Prawer-Begin bill protest 370.
Beduin Israelis and their supporters staged violent protests in several
locations across the country on Saturday against the controversial Prawer-Begin
resettlement bill currently being debated in the Knesset.
police and demonstrators were reported, inter alia, at the Hura Junction in the
Negev, in Haifa and in east Jerusalem. Some 15 police officers were lightly
wounded and 30 protesters were arrested.
The Prawer-Begin bill is a
five-year economic development initiative seeking to regulate Beduin settlement
in the South. It aims for a compromise solution for tens of thousands of Beduin
currently scattered in unrecognized villages throughout the Negev, legalizing 63
percent of claimed land.
Among the police who were hurt were Coastal
District Commander Haggai Dotan; Navah Tabo, the spokeswoman of the Negev
subdistrict; and an officer from the Central District who was stabbed in the leg
by a protester.
The protesters hurled rocks, firebombs and other objects,
said national police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld.
Some 1,500 demonstrators
gathered at the Hura Junction. Some were seen waving PLO flags, Israel
Police had been aware of attempts to boost tensions and
bring a new round of violent protests in Israel, Southern District Commander
Yoram Halevy said Saturday night at the site of the protests in
“This is not the first time we’ve heard people issue warnings about
a third intifada,” Halevy said. “We approved a license for a peaceful protest,
and to my dismay from the beginning it declined very quickly when they began
throwing rocks and we were forced to close the highway. They also threw
Molotov cocktails and garbage cans. There is an attempt to start a war
here, but we won’t allow it to happen.”
There were still a few hundred
protesters at Hura and in Haifa by the time Halevy made his comments, but police
said they had managed to establish control of both locations. They deployed
hundreds of reinforcements in Hura and Haifa, and employed a number of
crowd-dispersal methods, including tear gas, stun grenades and water
There were also protests off Highway 444 in the Triangle, where
many Arab cities and villages are situated adjacent to the Green Line, and
outside the Damascus Gate in east Jerusalem, where police used water cannons to
disperse over 100 Arab rioters.
A small protest also took place in Jaffa on Saturday evening where some
seventy people gathered at the Clocktower Square blocking traffic
intermittently, Israel Radio reported.
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu spoke
Saturday night with Public Security Minister Yitzhak Aharonovitch and the
national police commander, Insp.-Gen. Yohanan Danino, about the protests. He
praised the police for their determined actions against the demonstrators,
according to a statement released by the Prime Minister’s Office.
will treat offenders to the fullest extent of the law and will not tolerate such
We have – and will have – no tolerance for those who break
the law,” Netanyahu said. “Attempts by a loud and violent minority to deny a
better future to a large and broad population are grave.
We will continue
to advance the law for a better future for all residents of the
Danino said police “will allow legal, legitimate protests in
keeping with the law but won’t allow illegal protests to disrupt the daily life
The headquarters of the Economic and Community Development
of the Negev Beduin in the Prime Minister’s Office, headed by Maj.-Gen. (res.)
Doron Almog, issued its own statement.
“The government of Israel regrets
that extremists, many of whom are not Beduin, chose to divert the open debate
about a purely social and humanitarian cause into a confrontation, falsely
linked to the Palestinian issue,” the statement said.
had been behind the protests, which were not based on a “sincere concern for the
Beduin,” it said.
“We call upon the Negev Beduin to take a stand for
their own future and not let anyone else abuse and manipulate this process for
alien causes,” it added.
The statement went on to say that the vast
majority of Beduin would continue living “in their current location, while
property rights will be resolved, regularized and recognized. The Beduin of the
Negev, being equal citizens, deserve adequate housing, public services and a
better future for their children.”
In an interview with The Jerusalem
Post Saturday night, Almog called the protests politically motivated and in no
way connected to the genuine concerns of the Negev Beduin. He accused leaders of
the Israeli Arab parties Balad and UAL-Ta’al, as well as the Islamic Movement,
of being behind the protests.
“Most of the Beduin in the Negev want
change and development,” Almog said. “We have a good plan and are going to
invest a lot of money to create a better future. The Arab and Beduin population
need to cooperate to strengthen Israel.”
Asked if disturbances of this
type would threaten implementation of the legislation if passed, Almog
responded: “We will put the plan into action when the bill passes. It is not
about a process of force, but development. Most of the process will be done by
agreement between the Beduin and the state of Israel.”
Amir Abo Kwedr, an
Arab activist involved in the protests, told the Post Saturday night that people
gathered in “a day of rage from all around Palestine – Haifa, Ramallah, Gaza,
Hebrew University – against the Prawer plan, which is aimed at displacing tens
of thousands of people.”
He added that police had “provoked the protests
by gathering in the thousands and getting too close” to the demonstrators. He
added that the authorities should have exercised more restraint, but “they are
too stubborn and eager to oppress every kind of protest against this
Asked about a claim made by some that the protests were being
hijacked by non-Beduin Arabs, Abo Kwedr said: “We don’t accept this shameful
kind of old policy of ‘divide and conquer’ – that the Beduin are not part of the
He insisted that the majority of those at the
protest in Hura were from the Negev, and that saying otherwise was just an
effort to delegitimize the protests.
Abo Kwedr denied that the
Prawer-Begin bill was a compromise solution, saying it had been drafted without
consulting the Beduin community. He added that the protests should be seen as a
“warning sign” for what could happen in the future.
“As we saw today, the
community will react,” he said.
Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman called
the rioting “serious but expected,” and the situation in the south
“It is our duty to stop the situation in which there are
some citizens to whom the laws of planning and construction apply and there are
others who ignore them and use violence to ensure the laws don’t apply to them,”
Liberman wrote on Facebook.
“This isn’t a social problem or a housing
crisis, but a battle for the land,” the foreign minister and Yisrael Beytenu
“We are fighting for the national lands of the Jewish
people, and some are intentionally trying to steal them and forcibly take them
over. We cannot close our eyes and escape this reality.”
He called for
the government to deal with the situation by building modern cities for Israeli
Arabs, with tall buildings and infrastructure.
“Building permits are not
only for Jews,” he declared.
He also called for the government to
reexamine the Prawer- Begin plan and cancel benefits the Beduin were supposed to
receive, saying if there could be no agreement on the entire bill, none of it
should be implemented.
In response, MK Ahmed Tibi (UAL-Ta’al) called the
foreign minister a fascist and “an immigrant who lives on land stolen from
Arabs.” Liberman came to Israel from Moldova and lives in the West
Deputy Defense Minister Danny Danon (Likud) called for his Knesset
faction to discuss the bill.
“It cannot be that we are giving state-owned
land and getting uncontrolled violence,” he said.
Opponents of the bill
claim the legislation would result in up to 40,000 Beduin losing their
Former minister Bennie Begin is handling the Prawer-Begin bill on
behalf of the government. It is currently being deliberated in the Knesset’s
The plan will cost NIS 7 billion, NIS 2b. of which
would be earmarked for compensation to those whose land claims are not
addressed, Israel Radio reported.
Almog added that there is approximately an additional NIS 3b. that is budgeted for the plan, but is not included in the bill.
Demonstrations were also being planned
in a number of European and Arab countries to mark the so-called international
“day of rage” against the legislation, the Post has learned. The Foreign
Ministry is taking the international campaign seriously in light of increasing
interest in the issue by governments and NGOs, particularly in the US and the
European Union, where objections and protests are garnering publicity.
Friday, the British daily Guardian published a letter signed by 50 high-profile
figures from the world of arts and entertainment condemning what they termed
“the forced displacement of Palestinians from their homes and land, and
systematic discrimination and separation.”
The letter was signed by,
among others, musician Brian Eno, artist Antony Gormley, actress Julie Christie
and film director Mike Leigh.
Daniel K. Eisenbud and Tovah Lazaroff
contributed to this report.
Relevant to your professional network? Please share on Linkedin