|Photo by: REUTERS/Baz Ratner|
Analysis: Not such a Garden of Eden
By YONAH JEREMY BOB
Avigdor Liberman must have envisioned several scenarios for his historic court case.
With the famous “everything is a Garden of Eden” comment he uttered the day his
original indictment was announced on December 13, Yisrael Beytenu party leader
Avigdor Liberman must have envisioned several scenarios.
All of them
likely involved a full or overall acquittal and no finding of moral
But he probably also was focused a lot on timing.
best scenario was to finish the trial before elections. He could go into
election day with his name cleared, maybe get a pre-election-day bounce and go
right back to his office in the Foreign Ministry as if he had merely taken a
That was never very likely, but when the initial
indictment was announced, with fewer witnesses than ultimately turned up on the indictment that was actually
submitted, it was not completely impossible.
It essentially became
impossible when a Channel 10 report on missed testimony from outgoing Deputy
Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon and other Foreign Ministry officials pressured the
prosecution to decide to reopen its investigation and requestion Liberman –
killing another two weeks.
When the final indictment was submitted on
December 27, the election was less than a month away. There were now 23
witnesses, and the fact that the state decided to take two weeks more for the
investigation showed that prosecutors were in no rush to comply with Liberman’s
Still, there was an outside shot that the trial could
be started before elections and finished soon after, allowing Liberman to return
to the Foreign Ministry upon the formation of a new government.
became nearly impossible, though, when the court waited until January 27 just to
announce that the trial would start only on February 17.
chances of seamlessly rejoining the new government upon its formation were
finally put to rest on Sunday when the court set a trial schedule that would not
have it reconvene until late April, and probably not finish before late May or
early June – and then only if there are no delays.
knew this all too well as they pushed off the court’s suggestion of having a
hearing in late March or early April due to Passover, preferring to defer the
case a few more weeks. These are the actions of people who know that they have
missed the “get immediately into the new government” deadline.
team is still doing everything it can to speed things along: They made no
general claims to try to beat the charges before hearing witnesses; no claims
that his police interrogation was improper in any way; and none of the other
usual attempts to beat the charges and avoid a full trial.
They want to
move on to the witnesses and get the court to rule.
If Liberman is
acquitted in late spring, it has been widely speculated that he will return to
the Foreign Ministry if Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu “holds” the post for
him. But the whole idea of “holding” is very uncertain, and Netanyahu, no matter
how loyal he is to his political ally, would likely consider the formation of a
new government more important.
Even with an acquittal, the state might
appeal, as it did with former prime minister Ehud Olmert, something that would
keep Liberman out of the cabinet for another three or six months, or perhaps
None of these possibilities are anywhere near the “Garden of
Eden” scenario Liberman was hoping for.
While it might not be easy to
prove the crimes he is accused of, his claims that this would be an easy case
must now be viewed from the current vantage point, which he does not control and
has not succeeded much in influencing.