ROME – Dr. Riccardo Di Segni, chief rabbi of Rome, responded warmly on Yom
Kippur to Pope Francis’s remarks on Jews and Judaism.
In a letter
published September 12 by national daily La Repubblica, Di Segni, known for his
very cautious attitude toward interreligious dialogue and his insistence on
mutually recognized limits, said, “This Pontiff does not cease to
He was referring to an article written by the pope and
published September 11 in La Repubblica
in response to challenging questions
asked by Eugenio Scalfari, the paper’s cofounder and former editor, and a
Concerning Scalfari’s questioning as to
whether God had actually kept his promise to Abraham and the People of Israel
for prosperity and happiness, considering centuries of persecution culminating
in the Shoah, Francis replied: “This is a question – believe me – that touches
us profoundly as Christians, because with the help of God, especially since the
Second Vatican Council [created 50 years ago], we have rediscovered that the
Jewish People are still for us the holy root that produced Jesus.
all these years of friendship with our Jewish brothers in Argentina, I, too,
have questioned God many times in my prayers, especially when my mind turned to
the memory of the terrible experience of the Shoah,” declared the pope, who was
born in Argentina, where he became archbishop of Buenos Aires in 1998 and a
cardinal in 2001.
God never abandoned his covenant with Israel, and
notwithstanding their suffering over the centuries, the Jewish People have kept
their faith, the pope wrote.
“For this, we will never be sufficiently
grateful to them as a Church, but also as human beings,” he continued. “In the
persistence of their faith in the God of the Covenant, they summon all,
including us as Christians, to recall the fact that we are awaiting the return
of the Lord as pilgrims, and must therefore always remain open to Him and never
retreat from what we have already achieved.”
In his published letter, Di
Segni noted that while Francis’s words are not new but, rather, inherent to
Christianity and confirmed by Vatican II, “it is the force with which he
expresses them and his capacity of communicating them that is astounding. The
fact that Judaism is the holy root of Christianity is fundamental, but many
theological currents, especially in Protestantism, have tried to belittle them.
In opposing these currents, Francis is coherent to the teaching of Benedict.
Especially noteworthy is his expression of gratitude to Jews for their devotion
Paradoxically, after centuries of Christian preaching against
what they referred to as Jewish superstition and a vain expectation of the
Messiah, Jewish, fidelity has become a “model for Christians and for
This is not improvised but a very significant turning point
which Jews will have to take into account,” Di Segni affirmed.
In his Yom
Kippur speech, published after sundown by national online daily Pagine Ebraiche,
Di Segni again referred to the pope’s words, albeit without mentioning his
Speaking of the “special dignity” of the Jewish People, “which we
assume grows in proportion to our fidelity to the Torah,” the chief rabbi
specified that “in these strange times, in these very days, an authoritative
external voice has reminded us of this – a voice paradoxically coming from a
camp that has for centuries inflicted on us suffering, humiliation and offense
precisely because we kept true to our tradition in the Messianic expectation.”