GENEVA — Israel is not cooperating with the UN Human Rights Council's probe of May's deadly raid on a Gaza-bound aid flotilla, and it was unclear if investigators will be able to speak with Israeli soldiers involved, a UN official said Tuesday.
Juan Carlos Monge, a UN human rights officer working with the fact-finding mission, said the panel was speaking with other witnesses and government officials in Turkey and Jordan.
Opinion: Israel at the UN - An affair to follow
Ban Ki-Moon's flotilla probe begins
But Israel hasn't granted an invitation to the team, which is examining whether Israeli commandos broke international law by killing nine pro-Palestinian activists trying to break the Jewish state's blockade of Gaza. Eight of the dead activists were Turks, and the ninth was Turkish-American. Israel said the soldiers acted in self defense.
Monge said in an e-mail to The Associated Press that the mission would
only speak with Israeli soldiers about the incident if permission was
given by the Israeli government. Such approval is important to the
investigation if it hopes to be objective, but Israel has refused to
work with council probes in the past, citing their bias.
Israel's UN mission said Tuesday it will not comment on the
investigation, but Israeli officials have suggested since the panel's
creation in June that the Jewish state wouldn't cooperate. Israel
considers the Human Rights Council to be anti-Israel, and points to a
series of critical resolutions by the body in its four-year history.
Israel is working with a separate UN group under New Zealand's ex-Prime
Minister Geoffrey Palmer and Colombia's ex-President Alvaro Uribe that
is also examining the incident, said Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal
But Palmor said the 47-nation rights council "deals obsessively and
morbidly with Israel."
Former UN war crimes prosecutor Desmond de Silva, Trinidadian judge Karl
T. Hudson-Phillips and Malaysian women's rights advocate Mary Shanthi
Dairiam are investigating on behalf of the rights council.