It’s so easy to laugh at the Italians in the aftermath of their elections
earlier this week. They almost invite derision, especially given the success of
a populist small-screen comedian – a totally inexperienced political outsider –
who managed to score phenomenal success.
No scriptwriter could
conceivably have come up with a more stinging satirical spoof. The fact that it
happened in true life appears to blur the boundaries between lampoon and
But are we Israelis any better? Did we not entrust a hefty
segment of our Knesset representation to a totally inexperienced political
outsider as well? Their outsider is called Beppe Grillo and ours is Yair Lapid.
Though not a TV jester, Lapid won his fame as a TV anchor which puts him firmly
in the ranks of showbiz celebrities. Overnight wonder and ex-broadcaster Lapid
enthralled and mesmerized the electorate to the point of ushering in the second
largest Knesset faction. Analysts believe it bit into the support of both the
rightist and leftist stalwarts. It now remains to be seen how this unknown
entity will behave in the actual arena.
Laughs aside, fundamentally the
Italian and Israeli phenomena are too similar for comfort. In both cases,
members of the public treated the electoral process as something of a lark and
opted to cast their ballots for unknowns with facile and fetching slogans. In
both cases, this was a gamble whose longerterm consequences are yet to
This, of course, isn’t the only similarity between the two
elections. In both cases an essential deadlock has emerged which can only be
broken via some coalition deal or another. In both cases – it’s basically a
Israel’s election returns gave rise to shallow commentary abroad
that mostly missed the point. The Italian gridlock clearly set off great shock
Italy is the eurozone’s third-largest economy. The Italian
electorate evidently rejected pro-austerity tickets. That, alongside the ensuing
impasse, could well spell big trouble for Europe and rekindle its debt crisis.
Secondary fallout, should Europe slide deeper into recession, might indirectly
harm Israel’s economy too.
The Italian cliffhanger epitomized the
European nightmare as outgoing Premier Mario Monti – who steered Italy through
the worst that 2012 had to offer – trailed in fourth place. At the same time,
the irrepressible Silvio Berlusconi did better than expected, snapping at the
heels of the center-left Pier Luigi Bersani.
But despite the shivers sent
through the eurozone and despite the fear struck in the hearts of financiers
around the world, on the whole Italians took lesser risk with their votes than
The by-now perennial laid-back recklessness of the Israeli
voter incomparably exceeds any faddish ballot-box hijinks anywhere else.
Israelis, after all, face existential threats that far eclipse whatever
hypothetical economic mischief the Italian fiasco might activate or accentuate
in the eurozone.
The dangers which surround Israel involve our very
physical survival. From among all voters in all democracies, Israelis can least
afford to mortgage our most vital self-preservation concerns to a set of catchy
sound bites. We haven’t yet achieved anything like the strategic safety which
allows Italians the luxury to regard their political choice as a
With mounting instability and uncertainty in the neighboring “Arab
Spring” countries, with civil strife and rising forces of Islamic fanaticism,
with unpredictable rogue states like Iran persistently pursuing nuclear
ambitions, with terrorist machinations and incitement to hate by both the
Palestinian Authority and Hamas, can we really afford to divert attention even
to such emotive issues as “sharing the burden?” Are squabbles over the
procedural minutiae of rival plans to conscript haredim truly worth the damage
that the prolonged coalition wrangling causes? Can we afford Italian
idiosyncrasies? It is time to own up that no change in our electoral system
could cancel out the carelessness with which too many Israelis treat their
ballots. Voting for the trendy and unfamiliar as a hoot constitutes the root
aberration that stymies coalition construction, boosts the extortion potential
of marginal factions and condemns the mainstream to an Italian-like stalemate.
Jerusalem Post Annual Conference. Buy it now, Special offer. Come meet Israel's top leaders