Former Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) director Ami Ayalon sharply criticized the agency's conduct in recent months, warning that excluding Arab citizens from political participation poses a serious threat to Israeli democracy and national security.
Speaking on Thursday at the Palmach Museum in Tel Aviv during the launch of Dr. Amir Gilat's book Dam Adam Adama, which examines the Wadi Ara region, Ayalon argued that Israel was failing to uphold its commitment to equality for Arab citizens.
Ayalon, who previously commanded the Israeli Navy, referenced the findings of the Shamgar Commission, which investigated the assassination of prime minister Yitzhak Rabin and the Shin Bet's handling of informant Avishai Raviv, known by the codename "Champagne."
According to Ayalon, the commission's warnings against politically stigmatizing legitimate communities remain particularly relevant today.
Ayalon warns Shin Bet against undermining Israel's democratic institutions
"When the activities of the Shin Bet become activities that harm democracy by excluding a legitimate population that wants to participate but is prevented from doing so, this constitutes a devastating blow to the democratic system and the institutions the agency is entrusted with protecting," Ayalon said.
"I hope the agency's employees, its senior officials, and all citizens of the State of Israel hear these words."
Ayalon extended his criticism to the government, accusing it of embracing an ideological approach that he associated with the views of the late extremist rabbi Meir Kahane.
"Government policy has chosen a form of Judaism that expresses Rabbi Kahane's racist position," he said.
He pointed to the "Decisive Plan" published by Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich in 2017, arguing that it reflected the government's current policies toward Arab citizens and Palestinians in the West Bank.
Ayalon questioned the meaning of democracy when majority rule is used to justify denying minority rights.
"When democracy becomes the rule of a majority that believes it has the right to trample the individual citizen and the minority," he said, the meaning of a Jewish and democratic state must be reconsidered.
He argued that Israel was failing to honor the commitment to equality made to Arab citizens in the Declaration of Independence.
"Damaging the right to be a full partner in all institutions of government is, first and foremost, a violation and blatant repudiation of the promise we made to Israel's Arabs," he said.
Political exclusion of Arab citizens could increase violence, former security chief says
Ayalon warned that preventing Arab citizens from participating fully in political life could have serious security consequences.
"Israel will be a Jewish, democratic, and secure state only if we allow Arab citizens of Israel full and equal participation in all state institutions," he said.
"And it will not be Jewish, democratic, and secure if we do not do so."
He argued that declining trust in government institutions could eventually contribute to lawbreaking and violence.
"I am telling you, as someone who served as head of the Shin Bet and spent 34 years as a commander in the IDF, we saw exactly this process before the Second Intifada," Ayalon said.
According to Ayalon, when a state promises equality but prevents citizens from exercising those rights, it creates a process in which public confidence in government deteriorates and the risk of violence increases.
Survey shows deep distrust of government among Arab Israelis
Ayalon cited figures from what he described as a 2026 Israel Democracy Institute survey, highlighting a significant crisis of confidence among Arab citizens.
According to the figures he presented, only 7% of Arab Israelis expressed trust in the government, while just 5% expressed confidence in the prime minister.
He also said approximately 75% of Arab respondents supported including Arab political parties in government, while 71% of Jewish respondents opposed their participation in a governing coalition.
"They want to integrate, and we are unwilling to accept them as part of Israeli society," Ayalon said.
His remarks reflect wider debates over Arab political participation, with Israel Democracy Institute research also documenting substantial support among Arab voters for involvement in government.
Addressing the high turnout among Arab voters in the recent elections, Ayalon rejected claims that the increase was primarily driven by violent incidents during the election period.
"Anyone who attributes it to the violent incidents that occurred during the elections simply does not know what they are talking about," he said.
"The anger and the desire to receive the rights promised to them are what brought them to the polling stations."
Ayalon cites Or Commission and Ka'adan ruling on Arab equality
Ayalon also referenced the Or Commission, which investigated the October 2000 events in which 13 Arab citizens were killed during clashes with police.
He recalled the commission's conclusion that Israeli state institutions had failed to fully recognize Arab citizens as equal members of society.
Ayalon argued that even court rulings intended to protect equality do not necessarily translate into changes on the ground.
As an example, he cited the landmark Ka'adan case, in which the High Court of Justice recognized the right of an Arab family to equal access to state land in the community of Katzir.
According to Ayalon, the continuing gap between legal commitments and their implementation highlights the broader challenge facing Israel's democratic institutions.
Former Shin Bet director calls for Judaism based on equality and human dignity
Ayalon urged Israelis to embrace what he described as a different understanding of Jewish values from the one he believes currently dominates Israeli politics.
"We need to choose a Judaism that sees the human being," he said, emphasizing compassion, equality, and the treatment of strangers and vulnerable members of society.
"When we became sovereign, we forgot what it meant to be strangers," Ayalon said.
"Not thousands of years ago, but just one generation ago. And when we became sovereign, we forgot that we had been strangers, and we treat them as foreigners, as others who do not have the rights of those who hold sovereignty."
He argued that Israeli society must recognize the connection between maintaining the country's Jewish and democratic identity and ensuring equal rights for Arab citizens.
Ayalon urges Israeli civil society to defend democratic future
Concluding his speech, Ayalon called on Israeli civil society to take responsibility for the country's democratic future.
He maintained that equal participation for Arab citizens was not only a democratic obligation but also a prerequisite for Israel's long-term security and identity.
"We, the citizens of Israel, still refuse to see the simple truth that only by fulfilling the promise of partnership we made to Israel's Arabs in the Declaration of Independence can we preserve our security and our Jewish-democratic identity," Ayalon said.
"We, as a society, are ultimately the ones who hold responsibility."