Animal rights group Hakol Chai has launched a campaign against the Agriculture
and Rural Development Ministry’s August decision to invest NIS 750,000 in horse
breeding, charging that such horses will be raised predominantly for racing and
will likewise be subject to cruel consequences.
The increase in funds
toward horse breeding, Hakol Chai argued in a statement on Monday, is in reality
a ministerial effort to promote the establishment of horse racing and gambling
without due legislation, stemming from a government decision to establish
Israel’s first hippodrome in 2004. With a horse racing industry would come
animal brutality, as racehorses are often drugged for enhanced performance and
slaughtered when they can no longer perform due to horse overpopulation,
according to a statement from the group.
“Gambling on horse racing cannot
legally take place in Israel unless it is first approved by the Knesset,” said
Hakol Chai’s professional manager, Tal Sahar, in the statement. “Yet even before
a bill to permit gambling on horse racing has been introduced into the Knesset,
the ministry offered more than NIS 750,000 in public funds to farms willing to
breed race horses.”
While the Agriculture Ministry did confirm that its
increased efforts to strengthen the horse breeding industry do stem partially
from the 2004 hippodrome decision, a ministry representative told The Jerusalem
Post the office has no part in promoting gambling.
“The ministry began to
raise the level of the horse breeding industry similarly to what is accepted in
Western countries, and to support the advancement of activities related to
promoting the welfare of the horses – growth, multiplicity, training, treatment,
living conditions and economic management,” the ministry told the Post in
response to Hakol Chai’s allegations. “The decision and this tender indeed rely
on the 2004 government decision concerning the establishment of a hippodrome,
yet it is not intended to strengthen the decision but rather to provide a
fitting resolution to a developing industry in many aspects that are unrelated
to the hippodrome operations, and therefore the claim that the issue of support
requires legislation in the Knesset is to be denied.”
Not only will the
newly bred horses be used for racing, but they will also be used for therapeutic
and rehabilitative purposes, as well as bolster the economies of peripheral
areas with new industry, the ministry said.
Adamant in her opinion that
the horses would be mistreated, however, Hakol Chai CEO Nina Natelson slammed
the ministry for attempting to get racehorses a legal exemption from Israel’s
Animal Protection Law.
“All of these cruelties – it’ll be a free-for
all,” she said.
“It’s on the backs of horses – nobody cares about the
welfare of the animals.”
While the ministry confirmed it was in fact
trying to remove racehorses from the Animal Protection Law, the office said it
is aiming for the horses protected under different, slightly less strict
legislation, rather than no legislation at all, as is common throughout the
“Bad things happen to horses who aren’t producing money
for their owners, so a lot of ex-racehorses end up in situations like becoming
cart horses – they’re sold from hand to hand,” Natelson contended, arguing that
Israel doesn’t have room for a surplus of horses.
In England, Natelson
explained, the unwanted retired racehorses end up on dinner plates in France and
But the ministry argued that the racehorses are welltreated,
noting that organizations must receive permits from the ministry’s Veterinary
Services in order to hold a race, and throughout the entire race day, a ministry
veterinarian is present to supervise the proceedings.
Ever since the
ministry implemented a method for supervising horse races in December 2006, no
deaths or accidents to the horses have occurred, the ministry said.
Agriculture Ministry and its minister attach great importance to the maintenance
of animal welfare in general and to the welfare of racehorses in particular,
according to the strictest s t a n d a r d s accepted internationally,” the
Horse racing, however, has not occurred in great numbers
since the hippodrome approval in 2004. After granted government consent,
Israel’s first and only hippodrome was constructed in the Gilboa region near
Afula, with opening day at the races occurring in October 2006.
then, only about two races – small hobby, show races – have occurred, according
to Shlomi Eyal, manager of the sports department at the Gilboa Regional
“We are working very hard to get all the p e r m i s - sions.
It’s not easy to be able to open races. It’s on the way,” Eyal said. “There are
only a few countries in the world that don’t have horse races and we are one of
them. We would love to have them.”
Despite the concerns of animal rights
activists, Eyal said the council was firm in its desire to bring horse racing to
“It’s impossible to even understand that in 2012 almost we
still don’t have races even though the government decided that the races would
be in the Gilboa area,” he said. “It will better the area unbelievably.”