State charges Palestinian with stabbing of IDF soldier at Tel Aviv train station
IDF forces arrest 11 Palestinians overnight in West Bank
Barkat: My goal is to be able to respond within one minute to any security incident
Touting the management of Gaza war reporting
Labor MK Shai mocks Israeli threat to Iran
Possible 2016 US presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren to meet Netanyahu
Coalition in turmoil after cabinet approves controversial 'Jewish state bill'
Ministers okay poverty panel’s recommendations
Deri: We won't join government until after next elections
Sharp rise in additional, private health insurance costs
Health Scan: BGU course makes med students more empathetic
The toilet taboo
Pro-public health advocates battle against private-medicine lobbying and ad campaign
From Silicon Valley to Silicon Wadi
'Leviathan gas reservoir to begin flowing by early 2018'
New kid's Israeli archaeology game launched for iPhone
Green Knesset advances as MKs replace paper with iPads
Funeral Monday for Israel Zamir, only son of Isaac Bashevis Singer
Festival review: Curtain Up 2014
JEST’s grand finale
A taste Of Poland
Jerusalem still perfect after tough battle in Rishon
Sakhnin edges Beitar in subdued showdown
Rishon’s credentials to come under scrutiny vs J’lem
Vermut clinches dramatic win for Hapoel TA
Ashkelon children to be temporarily relocated from daycares where Arab laborers are working
Vote on Jewish state bill to be delayed until next week
Yehuda Glick set to leave hospital Monday nearly a month after terror shooting
WATCH: Thousands of Chabad rabbis convene for annual gathering in New York
Turkish governor's wish to morph synagogue into museum raises ire
Nazi-looted art collection may find new home in Switzerland
Ukrainian president to mark Auschwitz liberation in Prague
Reform to ease accreditation of immigrant professionals
Hungarian porn used in ISIS propaganda?
PA to delay Palestinian statehood bid at UN
Analysis: When the West and Arab nations differ
Iran seeks a second political framework as historic nuclear talks stall
Iran and world powers set to miss nuclear talks deadline, seek extension, sources say
Think About It: National unity and a national unity government
Terra Incognita: Murder, tourism and loving Islamic State
November 24: A modest soul
Berlin: Stumbling Stones and street art
Reality Check: Netanyahu has given up on full equality for Israel’s Arabs
Cinema of reconciliation
On the volcano’s edge
Knowledge, power and abuse
Q&A with a Colombian lone soldier
European Press: Dividing line
Veterans: Keeping an ear out for change
Book Review: Written from his heart
This Week in Jerusalem
Who is your God?
Grapevine: Amazing place
A voice from India
Happily Eva After: When the going gets tough...
Grapevine: Reclaiming our heritage
Upscale dining in Neveh Tzedek
Recognizing Palestine – anomalies and ambiguities
Dacca fighting New Delhi’s war too
A war for the soul of Israel’s Arab community
Iran and the West – how big a gap?
A song for Cheshvan: 'The Eucalyptus Grove'
הָאַרְכִיוֹן שֶל רוֹמַן וִישְנִיָאק
Har Nof in flames
Sail Away with me
Q&A with a Guatemalan combat soldier
Meet the Ambassador: No longer a conference diplomat
‘Post’ leads the way with new podcast
Grapevine: The highest accolade of all
Tempête au sein de la coalition
Crise de confiance
Qui prendra la relève de Mahmoud Abbas ?
Arafat, Abbas, même combat ?
Daniel Oren, maestro d’Israël, d’Italie et d’ailleurs !
Nos plus belles années ?
De Berlin à New York, 1920-1975
Le pogrome de Constantine
Le pot de chocolat liégeois par qui le scandale arrive
Le dernier kibboutz
La course aux étoiles
Les mordus du français
On n’invite pas un pyromane à éteindre un incendie
Tuer l’EI dans l’œuf
Le mont du Temple et la guerre sainte de l’islam
Les attentats du lundi 10 novembre vus par la presse française
L’Europe, nouvelle alliée d’Abbas ?
Christians United for Israel Chairman John Hagee says Obama is anti-Semitic
Temple Mount: Common ground between Jews and Christians
Pope Francis condemns Palestinian violence
Last Christian shop-owners in Old City: 'Tourists afraid of the politics'
Kurdish refugees struggle to survive as they outrun Assad's army and ISIS
KKL Belgium Donates Portable Bomb Shelter to Kiryat Gat
KKL-JNF Awards 2014 Blumberg Prize
Exploring the Ilanot Botanical Garden and the Vickar Observation Point
Cornerstone Laid for Sports Rehab Park at Meir Hospital
Mexican Politician and Business Leader Miguel Aleman Velasco Visits KKL-JNF in Jerusalem
International Conference in Sde Boker: Combating Desertification Together
Rehabilitation of the Lower Jordan: Bringing the River Back to Life
Central America Celebrates Independence at the Rabin Center
In his Footsteps: Heritage Excursions in Memory of Yitzhak Rabin
Cleanup Day Activities in Central Israel
International Cleanup Day: Cleaning Together in Northern Israel
KKL-JNF's Eyes in the Forest - The Horshim Forest Green Patrol
Israel Today and Tomorrow: KKL France Mission Visits Israel
Start-up Israel: KKL Italy November Mission Learns about Israel's Past and Future
KKL-JNF and Desert Agriculture Latin American Diplomats visit the Negev
A Successful Annual Fundraising Event for KKL Milan
Living Green in Israel: the Contest and the Winners
Addressing Climate Change Conference
Nurturing the Foresters of the Future
Saving the Sabras
11.24.2014 | 2 Kislev, 5775
Jewish women take home gold at 2014 Emmys
Dance review: Maya Brinner –‘Local’ Jaffa Port
‘Armed’ and dangerous
US music legend Seymour Stein to scout Israeli artists
Robin Williams, remembering the man of many voices
The play must go on
Dance review: Dafi Dance Group Warehouse 2, Jaffa Port
The prince of romance hits all the right keys
Return of ladino popularity ruthy
Eyal Sher to head Israel Festival
Menahem Golan, pioneering Israeli filmmaker, dies at 85
NOA AMOUYAL \
When enough is enough
12 Years a Slave.
Ever since the advent of the medium, movie-making and the portrayal of universal human suffering has been a natural pair.Before films like Amistad, Munich and The Pianist even debuted; they were deemed instant Oscar bait. And with good reason – the pathos extracted from displaying the gross injustice and inhumanity inherent in slavery and the Holocaust is limitless.But this weary film viewer has one request to Hollywood: Can we have a bit of a break? This year, 12 Years a Slave is up for nine nominations.The film is beautifully shot – the mesmerizing hues of orange and red sunsets illuminating the riverbanks of the American South effectively underscore the irony that such a beautiful country embodied such ugliness and evil. The costumes are top notch. And, most importantly, Chiwetel Ejiofor’s performance as a freeman from New York who is kidnapped and sold into slavery is excruciatingly heartbreaking.It’s unfortunate then, that the film is unbearably boring.I was flummoxed by my reaction for awhile afterwards.How could I possibly find a film about one of the most profound human tragedies boring? I realized that the film itself is not to blame. 12 Years a Slave added to the plethora of images from other slavery films that came before it. Amistad, Glory, Beloved have all blended into one interminably long film with the same message.This desensitized reaction is not limited to films about slavery, though.Holocaust movies, too, have largely followed the same formulaic path. As a result, they often dull our senses to the significance of this important genre.And they absolutely shouldn’t.Films depicting the unspeakable evil people do unto others should be riveting and hit the viewer to the core. When the TV mini-series Roots aired in 1977, it did just that. The brutally realistic portrayal of one family’s multi-generational enslavement was something American audiences had never seen before. Viewers watched in record-breaking numbers and it became a template for what movies about slavery should look and sound like.As for the Holocaust, Schindler’s List continues to be the defining film of that genre. In a Barbara Walters interview with Steven Spielberg shortly after the movie’s release in 1994, Walters said of the film, “When word got out in Hollywood that he was making a black and white movie about the Holocaust, you could almost feel the cynicism.The man who spent his career making us forget reality was making us remember.”It became a commercial and critical hit that garnered 12 nominations. It was new; it was innovative and no other mainstream Hollywood Holocaust movie since then has never quite been able to touch it.Which is exactly the problem: Virtually every movie since has been predictably formulaic. In a sincere attempt to ensure that the memory of slavery and the Holocaust not fade from memory, we have actually begun to do dilute the significance by releasing film after film that are carbon copies of each other.Inundation of images of malnourished Jews and beaten slaves serves only to provide an audience with torture porn, instead of compelling them to honor the memory of those who actually suffered through these strategies.A call to end production of these movies is not necessary, but it’s time for Hollywood to devise new ways for retelling these touching and critical stories.Quentin Tarintino – a man who built his movie empire by subverting popular genres and providing his own interpretation – has succeeded in reinventing both genres. His ahistorical and over-the-top take on both the Holocaust (Inglorious Basterds) and slavery (Django Unchained) is exactly what Hollywood needs.Those movies were unique because they empowered the victim. He transformed traditional tales of sorrow and tragedy to stories of vengeance and justice.While verisimilitude and historical accuracy is important, Tarintino proves that it doesn’t have to be a prerequisite for creating an emotionally powerful take on historical tragedy.After all, this is Hollywood. Any recreation of history will be tweaked and altered for dramatic affect.I say, leave the blow by blow of what actually happened to the history books and let Hollywood do what it does best – let its imagination run wild.Even when it comes to the horrors and injustice of slavery and the Holocaust.
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com.
Disqus users can post comments automatically.
Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
Sign up for our newsletter
Please insert a valid email address
By signing up to The Jpost mailing list, I hereby