print gohome
The Jerusalem Post - Israel News
 
Print Edition
Photo by: YouTube Screenshot
PM: IDF 'Refusal' advocates won't sit in my gov't
By LAHAV HARKOV
12/22/2012
Bennett accuses Likud of twisting his words, following wave of criticism after saying he would not evacuate settlements.
 
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu hinted that he would not bring Bayit Yehudi chairman Naftali Bennett into his coalition after the election, because the latter supports refusing military orders.

Bennett said the Likud had dangerously twisted his words for political gain.

“Whoever refuses orders will not be in my government,” Netanyahu said in televised interviews on Friday.

“The idea of refusal, even as a personal attitude, is not acceptable.”

Reacting to statements Bennett made on Thursday, that, as an IDF reservist, his conscience would not allow him to evacuate settlements, the prime minister added that it is “impossible to sustain the State of Israel” if people refuse orders, and whoever supports it will not be a minister.

“The army is built on fulfilling orders. The minute you subvert that, it doesn’t matter what side you’re on [Right or Left], you are collapsing the IDF and the country,” Netanyahu said.

Following a wave of criticism from the Likud and center- left parties, Bennett called a press conference on Saturday night to clarify that he opposes refusing military orders.

Bennett accused the Likud of “pouncing on my words, twisting them and making it look like I called for people to refuse orders just for a quarter of a seat in the next Knesset.”

“They harmed the unity of the IDF. Thousands of young people could think that I called to refuse orders, and take a mistaken example from me. I did not call to refuse orders. I have been serving in the IDF for 22 years as a fighter and a commander, and I never called to refuse orders – every intelligent [television] viewer understood that,” he said.

The Bayit Yehudi leader added that he spoke from his heart, and does not apologize, because a military command to remove a Jew or an Arab from his home is a human rights violation that would put soldiers in a moral dilemma.

“I pray with all my heart that a command like this will never be given again, but I want to say clearly: Every soldier must fulfill orders,” he said.

Bennett concluded his speech by saying that the fact that the Likud is dealing with the issue of refusing orders shows that it could be planning a second disengagement and to evacuate more settlers.

“Mr. Prime Minister – yes or no? Do you plan to uproot Jews from their homes again?” he asked. “[Bayit Yehudi] will be a big, significant party that will prevent a situation in which IDF soldiers will face such inhumane dilemmas again.”

On Thursday night, Bennett said in an interview on Channel 2 that he would ask his commander to excuse him from evacuating settlements.

When asked if he would go to prison rather than remove settlers from their homes, Bennett, a reserves major who served in the Sayeret Matkal (the IDF General Reconnaissance Unit) and the Maglan special forces units, said yes.

“I educated my soldiers that a command with a black flag hanging over it should not be fulfilled,” he added, referring to the concept in the IDF Ethics Code of an illegal or immoral command.

“To eject people from their homes is a terrible thing. I will do everything in my power not to allow that happen.”

Several Likud cabinet members attacked Bennett for his statements, including Education Minister Gideon Sa’ar, who said “a public figure who serves as a personal example cannot talk about refusing orders. That’s the difference between a statist and a non-statist attitude.”

“Putting your own worldview above democratic principles is very problematic,” Sa’ar added. “In a heterogeneous society like Israel, following the rules of the democratic game is what keeps us together.”

“If you don’t support a political move, then it’s a black flag?” Strategic Affairs Minister Moshe Ya’alon asked on Saturday. “Whoever makes an irresponsible statement like that cannot be part of the leadership.”

Ya’alon, a former IDF chief of staff, called for Bennett to “take back his permission, even if it was a hint, to refuse orders” if he wanted to be in the next government.

Politicians on the Left also criticized Bennett, with Labor chairwoman Shelly Yacimovich saying “refusing orders is dangerous whether it comes from the Right or the Left. It is seven times more dangerous when it is legitimized by the head of a party.”

Tzipi Livni Party Knesset candidate Maj.-Gen. (res.) Elazar Stern accused Bennett of trying to lead the “wonderful national-religious youth” to extremism, calling it “an illegal, non-Zionist” move.

“Extremist expressions endanger our basic social values. Any call to refuse orders must be criticized from the Right and the Left,” Stern said.

“Bennett revealed his true, dangerous face tonight – he is no more than the shepherd of the hilltop youth,” Kadima chairman and former IDF chief of staff Shaul Mofaz said. “He must be reminded that the law is the law is the law, and whoever says he will not follow the law is not worthy of being elected, certainly not to lead a party.”

Meanwhile, Bennett received support from his fellow Bayit Yehudi members and those to his Right.

“What a pile of hypocrisy and sanctimoniousness from the Likudniks,” MK Uri Orbach (Bayit Yehudi) said on Friday. “I oppose refusing orders, and calling to do so is an even more serious matter, but what Naftali Bennett said was much more complex. That was his mistake, to make a complex statement to [Channel 2 reporter] Nissim Mishal.”

Orbach added that Bayit Yehudi hopes to be in the next government in order to prevent situations in which Jews are uprooted from their homes.

“What is the Likudniks’ stance? Will they be the ones to make a decision that will put soldiers in this dilemma? The Likud must answer the hypothetical question – when they come to the point of decision, will they evacuate settlements?” Orbach asked.

Strong Israel congratulated Bennett on his statement, and said it hopes the Bayit Yehudi leader does not change his mind following criticism from the Likud, which revealed the latter party as one that plans to found a Palestinian state and expel Jews from their homes.
print gohome
print

Copyright © 2014 Jpost Inc. All rights reserved • Terms of UsePrivacy Policy