The Knesset House Committee is unlikely to authorize Kadima chairman Shaul
Mofaz’s attempt to fire four of his party’s 28 MKs, Likud and Kadima sources
said on Monday.
In a letter to House Committee chairman Yariv Levin
(Likud), Mofaz said that MKs Otniel Schneller, Yulia Shamalov Berkovich, Arieh
Bibi and Avraham Duan had left Kadima, based on quotes attributed to them in the
In his letter, Mofaz cited Article 61 of the 1994 Knesset Law,
which says the committee must investigate whether a lawmaker has actually left
his faction before authorizing such a change.
The House Committee will
hold a tribunal in which Kadima will present its claim that the legislators had
already quit the party.
Each MK can individually argue otherwise. Though
the MKs may bring a lawyer to Tuesday’s meeting, none planned to do so as of
Monday evening. Should Kadima or individual MKs disagree with the verdict, they
can appeal to the Jerusalem District Court.
If the committee authorizes
Mofaz’s request regarding the four MKs, the legislators would no longer be
members of any faction and as such would be unable to propose bills or motions
for the agenda. They would be unable to join any other faction or run on that
faction’s list in the next election unless they first resigned from the
It would also be impossible to appoint them as ministers or
deputy ministers, as the Likud had promised some MKs.
If the House
Committee turns Mofaz down, as is expected, the lawmakers may join another
faction, although they are unlikely to be accepted if they cannot find three
more Kadima lawmakers to join them so they can take party funding with
A source in Mofaz’s camp was skeptical that the House Committee
would force the foursome out of Kadima, saying the party would “dry them out”
instead. This means they would find themselves remaining in Kadima in a
situation similar to that of renegade Shas MK Haim Amsalem, who is essentially
ignored by the other members of his faction, who do not allow him to propose
legislation or motions to the Knesset agenda.
“Mofaz’s letter to the
House Committee is not serious and has no chance of being authorized,”
Government Services Minister Michael Eitan (Likud) said.
“MKs are not
marionettes who can be thrown away and punished just because of internal
Committee chairman Levin also said Mofaz’s letter was
unlikely to be authorized as it “barely presents a hint of a [valid]
From a legal standpoint, he said, quotes in the press about
signed agreements to jump from Kadima to the Likud would not hold water unless
the contracts were presented.
“This is a serious, weighty decision
because if an MK is forced to leave his faction he will have no funding and
cannot join an existing party in future elections,” Levin explained. “Real proof
is necessary to justify such a step.”
Levin added that the tribunal would
be fair and he would hear both sides’ claims.
marketplace, in which someone jumps from one party to another without
considering ideology, must be condemned,” Levin added.
“However, that is
not enough under the law. It is not enough that what they did does not look
The Likud MK pointed out that it was legal for groups of seven or
more MKs to leave a party, although if the four failed in their attempt it was
not reason for punishment.
Levin also said that disagreements between a
party leader and members of his faction were not a good enough reason for the
committee to allow the party leader to clean house. He called for all MKs on the
House Committee to vote according to legal considerations and said there could
not be party or coalition discipline in Tuesday’s meeting.