Analysis: Victory through a truce?
ByDavid Brinn
13 July 2014 05:57
The notion Israel can rid the world of Hamas is as unrealistic as the desire of Hamas to see a Palestinian state rise on the ruins of Israel.
Gaza

An iron dome launches rockets to intercept incoming rockets from Gaza on Tuesday.. (photo credit:REUTERS)

As the fifth day of Operation Protective Edge wound down Saturday night, with Hamas fulfilling its early evening vow to rain down rockets on Greater Tel Aviv at 9 in the evening, the options Israel and the IDF possess aren’t any clearer than they were on day one.

Despite Hamas’s macho threats and salvos of rockets, the effect on life in Israel has been minimal. The Iron Dome system has proven to be amazingly effective at protecting the country’s citizens, and as a result there’s a lopsided casualty tally on the Gaza side, where Hamas has called on citizens to stand their ground instead of seeking shelter. Israel’s measured response to the Hamas offensive has prevented the Palestinian civilian death toll, as painfully high as it is, from being much more extensive.



Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.


With IDF troops amassed and waiting the order to begin a ground invasion of Gaza, there are signs of various Arab-initiated efforts for a cease-fire. Which way the conflict will go in the next couple of days depends on the goals of our political leaders.

Is it realistic to think a ground campaign in Gaza will result in the toppling of the Hamas leadership? The IDF would have to level huge tracts, and even then it would require months of hunts in tunnels, high casualties on both sides and the specter of Israel once again being mired in Gaza without an exit plan.

Our military echelon has stated repeatedly that Hamas has been gravely weakened over the past week by the IAF’s strikes. If the option of a cease-fire is on the table that will stop the continued rocket attacks – not just in the center of the country, but in the South, where they have never really stopped – then it’s an option Israel needs to take seriously.

Aside from some property damage, trauma and a few injuries, Israel has remained unscathed by the Hamas attacks so far. Can we live with this kind of outburst every year or every few months? If it means saving countless lives of IDF soldiers and a long, bloody campaign in Gaza, then the answer is yes.

The notion Israel can rid the world of Hamas is as unrealistic as the desire of Hamas to see a Palestinian state rise on the ruins of Israel. The best that can be hoped for is a weakened Hamas becoming marginalized, the people of Gaza demanding true leadership, and moderate Palestinians uniting the people of Gaza and the West Bank and returning to negotiations with Israel.

As unlikely as that scenario might be, striving for it is still preferable to the inevitable mounting casualties and unachievable goals of a long ground offensive.

Relevant to your professional network? Please share on Linkedin

Tags:
  • Israel
  • Gaza
  • Hamas
  • Palestinians
  • Prev Article
    Juggling war, plans and planes
    El-Al passengers waiting to board flight
    gaza strip
    Rocket fire continues as IDF's noon deadline passes for northern Gazans to evacuate
    Next Article
    Share this article via
    from around the web
    Related Content
    Abu Ubaida
    28 August 2014
    Media are Hamas’s main strategic weapons, says visiting US historian

    By BENJAMIN WEINTHAL

    Top Stories
    Israel Weather
    • 8 - 18
      Beer Sheva
      11 - 18
      Tel Aviv - Yafo
    • 6 - 13
      Jerusalem
      12 - 16
      Haifa
    • 11 - 21
      Elat
      10 - 19
      Tiberias