Benny Gantz meets with chief rabbis.
(photo credit: IDF)
Chief Rabbis Shlomo Amar and Yona Metzger met with IDF Chief of General Staff Lt.- Gen. Benny Gantz on Sunday afternoon, in a traditional annual meeting ahead of the High Holy Days, and raised with him the matter of exempting religious male soldiers from events involving women singing.
RELATED:After Galant debacle, Benny Gantz set to be named IDF
According to Jewish law, men should not listen to women singing in person, an injunction known as kol isha.
Talking at the Chief Rabbinate headquarters in the capital, the rabbis asked that unit commanders and officers be sensitive to the religious beliefs of Orthodox soldiers and allow them to absent themselves or leave such events in a respectful manner.
Gantz told the rabbis that he was reviewing the issue and would soon discuss it with the IDF Chief Rabbi Brig.-Gen. Rafi Peretz.
The topic was raised in light of an incident last week in which nine
officer cadets left an army event involving a performance by female
soldiers, and some subsequently refused to return after their unit
commander ordered them to do so. Four of the soldiers were expelled from
the Officers Training School – better known as Bahd 1 – after refusing
to apologize for the incident.
Following Sunday’s meeting, the social freedom organization Yisrael
Hofshit criticized the chief rabbis’ request and called on the Military
Rabbinate to ensure that the army does not promote the “degradation and
exclusion of women.”
“IDF commanders fail to understand that giving legitimacy to the
silencing of women is another step in the attempts of religious
extremists to turn the State of Israel and the army into dark places in
which women do not enjoy equal rights,” the organization said in a
statement, adding that the chief rabbis’ demand was part of a broader
radicalization of religious life in the country.
In response to the dismissal of the cadets, The Legal Forum for Eretz
Yisrael, a group promoting Jewish religious and national rights, called
on Sunday for the IDF to cancel the expulsion of the soldiers from the
officers course, saying in a letter that religious soldiers have the
right to excuse themselves from leisure activities that contravene their
The forum called for the officers who ordered the dismissal to be
prosecuted, saying that the decision was a “severe and unjustified
injury to the freedom of religion of IDF soldiers,” and adding that if
the cadets were not reinstated the forum would consider filing a
petition with the High Court of Justice.
Gantz, Amar and Metzger also discussed the integration of women in the
IDF and ways to minimize tensions arising from religiously observant
soldiers serving in combat units with female soldiers. The Artillery
Corps this year transferred two female soldiers from their unit due to
the planned arrival of a group of yeshiva students.
Amar and Metzger also expressed concern regarding an incident last
Wednesday in which military vehicles on an IDF base north of Ramallah
were damaged in a “price tag” attack carried out, ostensibly, by
extremist settlers after the IDF and Border Police demolished three
illegally built homes in the Migron settlement outpost.
The rabbis told Gantz that “this is not the way of Jewish tradition and religion.”
Gantz presented the chief rabbis with two silver pomegranates,
expressing his desire that these would be the only kind of rimonim
Hebrew for both pomegranates and grenades) that the Jewish people would
have to make use of in the coming year. In turn, the rabbis gave Gantz a