NEW YORK – Fifth Avenue came to a standstill on Monday as nearly two-dozen
American dignitaries, hundreds of uniformed city police and thousands of New
Yorkers descended on Temple Emanu-El in Manhattan to honor the city’s former
mayor, Ed Koch, who died last Friday. He was 88 years old.
His
successors, mayors Rudolph Giuliani and Michael Bloomberg, mourned his passing,
along with representatives Peter King and Charles Rangel, NYPD Police
Commissioner Ray Kelly, Governor Andrew Cuomo and former president Bill
Clinton.
“It’s a sad day, but he had a full life,” Giuliani told The
Jerusalem Post. “Not too many people, if anyone, contributed more to New York
City than Ed Koch. We should feel guilty feeling too sad. He wouldn’t want us
to.”
Rangel, one of the oldest members currently serving in the US House
of Representatives, joked that Koch probably would choose Jerusalem as a place
to live as a close second to New York City, where he was mayor for three
terms.
“He was the quintessential New Yorker,” Rangel told the
Post.
But in Bloomberg’s eulogy, he recalled Koch saying the only place
he’d ever live besides New York is in heaven, where the current mayor predicted
he would be welcomed with an embrace solidified by his years of service to the
city.
In New York’s darkest hour, Bloomberg said, Koch “restored the arc
of our city’s history,” bringing it back from a state of despair and restoring
the potential it had to become the international capital it has become
today.
Bloomberg said he came to the service with the love and
condolences of 8.4 million New Yorkers. Ido Aharoni, Israel’s consulgeneral in
New York, said similarly that he came bearing the heavy hearts of all
Israelis.
“Ed Koch was one of us,” Aharoni said. “We Israelis owe him a
great deal of gratitude. With his unique combination of charm and chutzpah and
deep conviction, he became a clarion voice for Israel and one of the most
important and influential American Zionists of our time.”
As the
traditional simple wooden coffin carrying Koch was brought into the foyer of the
temple, past thousands of guests to the tune of “New York, New York” by Frank
Sinatra, NYPD pallbearers ritually unfolded the flag of the city of New York,
draping it over the Star of David that adorned the clean casket.
But just
before the doors opened to the formal salute, where half-a-dozen helicopters
were to pass overhead on the edge of Central Park, Koch’s family had the
officers remove the flag, citing religious reasons.
While Koch will not
be buried at a Jewish cemetery – he will be laid to rest at Trinity Church,
which is home to one of Manhattan’s oldest graveyards – he chose to inscribe the
Shema prayer on his tombstone, as well as the final words of Daniel Pearl, who
was killed in 2002 while in the captivity of Pakistani
terrorists.
Bloomberg quoted Pearl’s final words – “My father is Jewish,
my mother is Jewish, I am Jewish” – noting the emotions he felt when he learned
that both men died on February 1.
“Ed Koch wanted us all to shape up,”
Clinton eulogized. “We miss you so much because we all know we’re doing a lot
better because you lived and served.”