No more apologies for Israel

How many times have you actually changed the mind of an anti-Israel critic or even given him or her pause?

January 12, 2015 19:54
4 minute read.
Homes in West Bank settlement

Homes in West Bank settlement. (photo credit: MARC ISRAEL SELLEM)

I have recently returned from a visit to Israel and can report that the state of the State of Israel is excellent.

How, one might ask, can this be when Israel fought another deadly round of war in Gaza just this past summer and random acts of terrorism in Jerusalem suggest another intifada may be imminent? The answer lies in my confidence that the people of Israel have the courage and wisdom to do what is necessary to ensure their own security, regardless of what others may say or do.

Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.

Israel is the subject of severe criticism on many fronts.

It is attacked for its “occupation” of the West Bank, for its building of Jewish “settlements” in that territory, for its construction of a security wall to thwart terrorist attacks, and for its “disproportional” response to rockets fired from Gaza at its citizens – just a few of the common charges directed at Israel. It is characterized as a racist, apartheid society.

Of course, these, and other similar slanders against Israel, are simply wrong as a matter of fact. But I won’t go into a lengthy rebuttal of these baseless claims here or anywhere else for that matter. I have come to believe that the time for an apologetic defense of the State of Israel is over. Indeed, Bayit Yehudi chairman Naftali Bennett recently launched a pro-Israel “no apologies” media campaign.

Why stop engaging Israel’s enemies? Because it does no good. How many times have you countered every charge thrown at Israel by your anti-Israel friends and colleagues with undisputed facts that completely refute whatever negative claim they might be making. Settlements.

Occupation. Desperation. Checkpoints. Apartheid. Etc.

And how many times have you actually changed the mind of an anti-Israel critic or even given him or her pause? Right. Never. Not once.

Why is that? Because the mindset of the critics of Israel is not fact-based or even rational. It is grounded in an agenda forged, at best, out of a desire on the part of the anti-Israel exponent to fit into a certain social set, whether it be academia, a liberal circle of friends or a Christian “human rights” community. At worst, and, more commonly, the anti-Israel attitude is grounded in good old-fashioned, but ever popular, anti-Semitism.

One can talk until one is blue in the face, but one will never convince someone who instinctively blames Israel for the problems in the region that Israel retains the moral high ground. I know. I have tried for 66 years.

Aside from its futility, it is time to abandon a defensive posture to supporting Israel because it is not necessary.

This is because it just doesn’t matter what the critics of Israel say, think, or do. It doesn’t matter what you, your friends or your cousin Bernie think about Israel.

It doesn’t matter what the columnists of The New York Times or The Washington Post, the heads of the European Union or the United Nations, the leaders of think tanks, churches, synagogues, charities, institutes, or the writers of op-eds, blogs, tweets, and comments think either. It doesn’t even matter what the present holder of the office of the president of the United States thinks.

(For those of you who say that what the president says matters because Israel could not survive without the support of the United States, that support is not in jeopardy.

The United States does not provide financial support to Israel out of charity, but in its own national interest.

The US receives a substantial return on its investment in the form of intelligence sharing, training of US military and law enforcement personnel in Israel, and Israel’s purchase of weapons and supplies from US companies providing jobs for American workers. In addition, the vast majority of the American people recognize Israel as their only friend and ally in a hostile Middle East and consistently support Israel).

The survival of the State of Israel does not depend upon any of these elite institutions or individuals. Certainly, it would be nice to have these entities express a more sympathetic attitude toward the only democracy in the Middle East. However, their unwarranted and often abusive criticisms do not pose an existential threat to the State of Israel or its people. From its founding in 1948, Israel has managed to survive (and prosper) with support from various countries, groups and individuals. It will continue to do so.

But, most importantly, Israel has managed to survive the wars and terrorism launched against it because of the character of its people. As David Ben-Gurion famously said upon the founding of the State of Israel: “What matters is not what the goyim say, but what the Jews do.” Having just returned from Israel, I am happy to report that the strength and wisdom of its people will see them through. They are a strong, incredibly diverse and unbelievably intelligent group of individuals. They know exactly what they are doing. And they will prevail.

After all, for them, the issues they confront are not mere academic exercises as they are for the rest of the world.

For the people of Israel, these issues are a matter of life and death. And they have nowhere else to go.

The author is a writer and attorney in Washington, DC.

Related Content

Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman speaks in Tel Aviv
March 17, 2018
An open letter to Defense Minister Liberman and the haredi leadership


Israel Weather
  • 10 - 25
    Beer Sheva
    11 - 20
    Tel Aviv - Yafo
  • 12 - 18
    13 - 20
  • 19 - 28
    12 - 25