, Dowd said: "she disappeared off the podium."
The event, sponsored by NBC News and Politico, was only minutes old when
Perry charged Romney with having one of the worst records creating jobs
in Massachusetts in history.
This was an attempt to undermine Romney's argument that he can rebuild
the U.S. economy better than the struggling Obama. The president is to
unveil a jobs plan on Thursday to try to bring down America's
chronically high unemployment rate, the main issue in the 2012 campaign.
"As a matter of fact, we created more jobs in the last three months in
Texas than he created in four years in Massachusetts," Perry said,
fending off a question over whether many of those Texas jobs are low
"Wait a second," Romney interjected when the moderator sought to ask
another question. Romney said Perry benefited from vast reserves of oil
in a state that has no income tax, unlike Massachusetts.
"Governor Perry doesn't believe that he created those things," Romney
said. "If he tried to say those things, it would be like Al Gore saying
he invented the Internet. The reality is there are differences between
states. I came into a state that was in real trouble... I'm proud of
what we were able to do in a tough situation."
Democrat Gore was famously forced to defend himself during the 2000
presidential campaign for saying he helped create the Internet.
Perry fired back, comparing Romney to Democrat Michael Dukakis, the
former governor of Massachusetts who lost the presidential campaign in
1988 to Republican George H.W. Bush.
"Michael Dukakis created jobs three times faster than you did, Mitt," Perry said.
The exchange showed Perry capable of defending himself among rivals trying to knock him off his perch.
"I kind of feel like the pinata here," Perry said when Bachmann challenged him.
Obama may well have been the pinata as well as the candidates repeatedly questioned his economic policies.
In praising Obama for the successful mission in which al Qaeda leader
Osama bin Laden was killed, Perry hit Obama over high government
spending, and Romney declared Obama in over his head on the economy.
"We have a crisis in confidence in part because we have an absence of leadership," said Romney.
Romney shied away from aligning himself directly as a member of the Tea
Party, the conservative movement that has been a driving force in
Republican politics over the past year. This further reflected an
attempt not to alienate independent voters.
"If the Tea Party is for keeping government small and spending down and
helping us create jobs then, hey, I'm for the Tea Party," he said.