Sunday morning a few days before Passover little Tommy comes home from Hebrew school. As he sits at the kitchen table his mother puts a plate of waffles and maple syrup in front of him. After wiping her hands of the sticky residue that's always on the syrup bottle she turns to Tommy with an encouraging smile and asks:
"Tommy, dear, what did you learn in Hebrew school today?"
Tommy looks up warily at first, weighing his words, then lit up with excitement: "We learned about Moses and of
"And what happened? Tell me" his mother encouraged. Tommy's next answer comes out in a torrent of words and gestures:
"Well, Mom, you see Moses got the Jews to the
Tommy blurted all this quickly, hesitating only when mentioning a pillar of fire and cloud. As he concluded his narrative he looked expectantly at his mom, waiting for her reaction. She had gone from incredulous to shocked to being more shocked. After an awkward moment of silence Tommy's mother looked her boy sternly in the eye and asked in an authoritative manner:
"Is THAT what Rabbi Cagan taught you in Hebrew school today??"
Tommy suddenly found something of utmost important in one of his waffles.
"Tommy Katz you look your mother in the eye and answer me!"
Tommy finally looked up and sheepishly answered:
"Nah, ma, he said that God told Moses to stretch out his hand and staff over the sea and it would split: the Jews would cross on dry land, but then the sea would close on the Egyptians," Tommy sheepishly admitted.
"Then why didn't you say so," his mother asked, visibly relaxed now that she'd heard the answer she expected.
Tommy looked up at his mother and pleadingly said: "Because I thought hat if I told you what Rabbi Cagan taught us you'd get mad at me because you wouldn't believe what the rabbi said and you'd think I was making it up".
*********************************************************
I was reminded of this story when at the seder night a guest asked me: "Do you believe the story that the sea split literally or do you think it's allegorical?" I was initially somewhat taken aback at the question and didn't really answer seriously until a day later. The answer is a resounding yes! – Without mitigating explanations.
Some people don't believe man walked on the moon and some people don't believe that miracles – experienced by an entire nation and attested to by a meticulous tradition of story-telling from generation to generation – actually happened. We're only seventy years from the end of WW2 and there are people who have no problem denying that the Holocaust took place; only sixty seven years since the establishment of
If someone came from three thousand years ago and saw a sight such as Tommy initially described to his mother – they would be overwhelmed, because it would be something based on forces and knowledge unknown to the intelligent person of three thousand years ago. So, too, looking back 3,400 years the miracles seem, well, miraculous to us, and they should be, because they are based on a set of rules, laws and powers to which we are not accustomed.