CONCERT REVIEW: Two Bachs and One Vivaldi

In the Jerusalem Baroque Orchestra’s recent concert, the Hamburg Hanseatic grande bourgeoisie's elegance was substituted with Israeli impatience.

By URY EPPSTEIN
March 25, 2010 10:56
1 minute read.
jerusalem symphony 88 298

jerusalem symphony 88 29. (photo credit: Courtesy)

JBO
Two Bachs and One Vivaldi
YMCA Auditorium
Jerusalem
March 23


In the Jerusalem Baroque Orchestra’s recent concert, Shalev Ad-El’s interpretation transformed the Allegro assai (“quite fast”) and Allegretto movements of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach’s Symphony No. 182/3 into a hasty, breathless Presto, substituting the stately elegance of the Hamburg Hanseatic grande bourgeoisie with Israeli nervosity and impatience.

Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.


In J.S. Bach’s Concerto for harpsichord BV 1055, soloist El-Ad’s playing was deplorably almost inaudible.

El-Ad, a harpsichordist who also conducts, also let himself be carried away by the orchestra instead of restraining it in Vivavldi’s “La Notte” Flute Concerto, and Jan de Winne’s solo was overshadowed as a result.

Only in the orchestra’s rare calm moments was it possible to enjoy the flute’s lyrical, lovingly shaped melodic passages and the threatening, dramatic ones of the imaginary night phantoms.

In J.S. Bach’s concluding Concerto for Flute, Violin and Harpsichord, instrumental balance was finally achieved. This allowed one to be duly impressed by the brilliant virtuosity of El-Ad’s harpsichord, the singing sound of de Winne’s flute, and Dafna Ravid’s baroque violin blending in harmoniously with her partners.


Related Content

Sarah Silverman
August 26, 2014
Jewish women take home gold at 2014 Emmys

By JTA