We independently evaluate all recommended products and services.
If you click on the links we provide, we may receive compensation.

10 Most Popular Murder Mystery Board Games for 2023

Unleash your inner detective with the thrilling Murder Mystery Board Game! Compare the best options and bring your game night to life.

 10 Most Popular Murder Mystery Board Games for 2023 (photo credit: PR)
10 Most Popular Murder Mystery Board Games for 2023
(photo credit: PR)

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Hunt A Killer Body On The Boardwalk
Jump to Review
Hunt A Killer Death at the Dive Bar Game
Jump to Review
Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars
Jump to Review
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Board Game.
Jump to Review
Hunt A Killer Murder at The Motel.

Looking for a new way to entertain yourself and your friends? Look no further than Murder Mystery Board Games! Our team has spent countless hours researching and testing various options to bring you the best in the market. These games offer an immersive experience that transports players to a world of mystery and intrigue, perfect for game nights with friends and family.

When choosing the right game, consider factors such as complexity, number of players, and quality of materials. Our top ranking products offer a diverse range of options that cater to all preferences and skill levels, with customer feedback taken into account. Keep in mind that some games may not be appropriate for younger audiences or those sensitive to themes of murder and deception. Overall, Murder Mystery Board Games offer a unique and exciting way to socialize and bond with loved ones.

1

Hunt A Killer Body On The Boardwalk

Hunt A Killer Body On The Boardwalk
Hunt A Killer Body On The Boardwalk

Hunt A Killer Body On The Boardwalk is the perfect immersive murder mystery game for anyone looking for a challenging and exciting experience. With its unsolved case and multiple suspects, this game provides hours of entertainment for independent challenge, date night, or fun with family and friends. Suitable for ages 14 and up, this game is sure to keep you on your toes as you work to solve the mystery and catch the culprit. The quality of the materials and attention to detail make this game a great investment for lovers of the mystery genre.

Rated 9.7 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Immersive murder mystery game, Great for date night or with family and friends, Challenging and engaging gameplay
Cons
May not be suitable for children under 14

2

Hunt A Killer Death at the Dive Bar Game

Hunt A Killer Death at the Dive Bar Game
Hunt A Killer Death at the Dive Bar Game

Hunt A Killer Death at The Dive Bar is an immersive murder mystery game that challenges players to solve an unsolved case. Perfect for a night in with friends or a family game night, this game provides hours of entertainment for detectives ages 14+. With clues, puzzles, and a compelling storyline, Death at the Dive Bar is a great way to exercise your problem-solving skills and have fun at the same time. So gather your team and get ready to dive deep into the mystery!

Rated 9.6 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Immersive murder mystery game, Challenging and exciting gameplay, Great for group activities
Cons
Not suitable for young children

3

Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars
Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

University Games Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars is a thrilling detective game that can be played alone or with friends, family, or couples. Suitable for ages 14+, this game is perfect for those who love solving mysteries and playing detective. The game includes everything you need to host a fun and engaging murder mystery party, including clues, suspect profiles, and more. With a compelling storyline and challenging clues, this game will keep you and your guests entertained for hours. So, put your detective skills to the test and solve the murder at Underwood Cellars!

Rated 9.1 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Great for game night, Engaging murder mystery, Suitable for different group sizes
Cons
May require additional materials

4

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Board Game.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Board Game.
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Board Game.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective - The Thames Murders & Other Cases Board Game is an exciting and captivating mystery game that is perfect for kids and adults alike. With a playtime of around 90 minutes, this game is sure to keep you engaged and entertained. The game is made by Space Cowboys and can be played by 1-8 players who are aged 14 and above. The game is a great way to spend an evening with friends and family, and is sure to keep you on the edge of your seat as you try to solve the cases. The game includes a range of technical specifications, such as the size and weight of the components, which are sure to impress even the most discerning of players.

Rated 9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Captivating mystery game, Suitable for kids & adults, 1-8 players
Cons
Complex gameplay

5

Hunt A Killer Murder at The Motel.

Hunt A Killer Murder at The Motel.
Hunt A Killer Murder at The Motel.

Hunt A Killer Murder at The Motel is an immersive murder mystery game that allows players to take on an unsolved case as an independent challenge, for date night or with family and friends. Designed for detectives aged 14 and up, this game offers an exciting and unique way to spend an evening. With clues, puzzles, and evidence to sift through, players will feel like they're part of a real investigation. The game is perfect for those who enjoy solving puzzles and mysteries, and for anyone looking for a fun and engaging way to spend time with loved ones.

Rated 8.5 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Immersive murder mystery game, Challenging and engaging, Great for date night or family/friends
Cons
May not be suitable for children under 14

6

Deception Murder in Hong Kong Board Game

Deception Murder in Hong Kong Board Game
Deception Murder in Hong Kong Board Game

Grey Fox Games Deception: Murder in Hong Kong Board Game is a fast-paced murder mystery game that takes 20 minutes to play with 4-12 players, age 14+. The game challenges players to identify the murderer among them while using forensic evidence and deduction. This game is perfect for those who love to solve mysteries and test their detective skills. The game is made of high-quality materials and includes 200 clue cards, 90 means cards, 6 badge cards, 6 role cards, and more. It's a great addition to any game night and is sure to keep players engaged and entertained for hours.

Rated 8.4 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Fast-paced murder mystery, Suitable for large groups, Encourages deduction skills
Cons
Not suitable for young players

7

Hunt A Killer Dead Below Deck Game

Hunt A Killer Dead Below Deck Game
Hunt A Killer Dead Below Deck Game

Hunt A Killer Dead Below Deck is a murder mystery game that is perfect for true crime fans. The game provides documents and puzzles that players must solve to uncover the killer on a yacht. This game is great for game night or date night and will keep players engaged for hours. The game is designed for adults and provides a challenging and entertaining experience. It is a must-have for anyone who loves solving mysteries and enjoys a good challenge.

Rated 8.1 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Engaging murder mystery game, Realistic clues and documents, Perfect for game night or date night
Cons
May be too intense for some

8

Murder Mystery Party Case Files Death in Antarctica

Murder Mystery Party Case Files Death in Antarctica
Murder Mystery Party Case Files Death in Antarctica

The Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Death in Antarctica is a thrilling detective game that can be played by one or more players aged 14 and up. This game is perfect for anyone who loves solving mysteries and enjoys a good challenge. The game comes complete with all the materials needed to set the scene for a murder mystery in the icy wilderness of Antarctica. The game is easy to set up and provides hours of entertainment for players who want to put their detective skills to the test.

Rated 7.6 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Suitable for 1+ players, Challenging and engaging gameplay, Great for hosting parties
Cons
May not be suitable for children under 14 years old

9

Hunt A Killer Mystery at Magnolia Gardens

Hunt A Killer Mystery at Magnolia Gardens
Hunt A Killer Mystery at Magnolia Gardens

The Hunt A Killer Mystery at Magnolia Gardens is the perfect game for family game night or date night. This murder mystery game comes with documents and puzzles to help you solve a Nancy Drew-style mystery. Suitable for ages 14 and up, this game is great for both adults and kids. With its engaging storyline and challenging puzzles, it's sure to keep you entertained for hours. So gather your family and friends, and get ready to solve a crime!

Rated 7.4 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Engaging mystery game, Fun for family game night, Includes documents and puzzles
Cons
Age limit of 14+ only

10

Hasbro Gaming Clue Board Game Robbery at The Museum

Hasbro Gaming Clue Board Game Robbery at The Museum
Hasbro Gaming Clue Board Game Robbery at The Museum

The Clue Board Game Robbery at The Museum is a thrilling and challenging game that is perfect for anyone who loves escape room games and murder mysteries. Designed for 1-6 players aged 10 and up, this cooperative family board game is great for Halloween parties or any other occasion. With its engaging storyline and clever clues, players must work together to solve the mystery and escape the museum before time runs out. The game includes all the necessary pieces and instructions, and is sure to provide hours of fun and excitement.

Rated 7.1 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Cooperative gameplay, Great for Halloween parties, Multiple game modes
Cons
Limited replay value

FAQ

Q: What is a murder mystery board game?

A: A murder mystery board game is a type of game where players take on the role of detectives and try to solve a fictitious murder case. The game typically involves clues, suspects, and a storyline that players must follow in order to solve the mystery.

Q: How many players are needed to play a murder mystery board game?

A: The number of players needed to play a murder mystery board game can vary depending on the game. Some games can be played with just two players, while others may require a larger group of players.

Q: What makes a good murder mystery board game?

A: A good murder mystery board game should have a well-crafted storyline, interesting characters, and challenging clues and puzzles. It should also be easy to understand and play, and have enough replay value to keep players engaged over multiple plays. Additionally, the game should be designed to keep players engaged and invested in the outcome of the mystery.

Conclusions

In reviewing several Murder Mystery Board Games, we used a strict methodology to ensure accuracy and relevancy for our readers. Our research revealed that the Murder Mystery Board Game category is a popular and engaging way to bring friends and family together for a night of fun and intrigue. Each game we reviewed brought a unique twist to the genre, with varying levels of complexity and player involvement. We encourage readers to consider these games for their next game night and see which one suits their group best.