Yeshiva Stipends Protest 311.
(photo credit: courtesy of the National Union of Israeli Students)
Five weeks after the government approved the continued payment of stipends to
kollel students for a newly limited five years, seven religious advocacy, public
advocacy and student groups filed a petition on Sunday to the High Court of
Justice demanding that it prevent the Education Ministry from continuing to pay
allowances to unemployed kollel students.
The National Union of Israel
Student, Hiddush – For Religious Freedom and Equality, Masorti (Conservative)
movement and Reform movement spearheaded the petition that claimed that the
recent government decision is a “foolish and unacceptable attempt to circumvent
the High Court of Justice ruling.” In June, the court ruled that the government
could not continue paying stipends solely to haredim who study full-time, while
others – such as university students – are ineligible for similar stipends, and
determined that these payments must end as of 2011.
Controversial kollel stipend bill likely to fall
Violence mars student demo against kollel stipend bill
The court on Sunday
afternoon rejected the petitioners demand to issue an interim order halting the
payments, and gave the state 30 days to respond.
Under the plan approved
in December, however, kollel students under the age of 29 with three children,
whose income doesn’t exceed NIS 1,200 and who do not own a car, will receive a
stipend of NIS 1,040 a month for four years. In the fifth year – the so-called
“integration” year – the student will receive 75 percent of that amount and be
allowed to study half-time, and work half-time. After that, he will be expected
to enter the workforce. Another NIS 20 million will be set aside for some 2,000
yeshiva students – expected to be the most astute at their studies – who will be
allowed to continue studying past the five-year period.
arrangement is almost completely identical to the arrangement that was
disqualified by the court,” the petitioners charged on Sunday, saying that it
should be immediately called off.
Since the 1980s, the state had entitled
a modest stipend to kollel students whose wives were also unemployed and have at
least three children, and matched additional stipulations such as not owning a
car or leaving the country. The old arrangement, which was applicable in the
year 2010 to some 13,000 households at an approximate cost of NIS 135m., did not
limit the number of years a haredi kollel student could receive the
Chairman of the National Student Union Itzik Shmuli said that
“the government miserably failed the ethic and legal test, and we are therefore
petitioning the court, to force it to once again to tell the state its opinion
on the tricky scheme it pulled off at the expense of the public. The kollel
student arrangement is wrong and discriminatory, and we will continue to
struggle against it in the public and legal realms.”
Rabbi Uri Regev said that “instead of forming a policy that corresponds to the
fundamental values of democracy, the government is forcing the public to once
again turn to the court for help.”
Head of the Reform Movement Rabbi
Gilad Kariv called the government’s decision to continue the payments “moral,
social, governmental and economic bankruptcy.
The Israeli government and
the haredi politicos are ensnaring thousands of families in poverty traps... we
hope the court will draw a red line against the continued discrimination, and
indicate to the government and haredi parties that this celebration at the
expense of the public has reached its end.”