Late last week, the Modern Language Association, which has 30,000 members from
hundreds of colleges and universities, met in Chicago and provided a forum for
speakers who harshly criticized Israel in a panel titled “Academic Boycotts: A
Conversation about Israel and Palestine.” In a 60-53 vote, it passed a
resolution condemning Israel for denials of entry by US academics into the West
Bank – though it ultimately declined to consider a vote on an academic boycott
This comes as a few weeks ago, the American Studies
Association (ASA) voted to boycott Israeli universities and asked American
scholars to sever ties with Israeli academic institutions.
mainstream organizations have responded with shock and anger, both on at the
national level and in communities across the country. Here in Boston, the CJP,
JCRC, ADL and AJC joined together to issue a condemnation.
But to those
who’ve been paying attention to the growth of anti-Israelism on campus, the ASA
boycott was predictable.
For decades, a campus-based alliance of leftist
professors, “human rights” groups, purported “progressives” and Muslims built an
anti-Israel narrative that so overwhelmingly dominates university dialogue that
Jewish students who wish to defend Israel routinely face social and academic
penalties and even physical threats.
Harvard Law Prof. Alan Dershowitz
has been talking about this since 2000. Sooner or later, the assault on Israel,
which in 2005 took the form of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS)
movement, was going to capture one coven or another of “progressive
The ASA vote is simply the bursting of a long-festering
Jewish communal failure to stem the tide against Israel on American
campuses has many causes; among the more important is a flawed understanding of
anti-Israelism, which is a new and quite different form of anti-Semitism, and
which requires a unique response.
I have had countless conversations with
people of my generation who completely misunderstand the animus against Israel.
To so many of them it is simply and blatantly a matter of anti-Semitism, period.
They believe Israel is hated because it is the state of the Jews. But on
American campuses this is simply not the case: supporters of Israel are not
hectored by raucous rednecks screaming “Christ-killer” or by racists who think
Jews share DNA with rats; they are instructed about “Israeli evil” by
soft-spoken, high-toned and articulate professors who seem merely to want
justice for everyone.
Jews have to understand that anti-Israelism, and
its twin – Palestinianism – are derivatives not of traditional Jew hatred, but
of a more modern anti-Westernism, a product of Western intellectuals. They have
to understand that today’s animus comes overwhelmingly not from the Right, but
from the Left.
Pascal Bruckner’s book, The Tyranny of Guilt, offers a
brilliant description of this disease. He focuses on Europe, but the treatment
fits America as well. He cites European intellectuals that the general Jewish
public may not recognize, but it is the thinking of these people which has
trickled down onto American campuses.
Just ask your children.
cannot do this prescient book justice in a few paragraphs, but here’s a précis,
with quotes from the author: From beneath the West’s celebrated hedonism, and
its liberation from religious authority, Bruckner hears the hectoring cry:
“Repent!” The West is not liberated: it feels a heavy burden of guilt for its
past sins – colonialism, fratricide, racism, the Holocaust, for its hypocrisy
and mostly perhaps for its wealth. The West’s own intellectuals have come to
berate it, and hate it, and infect so many with their notions.
“all modern thought – from existentialism to deconstructionism – can be reduced
to a mechanical denunciation of the West” whose citizens are the beneficiaries
of a fabulous, but ill-begotten prosperity. Colonialism and militarism, and the
power they bring, unfairly privilege Europeans and Americans and keep Third
Worlders in poverty, powerless to rule their own lives. The only possible way
for a Westerner to redeem himself is through repentance, public contrition and
The average European, Bruckner writes, “is
always ready to shoulder the blame for the poverty of Africa or Asia, to assume
responsibility for the world’s problems.”
The same is true – or will be
true – in much of America, where the history book most widely used in high
schools is Howard Zinn’s book, A People’s History of the United States, which
teaches that America was born in sin, stealing the land from the Indians, and
steeped in racism, enslaving the blacks. America, the book argues, continues to
exploit innocent Third Worlders through a sophisticated imperialism.
parents will doubt that their college students feel guilt about their middle
class prosperity. But just ask them to explain why Middle Easterners, Asians and
Africans are so much poorer than we are. Then ask them if they think they
deserve to have so much more.
Many, the most sensitive perhaps, need a
way to come to terms with this inequity. The Left – often through public school
and campus curricula – teaches them the way.
As with Rousseau, Bruckner
explains, modern alienated Westerners, thinking about unmodern people, fantasize
of “noble savages” – unspoiled innocents whose natural and admirable lives
should be left untouched by Western exploiters. Today, the noblest savage – the
one who has come to represent the primary victim of Western malignance – is the
I imagine that in the minds of the leftist ASA boycotters,
one can find the fantasies of Georges Montaron, cited by Bruckner, who writes
that the “hero is the Fedayeen, the living image of the liberator, like Che
the Palestinian resistance is a flame that lights the way of
The international Left, having failed to win over the
working class, pivoted and invested its hopes in the anti-Western Third World,
but especially in the Arab/ Muslim world. Terrorist attacks on Western civilians
are ascribed by leftist professors to Arab/Muslim humiliation over the creation
of Israel. Islam has become, in the eyes of leftist “thinkers,” the “religion of
Noble savages have no agency: they cannot themselves be
racist, homophobic, anti-Semitic terrorists – because they are our victims and
they only act (justifiably!) in response to that. The 9/11 attackers are
described as poor wretches protesting against our insolent wealth, our way of
life, our predatory economy.
Jacques Derrida, a fixture of university
English Lit courses, explains that we Westerners are the real terrorists, as we
“let” people in the Third World die from AIDS. Again, the general reading public
may find this too bizarre to take seriously. This would be a big
Ask your kids.
People who support the Palestinians,
Bruckner writes, “are not so much engaged in inquiring into a specific
antagonism – a real estate dispute involving two equally legitimate owners – as
in settling accounts with Western culture.”
For middle class European and
American students, who cannot explain their own relative prosperity without
feeling guilt, Palestinianism can be a therapeutic.
By hating the primary
symbol of Western abomination, theft and cruel exploitation in the Middle East –
that is, by hating the Jews of Israel – they exonerate themselves. They wipe
away the sins of their own undeserved prosperity.
psychodrama, and the “intellectual” work behind it, can help us win the campus
We need to speak to those campus converts to
We need to show them gently how their need to feel
morally pure, to escape the moral taint their professors have imposed on them,
has them lionizing barbarism and abandoning true liberal principles.
the Palestinians suffer, we need to explain, but so much less than so many
others, and so much of this is due to their errors and conduct. We need to show
America’s youth that those Enlightenment ideas which have been so twisted could
mobilize people of courage and character to side with the Middle Easterners who
are most oppressed and threatened: today’s Christians, women, slaves, gays, and
yes, today’s Jews.The writer was named one of America’s top 50 Jewish
The Forward. He is the president of Americans for Peace and Tolerance
in Boston and is widely known.