Way too early
Sir, – With regard to your September 21 frontpage reminder for us
to set our clocks back by an hour overnight between Saturday and Sunday, can
someone please explain to me why we have to move the clocks before Yom Kippur?
Everyone I ask seems to be as clueless as I am.
It just doesn’t make
It seems so ridiculous to have to put on street lights so early
and when the weather is still so hot. No one seems to gain from it. Jews in the
Diaspora start the fast later and it doesn’t make a scrap of difference – the
fast is still 25 hours.
Why take our summer daylight away from us so
Trailers and cartoons
Sir, – Your
article “French paper prints cartoons ridiculing Muhammad, raising chances of
further Muslim rage” (September 20) mentions the cartoon on the cover of the
latest issue of the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo.
The cartoon recalls
a movie, this is true, but not the Hollywood film The Untouchables. It recalls
this year’s incredible cinema success in France called Intouchables, French for
“not allowed to touch.” In this case it refers to a disabled person who has no
feeling in his legs.
The cartoon uses as its basis the poster for the
film. Intouchables has won numerous awards and has been selected as the French
entry in the next Oscars.
But the strength of the Charlie Hebdo cover is
Worldwide judeophobes will notice that the film was directed
by two very successful young French cinema heroes, Olivier Nakache and Eric
Both are Jewish.
LAURENT ISRAEL CUDKOWICZ
– Have any of the Muslims who are rioting around the world seen the trailer
Innocence of Muslims? Who informed them of its existence? Instead of nations
beating their breasts in contrition and remaining utterly bewildered as to what
caused the violence, why isn’t there an investigation as to who got out the
word? Who heated up the Muslim mobs? Who would benefit? I am totally appalled
that lauded intelligence agencies such as the CIA and MI6 have not attempted to
pursue the trail that leads from the film trailer to the incitement of Muslim
Sir, – Is not the simple truth behind the
Muslim rage at perceived insults to its prophet the fact that Arabs just have no
sense of humor? There are plenty of jokes about Moses and Jesus. The good ones
we laugh at, the others we shrug off as tasteless. The film Life of Brian had a
rough ride at first but is now considered a classic work of satire.
the name of humanity, Islam, it doesn’t hurt to crack a smile now and
Sir, – Knesset member Talab
a-Sanaa would have us ban videos based on religious hatred (“Israeli-Arab
leaders petition Google to block ‘Innocence of Muslims,’” September
Good idea. Lets start with videos on YouTube showing Arab and
Islamic TV programs denigrating Jews or Israel. True to form, a-Sanaa would not
condemn any of this filth, claiming that Jews also incite against
The difference, of course, is that any Israeli who produces
anti-Muslim media can look forward to prosecution, while anti- Semitism in
a-Sanaa’s world is encouraged and rewarded.
Sir, – With regard to “Batman joins Spider-Man in court over
common enemy: Kippa Man” (September 19), what’s the complaint? For years, young
kippa wearers have been giving the comics free advertisements, as has the kippa
seller by displaying them.
Whether kippot gain value due to a display of
Spider-Man is most likely a moot point.
MIRIAM L. GAVARIN
Sir, – Thank you for publishing “From Kosovo to Catalonia”
(Fundamentally Freund, September 20), which exposes the folly of Kosovo’s
This singular event demonstrated to the world
that terrorists can indeed successfully alter the borders of sovereign nations,
and encourages secessionists the world over as national borders unravel because
of the desecration and erosion of international law.
spiritual Jerusalem to Serbian Orthodox Christians, is currently an impoverished
economic basket case that has been ethnically cleaned of non-Albanians. It will
never be recognized by the UN and is now serving as a drugdealing/
sex-slave/organ-harvesting conduit, as well as Islamic-terrorist safe haven
protected by NATO.
Western nations (most recently, the US in Libya) are
suffering significant blowback from their fanatical support of a beast they have
Sir, – I am sorry to point out
that Michael Freund has shown his ignorance of the relationship between England
He states that Scottish nationalists are gearing up to
escape English rule.
England does not and never did rule Scotland. In
1603 James, King of Scotland, ascended to the English throne by virtue of his
Tudor ancestry, thus creating a United Kingdom (he coined the
The parliaments were joined by agreement in 1707 as a good
business deal. Scotland did well and in fact is over-represented in Westminster,
to the extent that there are some chauvinist English who would like to get rid
of this influence.
FDR had good PR
Sir, – In
reference to Rafael Medoff’s “Jewish leader to FDR: ‘Don’t send Rosh Hashana
greetings’” (Comment & Features, September 19), most of us American Jews
thought Franklin D. Roosevelt was the greatest.
Evidently, his public
relations staff did a good job.
If not for Rabbi Abba Hillel Silver, most
of us would have continued in the same vein, content in the belief that men like
Rabbi Steven Wise were wise in their statements about FDR. We did not know that
Wise and other Jewish leaders had been taken in by the president, who really
couldn’t have cared less for European Jews.
Sir, – This week, leaders of the world will be in New York City
speaking at the United Nations.
Those from France will give their address
in French, those from Germany in German. Iran’s Mahmoud Ahmadinejad will speak
in Farsi, and the leaders of Arab countries will give their addresses in
The prime minister of Israel, though, will probably not be
speaking in Hebrew, but in English.
Here is an opportunity, missed so
often in the past, for our elected leader to speak on the world stage with many
millions of listeners, in our country’s dynamic, living language.
understand that Binyamin Netanyahu is a master at communicating in
Yet I recommend that he start his speech in Hebrew, and after
two minutes switch to English, starting from the beginning. I (and, I believe,
most Israelis) would be bursting with pride to hear Hebrew spoken at the UN,
even if only for two minutes.
Incidentally, there would be a bonus for
him in starting his speech in Hebrew. Can you imagine the shocked delegates
scrambling to put on their earphones? His words would attract studious
I. SRUL ZUNDER