When a 16-year-old motorcyclist crashed into a truck and died on Wednesday, it
marked the 330th traffic accident casualty of 2010.
Road safety advocacy
group Or Yarok said on Thursday that the nation had now exceeded its maximum
fatality target rate for the year, with two months left before January
The Transportation Ministry said in response: “We don’t deal in
numbers and targets when it comes to human lives.”
Deaths in traffic
accidents so far this year – 332 – increased by 11 percent compared to the same
period in 2009, when 298 died. This rise presents a reversal of a long-term
trend of reduced accidents and fatalities.
Last January, after Israel saw
a remarkable 22% drop in trafficrelated fatalities in 2009 (the lowest in 43
years), Transportation Minister Yisrael Katz (Likud) spoke proudly of his
ministry’s achievements in reducing casualty rates and surpassing the targets
set by the government.
On Thursday however, when asked to respond to Or
Yarok’s statement, Transportation Ministry spokesman, Avner Ovadiah, said that
the ministry doesn’t have casualty reduction targets, since it doesn’t deal in
numbers and targets when it comes to human lives. “We don’t have a target of
330. That’s Or Yarok’s target, not ours,” he said.
The minister’s media
adviser also refused to comment on the issue, saying that the minister would
address yearly summaries at the end of the year.
Or Yarok said that the
ministry’s refusal to acknowledge the fatality reduction target was disingenuous
and that the targets were set and approved by the government in 2005, when it
adopted the recommendations of the Sheinin Committee, a panel established to
develop a long-term plan to battle road casualties.
Committee set a clear target of reducing the death rate by 30% by 2010, to below
360 deaths a year, and below 300 by 2015,” Or Yarok spokesman Elad Sasi said.
“That works out to a 6% annual reduction. Six percent below last years’ rate of
350 deaths works out to 330 for 2010. The ministry can’t deny those numbers,
just because they failed to reach the target.”
Collecting data and
setting casualty reduction targets are a common and proven method of reducing
casualty figures. The European Council recently adopted a plan to reduce traffic
casualties by 50% in 10 years, after a similar effort for the previous decade
produced positive results in member countries. The 15 European countries that
joined the original plan in 2001 showed a 42% drop in traffic
“Even if the targets are not reached, having them in place gives
both the government and the public incentives to try,” Sasi said.
November, Katz participated in a Global Ministerial Conference on Road Safety,
held in Moscow. The ministers resolved to “Set ambitious yet feasible national
road traffic casualty reduction targets that are clearly linked to planned
investments and policy initiatives and mobilize the necessary resources to
enable effective and sustainable implementation to achieve targets in the
framework of a safe systems approach,” and to “Improve national data collection
and comparability at the international level, including by adopting the standard
definition of a road death as any person killed immediately or dying within 30
days as a result of a road traffic crash.”
The ministry spokesman
declined to comment on the Moscow commitments.
In March, MK Nitzan
Horowitz (Meretz) issued a formal question to Katz in the Knesset, asking him
what the casualty reductions target for 2010 was and how it was
Katz responded then that “Every person is a world unto
himself and therefore it is unworthy, in my opinion, to set targets for
‘casualty numbers’ and lists of fatalities. We are working to reduce the number
of accidents and the number of casualties relative to last year and bring about
constant improvement in road and vehicle safety in Israel.”
the National Road Safety Authority monthly casualty report, out of the 332
deaths recorded in 2010, 200 were Jews and 129 were non- Jews, 140 occurred
within city limits and 192 took place on inter-city roads, 113 were pedestrians,
39 were motorcyclists and 13 were cyclists.