Senate Democrats: Annexation puts Israel’s security, democracy at risk

"[Annexation] would betray our shared democratic values by denying Palestinians’ right to self-determination in a viable, sovereign, independent and contiguous state.”

Defense Minister Benny Gantz [L] and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu [R] wearing masks in the Knesset  (photo credit: AVSHALOM SASSONI)
Defense Minister Benny Gantz [L] and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu [R] wearing masks in the Knesset
(photo credit: AVSHALOM SASSONI)
WASHINGTON – A group of 18 Senate Democrats have sent a letter to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Alternate Prime Minister Benny Gantz urging them not to move forward with annexing Israeli settlements in the West Bank.
Senators Chris Murphy, Chris Van Hollen and Tim Kaine drafted the letter, and senior senators such as Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders joined it.
“A deep commitment to Israel’s security and a shared set of democratic values are foundational elements of the close relationship between our countries,” the lawmakers wrote. “We are therefore concerned that unilateral annexation puts both Israel’s security and democracy at risk.”
They went on to say that annexation “would betray our shared democratic values by denying Palestinians’ right to self-determination in a viable, sovereign, independent and contiguous state.
“It could bring an end to Palestinian security cooperation with Israel, directly threatening the security of the Israeli people, and endanger Israel’s crucial peace agreement with Jordan,” the senators added.
“As friends and supporters of Israel, we caution you against taking unilateral steps that would fray our unique bonds, imperil Israel’s future and place out of reach the prospect of a lasting peace,” they continued.
“If you move forward with unilateral annexation, we would not support that action. This is consistent with long-standing American policy opposing unilateral actions by either party to the conflict. Pursuit of a viable, negotiated two-state solution is essential to ensuring our shared democratic values and lasting bipartisan support for Israel in Congress.”
The letter has been circulating in the Senate for a few weeks. The progressive Jewish group J Street asked supporters earlier this month to urge their respective senators to sign the letter. However, the majority of Senate Democrats did not sign the letter.
“Unilateral annexation of the West Bank would likely destroy prospects for a negotiated two-state settlement between Israel and the Palestinians, thus jeopardizing Israel’s long-term security,” Murphy said in a statement to The Jerusalem Post.
“The letter shows that there is a large group in the United States Senate who oppose this policy and are also willing to state the obvious – that if Israel is no longer committed to a two-state future, it will likely have an impact on the US-Israel relationship,” the senator added.
On May 6, Sen. Ben Cardin of Maryland implied in a conference call organized by the Jewish Democratic Council of America that he would not sign the letter. “I don’t like to second-guess Israel’s government decision,” he said.
“When you talk about annexation, I look at it in the context of how it advances the two-state solution, and I find unilateral actions not to be helpful [for that] process,” he said. “So, I have concerns about the annexation issue. I think that Israel is trying to implement a two-state solution unilaterally. I think there are risk factors about that.
“I would encourage them, instead, to try to preserve the process. But I don’t think it is helpful for us to sow dissension in the United States as it relates to the support for Israel,” Cardin addedA. “We have to show that even when we disagree with the policies of the government, the relationship between the US and Israel must remain strong.”
Democratic Majority for Israel President and CEO Mark Mellman said his organization opposes unilateral annexation, but the Senate Democrats letter “will be counterproductive in achieving its goals.”
“By focusing only on Israeli policies and not on Palestinian impediments to peace, nor on the failure of the Palestinian leadership to accept previous Israeli offers of statehood, the text also leaves a false impression and could send a dangerously misleading signal to Israel’s enemies,” Mellman added. “We are pleased that, in fact, every Senate Democrat is clearly on the record supporting both a strong US-Israel relationship and America’s role in ensuring Israel can defend itself, by itself.”