'Collective punishment needed in light of W. Bank terror'

Kiryat Arba Chief Rabbi Dov Lior says Asher Hillel Palmer and infant son who died when car overturned on Route 60 killed by "rioters."

Funeral of Kiryat Arba car accident victims 311 (photo credit: Ben Hartman)
Funeral of Kiryat Arba car accident victims 311
(photo credit: Ben Hartman)
Kiryat Arba's Chief Rabbi Dov Lior on Sunday called for collective punishment for the "rioters" that he said killed Hillel Palmer, 25, and his one-year-old son Yonatan in the West Bank on Friday.
Palmer and his infant son Yonatan died when their car overturned on Route 60 outside Kiryat Arba on Friday, in what police and the army suspect was a terror attack. "There are murderous rioters around us," he said. "According to the Torah, there is a need for collective punishment, and the IDF must carry this out against the rioters. The are no innocent people in war," he continued.

Man, baby killed when car overturns near Kiryat Arba
'IDF not telling truth about fatal W. Bank car accident'
Over a thousand people crowded a parking lot in Kiryat Arba on Sunday evening, to bid farewell to Palmer and his infant son Yonatan.
Asher’s brother-in-law, Aharon Peretz told the mourners “Asher you were my beloved, noble brother in law. Yonatan, my nephew, people used to stop me in the street and say what a little angel your sister has; with eyes as blue as the heavens, a baby that at only 10 months old started to walk. Asher, the love of my heart, always spoke softly, always with a pure heart.”
His voice cracking as he burst into tears, Peretz added “I want to tell you one thing, we promise you that we will take care of your mother Yonatan, we will take care of her, and we will try as much as possible to make sure that you are happy up in heaven with how we take care of her. And we want you to make sure to protect her and us from up above as well. We love you and miss you every second.”
After the eulogies ended, mourners carried the body of Asher and a tiny prayer shawl carrying Yonatan to a waiting van, in which they were taken for burial at the Jewish cemetery in Hebron.
Controversy and anger surrounds the incident, in that after the accident security services said there was suspicion that the accident may have been caused by stone-throwers, a statement that was later retracted, only to emerge again on Sunday. Across the settlements of Judea and Samaria, voices were claiming that security officials covered up the stone-throwing in order to prevent “price tag” actions by settlers on the same day that the Palestinians were presenting their statehood bid at the United Nations.
Details of the incident began to emerge on Sunday, after the family of Palmer, 25, reached an agreement with the state to allow for blood samples to be taken from his body and that of Yonatan, in order to determine the cause of death. Palmer's family had initially refused the state permission to conduct an autopsy on the bodies, and the state petitioned the Jerusalem Magistrates' Court against the family's decision. When the court refused the petition, the state immediately appealed the lower court's ruling directly in the High Court of Justice.
The High Court issued a temporary injunction delaying the Magistrates' Court ruling ahead of a hearing scheduled for Sunday, but the hearing was cut short after both sides reached an agreement that blood samples could be taken from the bodies.
Police Spokesman Micky Rosenfeld said Sunday that “based on finding of the external autopsy, the main direction of the investigation is that he [Palmer] was hit by a stone which caused him to lose control of the vehicle.”
Rosenfeld added that police found the stone, but that they don’t know when it was thrown at the car and the investigation is still ongoing.
The IDF spokesperson’s office said Sunday evening that their findings have reached the conclusion that stones were not thrown at the car from the side of the road, but that findings that have turned up since then have raised the possibility that a stone was thrown at the vehicle from a passing car. They added that it is still under investigation.
Anger at the incident was palpable on the way to Kiryat Arba on Sunday, where traffic crawled to a half for several kilometers while clashes broke out between settler youth and Palestinians next to the Palestinian village of Beit Anoun. In addition, well over a hundred people took part in a protest held at the site of the accident on Sunday afternoon, before marching to Kiryat Arba.
Head of the Kiryat Arba local council Malachi Levinger said Sunday that “there must be an investigation into why the police changed their story within less than 48 hours. The rock-throwing, which is a growing phenomenon in recent days has become unbearable. We are demanding that security forces work to completely end this phenomenon which constitutes a mortal threat not only to human lives but also harms the honor of the state and its citizens.”