Merkel against unilaterally recognizing Palestine as a state
Report: Abbas accuses Israel of using wild boars against Palestinians
Jewish youths hurt in brawl with Arabs in east Jerusalem
Riots break out in various areas of West Bank
Hamas denies knowledge of Liberman plot, but says leaders of 'occuaption' are legitimate targets
Israeli official: Erdogan rhetoric befits Tehran or Damascus, not a NATO capital
Netanyahu proposes his own version of 'Jewish state bill'
Israel’s ambassador to return to Sweden on symbolic Nov. 29th date
Netanyahu: We have nothing against east Jerusalem residents, but we must protect our citizens
Pro-public health advocates battle against private-medicine lobbying and ad campaign
Doctors, nurses more than twice as likely to get flu shots than general population
Cheapen gluten-free food for celiac patients, panel says
Project to improve nutrition loses funds
'Leviathan gas reservoir to begin flowing by early 2018'
New kid's Israeli archaeology game launched for iPhone
Green Knesset advances as MKs replace paper with iPads
Zion Tech: Our Israeli start-up of the week aims to revolutionize therapy access
James Blunt is coming to get ‘high’ in Tel Aviv
Grapevine: Farewell to an articulate advocate for Israel
Theater Review: The Tempest
Yellow-and-blue survives scare to beat Limoges
Beersheba with an opportunity to go top
Back-on-track Maccabi Tel Aviv takes on Limoges in Euroleague
Hapoel Jerusalem facing early Eurocup exit
HRW: Israel's demolition of Palestinian terrorists' homes is 'war crime'
Jerusalem mayor: We cannot discriminate against Arabs
English soccer club owner faces racism probe for saying Jews 'chase money'
Lawmaker in Antwerp calls on Belgian government to fund security for Jews
German survey: Spike in anti-Semitism after Gaza war
WATCH: How do American college students react to ISIS, Israeli flags?
Picking up the pieces of a lost culture
Jordanian PM reportedly sends condolence letter to families of Jerusalem synagogue terrorists
Yemen minister dedicates award to country’s Jews
ISIS releases new video with Cantile
IAEA to discuss Iranian offer to allow 'managed access' to site
Khamenei frees Iranian blogger who visited Israel
Into the Fray: The Arabs’ war against the Jews and what must be done
My Word: A personal response to terrorism
An open society
November 21, 2014: Expel ‘shahids’
No Holds Barred: The ferocious battle for Israel at New York University
Cinema of reconciliation
On the volcano’s edge
Knowledge, power and abuse
Q&A with a Colombian lone soldier
European Press: Dividing line
Veterans: Keeping an ear out for change
Book Review: Written from his heart
This Week in Jerusalem
Who is your God?
Grapevine: Amazing place
A voice from India
Happily Eva After: When the going gets tough...
Grapevine: Reclaiming our heritage
Upscale dining in Neveh Tzedek
A war for the soul of Israel’s Arab community
Iran and the West – how big a gap?
Iranian nukes and 'Palestine' - mutually reinforcing perils for Israel
Islamic State – APEC a fizzer - G20 promises no better
A song for Cheshvan: 'The Eucalyptus Grove'
הָאַרְכִיוֹן שֶל רוֹמַן וִישְנִיָאק
Har Nof in flames
Meet the Ambassador: No longer a conference diplomat
‘Post’ leads the way with new podcast
Grapevine: The highest accolade of all
The secret of Jewish survival
Frontlines Podcast: Jerusalem's 'lone wolves'
Tempête au sein de la coalition
Crise de confiance
Qui prendra la relève de Mahmoud Abbas ?
Arafat, Abbas, même combat ?
Daniel Oren, maestro d’Israël, d’Italie et d’ailleurs !
Nos plus belles années ?
De Berlin à New York, 1920-1975
Le pogrome de Constantine
Le pot de chocolat liégeois par qui le scandale arrive
Le dernier kibboutz
La course aux étoiles
Les mordus du français
On n’invite pas un pyromane à éteindre un incendie
Tuer l’EI dans l’œuf
Le mont du Temple et la guerre sainte de l’islam
Les attentats du lundi 10 novembre vus par la presse française
L’Europe, nouvelle alliée d’Abbas ?
Pope Francis condemns Palestinian violence
Last Christian shop-owners in Old City: 'Tourists afraid of the politics'
Kurdish refugees struggle to survive as they outrun Assad's army and ISIS
Discover Ramla from a Christian persepective
Pastor who died in crash mourned in Israel
KKL Belgium Donates Portable Bomb Shelter to Kiryat Gat
KKL-JNF Awards 2014 Blumberg Prize
Exploring the Ilanot Botanical Garden and the Vickar Observation Point
Cornerstone Laid for Sports Rehab Park at Meir Hospital
Mexican Politician and Business Leader Miguel Aleman Velasco Visits KKL-JNF in Jerusalem
International Conference in Sde Boker: Combating Desertification Together
Rehabilitation of the Lower Jordan: Bringing the River Back to Life
Central America Celebrates Independence at the Rabin Center
In his Footsteps: Heritage Excursions in Memory of Yitzhak Rabin
Cleanup Day Activities in Central Israel
International Cleanup Day: Cleaning Together in Northern Israel
KKL-JNF's Eyes in the Forest - The Horshim Forest Green Patrol
Israel Today and Tomorrow: KKL France Mission Visits Israel
Start-up Israel: KKL Italy November Mission Learns about Israel's Past and Future
KKL-JNF and Desert Agriculture Latin American Diplomats visit the Negev
A Successful Annual Fundraising Event for KKL Milan
Living Green in Israel: the Contest and the Winners
Addressing Climate Change Conference
Nurturing the Foresters of the Future
Saving the Sabras
11.22.2014 | 29 Heshvan, 5775
Rioting resumes throughout east Jerusalem Saturday night
MK calls to ban Secret smartphone application
Confirmed: Body of Aaron Sofer found in Jerusalem Forest
US: Israeli police harassing another Abu Khdeir cousin
With another yeshiva student arrested, haredi ‘draft dodgers’ could soon number in hundreds
Missing American's parents meet with Jerusalem police chief
Ayala Hasson, first woman to head Channel One News Division
Bar-Lev: Allow siblings’ names on IDF headstones
Sa’ar denies presidential deal with haredim
Police heighten security ahead of haredi protest in capital
Analysis: US tries policy of ‘shame’ to stem Chinese cyber-hacking
Israeli nightlife figure found dead in Tel Aviv apartment in apparent murder
YONAH JEREMY BOB \
Analysis: Third-world style elections in Beit Shemesh?
MOSHE ABUTBOL 311.
Many arguments were thrown out by some of the country’s best lawyers in Tuesday’s hearing on whether to overturn the Beit Shemesh elections and order new elections.But two issues stand out as likely being outcome-determinative: the battle over whether proof of fraud must meet near criminal law standards or a much lower standard; and the battle over what is the decisive issue – pure math or shoring up democratic values.The state and mayoral challenger Eli Cohen argued different variations on the theme that since the hearing was administrative and not criminal, the standard of proof was much lower, and that the decisive issue should be shoring up the legitimacy of democracy in the eyes of Beit Shemesh’s voters.Incumbent Mayor Moshe Abutbol and his allies argued that crimes were being alleged against persons accused of election fraud and that the standard of proof should be near the criminal law – one of beyond a reasonable doubt – while adding that those challenging the election needed to show they could invalidate at least 956 votes (Abutbol’s winning differential) or the rest of their arguments became irrelevant.Hebrew University Prof.Barak Medina said each side could push their argument from a different framework.He said that until now, most voter fraud cases involved one polling booth and that such cases were often decided on precise mathematical calculations, but also that a lower standard of proof was required regarding evidence.In contrast, the Beit Shemesh case had no comparable precedent that Medina was aware of, in that the accusations were of city-wide systematic fraud.Since the fraud was citywide, he said, there could be a strong argument for the court moving beyond the narrower arithmetic issue and focusing more on shoring up public confidence in the democratic system.On the flip side, he said, ordering new elections is an extreme measure, so the court might require a standard of proof closer to the criminal law standard.In deciding this question, observers might ask: Should courts be purely objective fact-judgers who tally balls and strikes with no global purpose? Or even as judges must strive for objectivity, do judges have an obligation to defend the more general interests of justice, even if it is their own somewhat subjective viewpoint? As Medina points out, the three judges are likely to need to make some political judgments.“If they overturn the election, they will be admitting” that what happened in Israel in the city of Beit Shemesh was “like in a third world country,” said Medina.Many observers had assumed that once Attorney-General Yehuda Weinstein put the state on the side of requesting new elections, the court would find it hard to refuse.That argument may still carry the day, but the judges initial interest in the arithmetic on Tuesday indicated that formally recognizing and admitting that a thirdworld style election occurred in a major city in Israel may be an equally hard pill to swallow.
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com.
Disqus users can post comments automatically.
Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
Sign up for our newsletter
Please insert a valid email address
By signing up to The Jpost mailing list, I hereby