beersheba real estate 58.
(photo credit: Courtesy)
Just like any living organism, an economy – or a given segment of it – can catch
fever. For a long time the thermometer has been pointing to spiking temperatures
in Israel’s real estate sector, where prices have soared by a dizzying 19% in
the past 12 months alone.
RELATED:EU approves data protection agreement with Israel
This is a radical shift Israel cannot afford to
overlook. As in physiology, one ailing organ affects the
The American experience, which generated the subprime crisis of
2008 and subsequent global recession, is a case in point. Some of the symptoms
presented in our mortgage markets of late are similar and, if unchecked, could
trigger dire consequences, even if not quite the US disaster.
mortgage system is fundamentally different from that of the United States. For a
start, it is impossible for someone buying his first home to obtain a loan that
covers 100 percent of the property’s value. Buyers have to come up with a
substantial down payment, and they may be asked for guarantors.
transactions today are relatively more leveraged than they they used to be, and
interest rates over the past two years have been at historic lows. It’s a
situation that entices many to take out whopping mortgages by local
The danger is that some borrowers may be getting in way over
their heads, and won’t be able to keep up the monthly payments on their
floating-rate mortgages in the event of interest rate hikes, which are probably
inevitable. This is a risky situation for the borrowers, for the lenders (the
banks) and, down the line, for the entire economy.
One of the culprits
overheating the housing market is low interest. This week, Bank of Israel
Governor Stanley Fischer felt he had to prescribe at least a temporary
palliative designed to make large mortgages less attractive, even if only by a
minuscule symbolic degree.
He could have achieved this by raising
interest rates, but that’s problematic, too. Low as our rates are (2%), they are
still higher than the near-zero elsewhere, most notably in the US. That makes
the Israeli currency attractive to speculators worldwide. It pays them to buy
shekels and derive greater interest here than they would abroad. This boosts the
shekel’s value, making Israeli products and services more expensive in the
international marketplace and, accordingly, less competitive. Israeli
exports are hurt and jobs are lost.
Hence there was no way Fischer was
going to raise interest rates just as the shekel is soaring in value against the
plummeting dollar. Instead, he jacked up the cost of big mortgages based on
variable interest rates.
Fischer’s direct targets are the banks, and the
logic is to cool their ardor to lend liberally at rock-bottom rates (for now).
He has made the mortgage business marginally less profitable for the banks and
more expensive for their clients.
The banks will be obliged to back up
with capital 100% of the value of any loan that covers more than 60% of the
property price, or is over NIS 800,000, or if 25% or more of the loan is at
variable interest. Thus there will be a reduction in the amount of bank funds
that will be available for loans.
The aim isn’t to punish home-buyers,
least of all first-time home-buyers. The aim is to save them from themselves
where necessary; to keep them from making grievous errors.
under any illusion that this step in itself will suffice to reduce home prices.
Israelis are used to exorbitant costs and might not be put off by small
increases. Anyone taking out a mortgage for less than 60% of the property
value would be unaffected, as would borrowers opting for fixed interest or not
exceeding the NIS 800,000 limit. The new measures are mostly meant as
disincentives for real-estate investors out to make a bundle via highly
The genuine, long-term cure lies in upping supply
rather than curtailing demand. That isn’t possible in the already choc-full,
ultra-desirable central region. So population dispersion is the call of the
For now, the “periphery” of the country remains relatively
uninviting due to its distance from employment opportunities, commercial centers
and cultural hubs. Plainly these prohibitive distances need shrinking,
via credible infrastructure projects and fast rail lines.
eminently doable, though it will take time, and the construction itself will
become a growth engine and job-creator.
Such an effort would pay for
itself. And the sooner the better.
Join Jerusalem Post Premium Plus now for just $5 and upgrade your experience with an ads-free website and exclusive content. Click here>>