See the latest opinion pieces on our page
Amid such hatred and weakness, it feels foolish to sit around a darkened room, listening to yet another Holocaust survivor’s story. Standing still during the siren is the opposite of what we should be doing. We need action not contemplation, anger not mourning. We must avert a future Holocaust, not regret the first one.Precisely at this danger point, accept two other obligations. First, honor the millions murdered and those who survived by listening to them. Elie Wiesel teaches: “To forget the dead would be akin to killing them a second time.” That, frankly, is easy. Jews, Zionists, Israelis, democratic patriots, are good memorializers. We know how to bathe in memory, cherish our heroes, echo our past. The second obligation is harder. Even in a world rife with injustice, teetering toward madness, learn to resist false analogies. It’s not 1938, because we have a flourishing Jewish state and a powerful Jewish army. It’s not 1938, because we have an engaged America not an isolationist America. It’s not 1938, because we live in a more civilized world.Commemorating Yom Hashoah honestly also involves isolating the variables that made the Holocaust unique, not just generalizing the ones that make it seem imminent. Yes, beware violent words. But also beware sloppy comparisons. In his challenging and uplifting 2011 book, The Better Angels of our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined, the cognitive scientist Steven Pinker provides nearly 800 hundred pages of good news, showing that our era, for all its faults, is the least violent, the least tumultuous, the most civilized, the most humanitarian epoch humans have ever enjoyed. The post-Nazi “Long Peace” has now been followed by the post-Soviet “New Peace.”Especially in the West, our media-fueled outrage sometimes reflects a bratty perfectionism. Once, life genuinely was nasty, brutish and short; today, it’s mostly cushy, safe and long. As a result, we get particularly annoyed when things go wrong, when that pleasant baseline feels threatened.Anger is legitimate when confronting injustice; just judge today’s chaos in context. In Jewish terms, the change from 1938 and 2015 is transformational. In spring, 1944, Nazi killers in Auschwitz gassed 6,000 Hungarian Jews a day. That means that the Nazis slaughtered more Jews in five days than the 25,000 Jews Arabs have murdered in a century of war and terrorism.Today, most Jews live in free, safe, prosperous countries, with most living in Israel and the United States, two of the happiest experiments in productive, constructive, peaceful Jewish living in our 3,500-year history.We need that context not to approve a contemptible surrender to Iran or to restrain our fury at even the slightest stirring of anti-Semitism. But that perspective highlights the true horrors our ancestors and elders endured. We also should appreciate all we have, cataloging all the good we got from our parents’ and grandparents’ sacrifices. And we should fight hard to guarantee that just like they made a better world for us, we leave our children an even better, safer, sounder world.When you stand at attention this Yom Hashoah, don’t just remember the past also but think of an effective action plan, asking, “What am I doing to fight anti-Semitism today and to build a positive modern Zionism for the future?” When listening to survivors, find inspiration in their grit and ingenuity. And with zero tolerance for any intolerance that remains, let’s celebrate all the good in our lives, even at this sobering moment.The author is a professor of history at McGill University and is teaching this semester at Hebrew University’s Rothberg School. His eleventh book, The Age of Clinton: America in the 1990s, will be published in October. @GilTroy