The Jerusalem Post
Jpost search icon google-icon iphone
  Set as Homepage
Tue, May 21, 2013   12 Sivan, 5773
newspapers magazines
 
    • Breaking News
    • Diplomacy & Politics
    • Defense
    • National
    • Mideast
    • Syria
    • Iran
    • World
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Health & Science
    • Environment
  • Video
  • Opinion
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Op-Eds
    • Letters
  • Jewish World
  • Lifestyle
    • Arts & Culture
    • Food & Wine
    • Travel
  • Features
    • Insights & Features
    • Week in review
    • On the Web
    • Shalva Superheroes
    • Obama in Israel
  • Blogs
    • In the news
    • Judaism
    • From the Middle East
    • Lifestyle
    • Aliya
    • Science and Technology
  • JPost Apps
    • iPhone app
    • iPad app
    • Android app
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS feeds
    • JPost Toolbar
    • JPost Newsletter
    • JPost Alert
  • Premium Zone
    • The Jerusalem Report
    • The Experts
    • 20 Questions
    • e-paper
    • Ivrit
    • Christian Edition
    • Dash
    • Magazine
    • Metro
    • In Jerusalem
  • French
    • Politique & Social
    • Affaires Palestiniennes
    • Diplomatie & Monde
    • Art & Culture
    • Israel
  • Green Israel
JPost Learn Hebrew  
Advertise with us  
Nefesh Guided Aliyah  
Eldan  
AFMDA  
Africa Israel Group  
Isram Group  
Kupat Ha  
JPost Twitter  
JPost Facebook  
Classifieds  
         
 
 
    
Breaking News
 
 
  • JPost.com
  • Middle East
 

Mubarak's tainted legacy hangs over Egyptian vote

By REUTERS
05/13/2012 14:15
Tweet

"We have not had regime change in Egypt, only change within the regime, with a lot of street noise outside," expert says.

Hosni Mubarak
Hosni Mubarak Photo: REUTERS

CAIRO/LONDON - Military police idly guard the gates of Egypt's presidential palace in Heliopolis, built as a 400-room luxury hotel in 1910 and vacant since a popular uprising deposed Hosni Mubarak 15 months ago.

Egyptians, who never stormed in to gawk and plunder their fallen leader's home as Tunisians and Libyans did last year, vote on May 23 and 24 for a new president, the latest stage of an uncertain transition guided bumpily by the military.

  • Egypt launches presidential election with expat vote
  • Poll: 61% of Egyptians want to cancel Israel treaty

People who live in the wealthy Cairo district around the palace are delighted to be spared the road closures that snarled traffic for hours every time Mubarak went anywhere.

But some, such as 24-year-old Sara Hussein, find it harder to perceive any other changes wrought by the uprising she had so ardently supported. "Like everything, the palace is still not free of the Mubaraks. The palace, and the country, are not for the people," she says. "His regime is still in power."

Still, Egypt will soon have a freely elected - and probably civilian - president for the first time in the republic's 60-year history, assuming the generals who sealed Mubarak's fate by refusing to shoot at crowds baying for his downfall keep their promise to hand over by July 1.

Little else is clear. Attempts to craft a new constitution have stalled. No one knows how power will be divided between the president and parliament, dominated by Islamists.

The military, wary of Islamists and jealous of its own power, perks and privileges, may step back from day-to-day affairs but is likely to seek an as-yet undefined political role, seeing itself as the paternal guardian of the state.

The generals effectively removed Mubarak to safeguard the system, not to promote revolutionary change. So far reform has not touched that system's main pillars - the military, the judiciary, the police, security and intelligence agencies.

"We have not had regime change in Egypt, only change within the regime, with a lot of street noise outside," said Robert Springborg, a professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California, and a specialist on the Egyptian military.

"He was a tyrant under the umbrella of the law"

Mubarak may be gone, but his legacy lingers.

Then vice-president, he was catapulted into office in October 1981 after surviving the gunfire from Islamist army soldiers who assassinated his predecessor, Anwar Sadat.

He brought calm and kept Egypt at peace for 30 years, crushing an armed Islamist rebellion in the 1990s, until political and economic frustrations with his stagnant rule boiled over in the cauldron of Cairo's Tahrir Square, where wild rejoicing greeted his departure on Feb. 11, 2011.

Many compare Mubarak to his predecessors - Sadat, who made peace with Israel and forged an alliance with the United States, and Gamal Abdel Nasser, an Arab nationalist who once inspired those fighting colonial powers in the Arab world and beyond.

"Sadat was exceptional in his intelligence, Nasser in his charisma. Mubarak was half-talented at everything and had no exceptional quality," said Ayman Nour, who ran in a 2005 election against Mubarak and was later jailed for his pains.

"Mubarak had the kind of tyranny that is typical of half-democracies," the 47-year-old lawyer told Reuters. "He was a tyrant under the umbrella of the law."

That did not stand in the way of Mubarak's friendship with the West, which valued him for upholding Sadat's 1979 peace treaty with Israel, deeply unpopular with many Egyptians.

He was also a close ally of Saudi Arabia, which was dismayed at Washington's failure to prevent the fall of a pillar of a US regional political and security order that included Egypt and conservative Arab monarchies from Morocco to the Gulf.

"Without Mubarak, it will be harder for the United States to do the things it has done in the past," said Steven Cook, a Middle East expert at Washington's Council on Foreign Relations.

US-Egyptian relations have become tetchier since Mubarak's ouster, but military aid and cooperation continue, as does the treaty with Israel, although the peace is colder than ever.

Verdict for Mubarak promised by June 2

Now on trial for his life, Mubarak, who turned 84 this month, spends his days in the capital's International Medical Center, sitting in a lounge, walking in the garden, watching television and seeing relatives, according to a hospital source who offered a rare, unauthorized glimpse of his activities.

This suggests he is healthier than the image projected at his court appearances, when he showed up lying on a stretcher, wearing dark glasses and taking little part in proceedings.

He and ex-Interior Minister Habib al-Adly both deny ordering the killing of protesters. If convicted, they could face the death penalty, but appeals will follow and the military may well protect Mubarak, a former airforce chief, from execution.

The judge has promised a verdict on June 2, a date that falls between the first presidential election round and a likely run-off between the two top vote-getters on June 16 and 17.

Mubarak's two sons, Gamal, once seen as his heir-apparent, and Alaa are also on trial with him on corruption charges.

Many Egyptians see the trial as a test of accountability and want justice for the 800 or so people killed during the revolt, but Mubarak, if not his unloved sons, still has a following.

A 62,000-member Facebook page called "We are sorry Mr President" says: "You made your mistakes and you disappointed some. You trusted men around you with no conscience, but you will stay in the heart of every Egyptian who loves you."

Weariness with post-uprising chaos and shattered livelihoods may also feed nostalgia for Mubarak's staid order.

"The economy is in terrible shape. It's not as if his passing has led to a golden era for Egypt, so lots of Egyptians are already yearning for the good old days," Springborg said.

"Next president won't dare squander money as before"

Under Mubarak, Egypt's social and economic indicators improved, but economic growth lagged behind former peers such as Turkey and South Korea despite a spurt in the last seven years of his rule when liberalization created prosperity for some.

"The problem was that most people did not share in those benefits and in order to maintain political control, Mubarak employed violence and coercion," Cook said.

Those methods worked for three decades, but after Tunisia exploded, Egyptians lost their fear and in 18 heady days disposed of the only leader many of them had ever known.

Since then, although the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamist parties have emerged as Egypt's main political force, it is street power - not solely or even mainly driven by Islamists - that has often forced concessions from the military.

That empowerment may be one of the most significant outcomes of the youthful movement that toppled Mubarak.

"I've never seen people speak so freely, or such a proliferation of opinion, such fearlessness," said Rashid Khalidi, professor of Arab studies at Columbia University. "Will that genie be put back in the bottle? I doubt it."

Across the busy Heliopolis avenue from the elegant arches and secluded lawns of Mubarak's now empty presidential palace, the blue, green and orange posters and banners of candidates vying to become its next occupant festoon the trees.

Although if Moustafa al-Banna, a lawmaker from an ultra-orthodox Salafi Islamist party, gets his way, the palace will house no more presidents in luxury, but revert to a hotel.

"It will become an icon for Egypt and the world. People will want to stay in a palace where Mubarak stayed until his last moment in power," Banna says, advocating tourism with a moral.

"When the next president comes and sees what has happened to his predecessor and his palace, he won't dare squander money as before. He'll be a normal citizen motivated to achieve social justice and serve the nation - we are the ones who create dictators."

  • Send
  • Large
  • Small
  • Print
  • Share
Most Viewed in
1
Intertwined fates: The Lebanon-Syria-Iran axis
2
Syrian army, Hezbollah kill over 30 in border town
3
Erekat throws his weight behind Kerry's peace bid
4
Activists: Hezbollah suffers big losses in Syria
JPost Community
Tweet
Hosni Mubarak Mubarak Egypt elections military Sadat
Share this article
Tweet
Share
Send
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com. Disqus users can post comments automatically.

Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
JPost Services
conferenceConference
newsletterNewsletter
iphoneMobile Apps
kotelcamKotel Cam
kolboJPost Alert
premiumPremium
JPost TV News  
Mobile Apps  
Bank Hapoalim  
Meir Panim  
Yad Ezra  
Rambam Hospital  
TourLuxe  
Zev Goldstein PLLC  
Penrose Gallery  
JPost Premium Zone  
JPost kotel Camera  
         
 
Israel Focus
JPost TV News
Coming soon to a screen near you!  
Nefesh B'Nefesh Guided Aliyah
Already living in Israel? Enjoy the Benefits of Aliyah!  
Give "Freedom" this Passover
to needy Israeli families. Donate now  
War Threatens
Protect the People of Northern Israel  
Intelligence Squared
The international debate forum, announces it is coming to Israel  
Bank Hapoalim
Israeli's number one bank  
Jerusalem Post Lite
Lite Edition of the Jerusalem Post for English improvement  
Learn Hebrew with us
Get 10 minutes free personal coaching in Hebrew through phone or Skype  
JPost newspapers
Sign up for the JPost newspapers and receive one month free subscription  
Kosher English Magazine
English language weekly magazine - especially for religious people  
JReport Kindle Edition
Now you can get the Jerusalem Report directly to your Kindle  
JPost Premium Edition
The very best articles are available only in our Premium edition  
Lifestyle Magazine
 
 
Real Estate
Don't Look For a House!
In Israel, our website will do it for you!  
 
Travel
Eldan Rent a Car
20% off all Car Rental Reservations in Israel  
Hertz Car Rental
Special Online Discounts!  
The King David Jerusalem Hotel
One of the world's truly iconic hotels, and a Jerusalem landmark  
 
 
 

Sites Of Interest:

Jerusalem Hotels
KKL-JNF
Poalim Online
BreitBart.com
Our Friends
Jerusalem Attractions
Jerusalem Tours
itraveljerusalem.com

JPost sites:

Learn Hebrew
The Jerusalem Report
Our Magazines
JPost Edition Francaise
Green Israel
Christian World
Jerusalem Post Lite

Services:

JPost Mobile Apps
JPost Premium
JPost Newsletter
JPost Toolbar
JPost News Ticker
JPost RSS feeds
JPost Archives
JPost Alert
JPost Kotel Cam

JPost Conferences:

NYC Conference
Diplomatic Conference

Information:

About Us
Feedback
Staff E-mails
Copyright
Sitemap
News Partners
Advertise with Us
Price List
Statistics
Ad Specs
Terms Of Service
Jpost.com, the online edition of the Jerusalem Post Newspaper - the most read and best-selling English-language newspaper in Israel. For analysis and opinion from Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East. Jpost.com offers expert and in-depth reporting from Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including diplomacy and defense, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, the Arab Spring, the Mideast peace process, politics in Israel, life in Jerusalem, Israel's international affairs, Iran and its nuclear program, Syria and the Syrian civil war, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Israel's world of business and finance, and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
 
About Us | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Premium | Newsletter | RSS | Contact Us
 
All rights reserved © The Jerusalem Post 1995 - 2012