BERLIN – The Jerusalem-based watchdog organization NGO Monitor sharply criticized
a large German foundation on Wednesday for funding left-leaning online magazine
+972 .
Heinrich Böll Stiftung, a German think-tank affiliated with the
Green Party, provided 6,000 euros to the magazine, which uses Israel’s
international calling code number as its title.
Professor Gerald
Steinberg, head of NGO Monitor, told The Jerusalem Post that “Heinrich Böll’s
decision to support +972 fulfills no humanitarian purpose and does not foster
peace and mutual understanding.”
He continued that Böll “cannot justify
funding an online magazine that targets English speakers and routinely presents
biased, one-sided perspectives on the Arab-Israeli conflict. This funding helps
provide a platform used to demonize Israel. +972 reporters and bloggers, for
example, invoke the hateful ‘apartheid’ analogy. Why is German taxpayer funding
going to this counterproductive activity?”
+972 is a blog-based web magazine
that is jointly owned by a group of Israeli journalists and bloggers, whose
goal, they say is to “to provide fresh, original, on-the-ground reporting and
analysis of events in Israel and Palestine.”
One contributor, Haggai
Matar, wrote in +972 blog in January, “Dozens of Popular Committee activists
gathered in Jericho for a ‘freedom ride’: an attempt to drive their cars to
Ramallah on the fast lanes of the apartheid roads meant for Israelis
only.”
Critics, including NGO Monitor, have argued that applying the term
apartheid to Israel meets the criteria of modern anti-Semitism because it seeks
to strip the Jewish state of its legitimacy.
When asked whether the Böll
Foundation considers the comparison anti-Semitic, its spokeswoman Karoline
Richter told the Post that Böll sees the apartheid application as part of
“critical solidarity with Israel,” and the think tank does not want to censor
+972.
Ralf Fücks, head of the Böll Foundation, wrote in a statement to
the Post, “While the Heinrich Böll Foundation does not agree with each opinion
expressed in individual contributions to the site, it has not and will not
interfere in the content for its conviction for freedom of the
press.”
“In this context, our grant to 972mag.com is part of a
differentiated and pluralistic agenda we are following in Israel,” he
added.
+972 did not immediately answer a Post query.
Steinberg
said, “Contrary to Böll’s claims, +972 presents a one-sided, highly distorted
view of the complex Arab- Israeli conflict. Such interference in the internal
affairs of another sovereign state is a blatant violation of democratic
norms.”
Meanwhile, the German Shoah Foundation EVZ cut its financial
support for Zochrot, an Israeli NGO that supports nakba. The Palestinians use
the word nakba (Arabic for catastrophe) to reject Israel’s existence and to
commemorate an estimated 700,000 Palestinians who fled during the 1948 War of
Independence.
Steinberg said, “This is a significant victory in the
battle to hold funders accountable for their support of NGOs involved in
demonization. Zochrot, a radical Israeli NGO, supports the Palestinian
claim to a ‘Right of Return’ – which has no legal basis and would end the
existence of Israel as the Jewish nation-state – endorsed the violent ‘Free Gaza
Flotilla,’ and falsely accused Israel of ‘ethnic cleansing’ and ‘forcible
displacement and dispossession of the Palestinian people.’”
In an e-mail to the
Post on Wednesday, Eugen Esau, a spokesman for EVZ, wrote that “the support for
the projects from Zochrot contractually ended on December 31, 2011.”