Raphael Golb with attorney in court 311 AP.
(photo credit: AP)
NEW YORK — A New York lawyer was sentenced Thursday to six months in jail for an ultramodern crime that was all about antiquity: using online aliases to harass people in an academic debate about the Dead Sea Scrolls.
RELATED:Google plans to offer Dead Sea Scrolls online US lawyer convicted in Dead Sea Scrolls case
Raphael Golb, 50, was sentenced on identity theft and other charges in a rare criminal case centered on Internet impersonation — and a very rare trial that aired a bitter scholarly debate over the scrolls' origins.
The top count was punishable by up to four years in prison. Golb has said he plans to appeal.
Golb's father is a historian and Dead Sea Scrolls scholar. Prosecutors said Golb used fake e-mail accounts and wrote blog posts under assumed names to discredit his father's detractors.
"Using fictitious identities to impersonate victims is not what open
academic debate seeks to foster," District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr.
said when Golb was convicted.
Golb said the writings amounted to academic whistle-blowing and pointed parody, not crime.
"My purpose was to expose the pattern of unethical conduct in the field of studies," he told jurors during his trial.
Found in caves in Israel beginning in the 1940s, the scrolls contain the
earliest known versions of portions of the Hebrew Bible. They have
provided important insight into the history of Judaism and the
beginnings of Christianity.
Some scholars, including New York University Judaic studies chairman
Lawrence Schiffman, say the texts were assembled by a sect known as the
Essenes. Others — including Norman Golb, a University of Chicago
historian and Golb's father — believe the writings were the work of a
range of Jewish groups and communities.
Schiffman went to authorities after some of his students and colleagues
received e-mails from an address that used his name. The e-mails
appeared to have him admitting that he plagiarized Norman Golb's work
and asking the recipients to keep quiet about it. Schiffman denies
copying the historian's work.
Raphael Golb, a linguistics scholar and lawyer with degrees from Oberlin
College, Harvard University and NYU, acknowledged during his trial that
he wrote the messages. But he said he never intended for anyone to
believe Schiffman actually sent them and portrayed them as "satire,
Internet impersonation claims have generated a number of lawsuits, but
prosecutions are unusual unless phony identities are used to steal
money, experts say.
In one notable case, Missouri mother Lori Drew was accused of helping
her daughter and a friend pose as a teen boy on MySpace to send hurtful
messages to a 13-year-old neighbor girl. The girl committed suicide.
A federal jury in California, where MySpace has its servers, convicted
Drew of misdemeanor counts of accessing computers without authorization.
A judge overturned the verdict and acquitted her.