One bright spot in the recent dark days arrived via Canada. The brave northern
state broke relations with Iran, pure and simple, without blinking an eye, and
proved that even in the West people can every now and then recognize
Relations between Canada and Israel have never been better, and
the mutual esteem, cooperation (even security) is great. We can only hope that
the Canadian move will lead to other countries following suit (though I wouldn’t
hold my breath).
Amid the warm ties between Israel and Canada, an
internal Israeli conflict has taken place that has been kept secret until
The Israeli military attaché in the US (now returning to Israel
after two years and 10 months), Maj.-Gen. Gadi Shamni, traveled last year to
Ottawa for a working meeting.
Shamni was scheduled to meet with all the
top Canadian security figures.
First, though, Shamni met with Israeli
Ambassador to Canada Miriam Ziv. During the meeting, Ziv expressed her wish for
an independent military attaché to Canada, who would be based in Ottawa, in
light of closer relations and rapprochement between the two
Shamni objected. We work really well in Washington, he said,
we have no problems in our relationship; to bring a military attaché in uniform,
with family, etc., to Canada would be a waste.
The conversation became
unpleasant as both Ziv and Shamni argued. At one point, Shamni got so livid that
he got up and left the room.
The meetings with the Canadians were held
later the same day, and everything went well.
The highlight was supposed
to occur in the evening, when a dinner party at the ambassador’s house was set
to honor Shamni in the presence of all the top Canadian security figures; the
chief of staff, the head of intelligence, the head of the National Security
Shamni announced to Ziv that he wouldn’t be coming to the
dinner, which was coordinated months in advance with all the tight schedules of
all the respected participants. The ambassador tried to reason with him –
everyone was invited, all had confirmed their arrival, this is a very important
event, but Shamni insisted.
I cannot work with you after how you spoke to
me, he said.
Because the dinner is taking place in your house, I’m not
going to set foot there, he continued, and he unceremoniously left and flew back
The ambassador had to call and apologize. The attaché was
urgently called back to Washington, Ziv explained to the Canadian chief of
staff’s office and other offices. The dinner was canceled.
Those who live
in North America know that a cancellation of this type of meal, with just a few
hours notice, is considered rude. Only a medical emergency or a war justifies
such a move. But for Shamni, an IDF major-general representing the State of
Israel in the US, it did not matter. He just didn’t come. Ambassador Ziv
complained about the incident to all relevant parties in Israel. It turns out
that Shamni complained too. The question is, whom did the Canadians complain to?
The IDF Spokesman’s reaction was: “Major- General Shamni is currently completing
a successful and busy tenure in Washington, during which he preserved and
improved the professional and close work relationship with the Canadian security
agencies. The military attaché is in constant professional contact, in a
cooperative atmosphere and with promotion of projects, with the Canadian armed
forces, and all their branches.”
By the way, Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen.
Benny Gantz is aware of that incident and on his visit to Canada last March, he
spoke of it, separately, with the attaché and the ambassador.
of Shamni confirm the information written here, but claim that no damage was
caused to the bilateral relationship; the Canadians do not know, even now, that
the dinner was canceled because of ego conflicts.
The associates added
that the ambassador’s behavior toward Shamni was crude and blunt, she crossed
all red lines while offending him, which is actually insulting the defense
system as a whole, and with that, Shamni was not ready to continue to work with
I think that Shamni, a decorated veteran who has built solid
credentials in the IDF, missed the point. First, I tried to verify the version
of his associates, that the ambassador yelled at him and insulted him, but this
version was not supported by any other source.
Second, even if was true,
what’s the connection? Why should the Canadian defense establishment pay for a
bad working relationship in the Israeli ranks? Shamni does not represent himself
in the US, nor his wife, but the State of Israel and its security
He should have swallowed the insult, come to the dinner, and
then complained against Ziv as much as he pleased. Something in the
major-general’s judgment was wrong.
According to the information that’s
flowing from Washington and Ottawa, stated even by the military attaché office
itself, Shamni’s pride got a little too swollen.
Translated by Moria
Jerusalem Post Annual Conference. Buy it now, Special offer. Come meet Israel's top leaders