Actress Angelina Jolie’s decision to undergo a radical mastectomy to minimize
her risk of breast cancer from her inherited BRCA mutation aroused numerous
views in Israel on Thursday.
Prof. Ephrat Levy-Lahad, director of the
medical genetics department at Jerusalem’s Shaare Zedek Medical Center,
commented on the story, “I think it is wonderful and courageous of her to be
going public with her being a carrier and her decision to have a bilateral
mastectomy for risk reduction. I am sure it will do a great deal to raise
women’s awareness of being tested for cancer risk due to BRCA1 and BRCA2
“The fact that a beauty icon is willing to undergo bilateral
mastectomy also legitimizes this choice, and shows that it is not a sign of
reduced femininity, or a crazy thing to do,” said Levy-Lahad, who regularly
counsels women with the mutations.
“That being said, it is important to
remember that risk reduction mastectomy is a personal choice even for BRCA1 and
BRCA2 carriers, and it is not an absolute medical indication. Yes, it does offer
the greatest risk reduction, but, removal of the ovaries [oophorectomy] and
fallopian tubes by age 40 reduces breast cancer risk in carriers by 50 percent –
and this is a much simpler and internal procedure. Also, there are
effective surveillance measures for early breast cancer detection, and breast
cancer treatment is successful in most cases.”
The Shaare Zedek
geneticist added that “although Jolie’s operation highlights breast-cancer risk
reduction, the importance of ovary plus fallopian tube removal in carriers
should be reemphasized. For carriers, riskreduction oophorectomy
surveillance is necessary to prevent the high risk of ovarian cancer, which is a
lethal disease that is with no effective early detection.”
Shlomit Shadmon Sayag, an expert in women’s health and a member of the Family
Physicians Association, also commented on the Jolie case.
shown that radical mastectomy and/or oophorectomy for women carrying the BRCA1/2
genetic mutation can reduce the risk of getting breast cancer by 50% to 85%. The
recommendation is very significant for the women, as there is risk of a sharp
reduction in such a woman’s female hormones and quick entry to menopause, with
hot flashes, night sweating and sleeplessness. The effects on body image are
smaller. But the decision to undergo surgery, even with restoration of the
breasts, is very difficult,” said Sayag.
“One must have a long discussion
with the woman, her partner and other family members to make the conscious
The family physician described a case, however, of a woman who
did decide to undergo surgery and was very pleased with her choice. She
underwent plastic surgery to restore the natural look of her body and was
relieved of her terror of getting breast cancer.
Angelina Jolie, who did it and turned into an ambassador for radical mastectomy
to prevent the disease, thereby telling the whole world about what she
Levy-Lahad was joined in her views by Prof. Mary- Claire King, a
worldrenowned geneticist at the University of Washington and the discoverer of
the BRCA1 gene mutation.
Jerusalem Post Annual Conference. Buy it now, Special offer. Come meet Israel's top leaders