The Haredi Public party won something important in Israel’s election, and the first step in explaining what it won is admitting how badly it lost. Party chairman Moti Leitner’s list drew roughly 10,000 votes and fell well short of entering the Knesset.
I worked closely with the party from its inception, and I had hoped for a very different result.
Nevertheless, I also saw what happened when haredim (ultra-Orthodox) who had long discussed enlistment, poverty, and education in private finally heard those issues raised by people who shared their way of life.
The campaign gave them a public voice and showed the rest of Israel that many haredim are willing to help solve problems too often discussed as though the community itself had nothing to offer.
The country heard a haredi leader acknowledge the burden on reservists and their families and argue for meaningful service in frameworks that respect haredi religious life.
It heard him argue that a young person can learn math and English, earn a dignified living, and remain deeply committed to Torah.
Furthermore, it heard him describe poverty in haredi families as a problem their own representatives have a responsibility to address. What was unprecedented was hearing them as a political program advanced by people prepared to make the case inside their own community.
Indeed, other seemingly impenetrable barriers were surpassed: having women on a haredi party list, and in the most prominent positions.
The issues that were raised put the established haredi parties, Shas and United Torah Judaism, on the spot.
When a haredi parent asks for a school that offers a broader education while preserving its religious character, what do the established parties have to offer?
When a young haredi man wants to serve, what will they do to help him find a framework he can trust? When a family struggles to make ends meet, what will they do to give their children better prospects?
These are questions from their own constituents, and the campaign made them harder to dismiss. If the established parties start offering credible answers, that will be a gain for the people Leitner set out to represent.
So why did more people respond to the message than vote for the party? One pre-election poll put support at 1.7%, a figure that suggested more interest than the ballot count ultimately showed.
Even that poll put us well below the electoral threshold, and potential voters acted accordingly.
Some people who agreed with us feared that a vote for a small list would go to waste and make it harder for the right to reach 61 seats.
The precise reasons will differ from voter to voter, but it was always going to be easier to tell a pollster you supported a new party than to trust it with your ballot in a close election.
Open to conversation
We also made mistakes. We spent so much time telling the wider Israeli public that there were haredim ready to work with them that we sometimes left haredi voters wondering who would stand up for them.
When people are used to hearing their community blamed for everything, from economic handouts to the strain on the army, they listen closely for any sign that a new leader understands what they fear losing.
Many potential haredi voters were also put off by the admonitions of senior rabbinic figures threatening spiritual punishment or not accepting supporters in educational frameworks.
The fact that the Haredi Public party was targeted by the highest levels demonstrated how much of a political threat the party was to the status quo.
Haredi leaders have to reckon honestly with the demands placed on other Israeli families, especially those sending loved ones back into uniform again and again.
The wider public, in turn, has to take seriously the religious commitments that shape what service and education can look like in haredi life. There is room to negotiate the details once each side accepts that the other is asking for something real and achievable.
One of the campaign’s achievements was to give Israelis a haredi partner willing to have that conversation in public.
I saw the same sense of possibility among haredi supporters overseas.
Many recognized a way of life familiar to them in Leitner’s proposals, in which Torah, education, and earning a living belong together.
The next time Israeli haredi leaders meet donors abroad, some of them will have their own question: If a haredi party in Israel can put forward practical proposals on schooling, employment, and service while defending Torah life, what are the established parties prepared to do about those same problems?
Leitner took a genuine risk in challenging parties that have long claimed to speak for haredi Israel.
Now, his task is to earn the trust of the people who agreed with much of what he said and still voted elsewhere.
If he spends the time between elections listening to those voters, standing up for them, and showing how his proposals can work in their own communities, he can turn this campaign’s achievement into political representation.
The argument has been made, and there is broad support for the program.
The next step is to move past the fear factor, see that change is indeed possible, and demonstrate to wider Israeli society that a true partner has taken his seat at the table.