An adviser to the Lebanese prime minister said Tuesday that the
suspension of $100 million in US aid to the Lebanese Armed Forces was
unwarranted, and weakens the nation's effort to build the country's army.
Mohamed Chatah, an adviser to Western-backed Prime Minister Saad Hariri,
said Tuesday that the Lebanese forces are reliable. He said any "friend
of Lebanon" should not take steps that would hurt efforts to build up
Enforce international law in LebanonEditorial: US
has it wrong on Lebanon
The US Congress is blocking funding to the Lebanese military
following a cross-border shooting attack on Israeli soldiers last week amidst
concern it is cooperating with Hizbullah.
“This incident was tragic and
entirely avoidable,” Rep. Nita Lowey (D-New York) said Monday. “US
assistance is intended to enhance our safety and that of our
Lowey chairs the House appropriations subcommittee that
authorizes such funds.
The $100 million in Lebanese military assistance
approved for 2010 has yet to be disbursed, giving her a window to put the
funding on hold for the immediate future.
Lowey is looking to find out
more about the nature of what she termed an “outrageous incident,” as well as
watching how Lebanon responds in the wake of the violence.
are typically dependent on the actions and rhetoric coming out of the relevant
nations,” a Democratic aide noted.
Similarly, House Foreign Affairs
Chairman Howard Berman (D-California) also applied a hold, citing more general
concerns about “reported Hizbullah influence on the Lebanese Armed
Forces.”Congressman calls for information on Hizbullah's role in LAF
Berman entered his hold the day before the deadly incident, he
said Monday, which only confirmed his reservations.
His office also wants
more information on Hizbullah’s role in the LAF, how diligently US weapons are
kept track of and how well the LAF cooperates with UNIFIL.
“Until we know
more about this incident and the nature of Hizbullah influence on the LAF – and
can assure that the LAF is a responsible actor – I cannot in good conscience
allow the United States to continue sending weapons to Lebanon,” Berman
Last Tuesday, Lebanese Armed Forces soldiers shot at Israeli
officers while brush was being cleared along the northern border; one officer
was killed and another seriously wounded. The IDF returned fire, killing at
least two Lebanese soldiers and a journalist.
A State Department official
said the US was still trying to ascertain the facts of the incident, including
whether there was any truth behind reports that the LAF troops were using
“We consistently review all of our security
assistance programs to all receiving countries,” the official said. “Ultimately,
we continue to believe that our support to the LAF and ISF [Internal Security
Forces] will contribute toward improving regional security.”
that the funding was “part of an international effort to help strengthen the
institutions of the Lebanese state. We have provided support to Lebanon to
strengthen the ability of the Lebanese government to exercise its own
sovereignty.”Additional $100 m. was requested before incident occured
LAF funding approved for 2009 and already in the pipeline
is being distributed by the US as scheduled. Another $100 million had already
been requested by the Obama administration for 2011 and considered by Lowey’s
subcommittee before the incident occurred.
That money could also be
affected when Congress reconvenes from its summer recess in September.
Monday, Rep. Eric Cantor (R-Virginia), the House minority whip, called for
2011’s funding to be blocked until the incident was investigated and it was
clear that the Lebanese military wasn’t collaborating with
“The LAF’s unprovoked attack on the Israeli defense forces in
undisputed Israeli territory demands a sweeping reassessment of how we
distribute our foreign aid,” Cantor declared in a statement.
of the assistance was to build up a Lebanese fighting force that would serve as
a check on the growing power of the radical Islamist Hizbullah movement,” he
noted, referring to hundreds of millions of dollars the US has already spent
training and equipping the LAF in recent years.
“For the past few years,
the US and the international community looked the other way as the lines between
Hizbullah and the Lebanese military and government became blurred,” he charged.
“But the days of ignoring the LAF’s provocations against Israel and protection
of Hizbullah in southern Lebanon are over.”
Separately, the US is also
looking to boost the military capabilities of Saudi Arabia, with a reported $30
billion arms deal in the works.
The Saudis will be getting the advanced
F-15 fighter, although the jet will not have longrange weapons or other systems
that Israel has been wary about, according to a report in the Wall Street
Journal. Defense Minister Ehud Barak was recently in Washington for talks with
Defense Secretary Robert Gates and other top Pentagon officials, in which this
issue was understood to have figured prominently.
The US has also taken
steps to boost Israeli capabilities as part of maintaining its qualitative
military edge (QME), a stated American priority.
Part of the process
includes keeping Israel apprised of arms sales to its enemies and giving
Jerusalem opportunities to register objections, even if the sales go
“We have a good dialogue with the United States, and we’re
discussing how to maintain Israel’s QME,” said an Israeli official. “In that
framework these and other issues can be brought up.”